does fine tuning a llm model expand its parameters size?
- User
does fine tuning a llm model expand its parameters size?
- Assistant
No, fine-tuning a large language model (LLM) does not expand its parameter size.
Here's why:
-
Fine-tuning adjusts existing parameters: Fine-tuning involves taking a pre-trained LLM (which already has a fixed number of parameters) and updating the values of those existing parameters based on a new, smaller dataset. The architecture of the model remains the same. You're essentially nudging the model to perform better on a specific task or domain without adding new layers or nodes.
-
Parameter size is determined by the model's architecture: The number of parameters in an LLM is determined by its architecture – the number of layers, the size of the hidden layers, the number of attention heads, etc. These are fixed when the model is initially designed and trained.
-
Alternative: Adapters/LoRA: There are techniques like LoRA (Low-Rank Adaptation) and adapter layers that can be used during fine-tuning which can effectively add trainable parameters but these are added on top of the original model and are typically much smaller than the base model. While these add parameters in a sense, they don't fundamentally alter the base model's architecture or increase the size of the original parameters. Instead, these new parameters (or matrices in LoRA's case) are what's being trained, while the weights of the original model remain largely frozen.
In summary:
Fine-tuning leverages the knowledge already encoded in the model's parameters and refines it. It doesn't grow the model's capacity (parameter count). The model has the same "brain size" (number of parameters), but it becomes better at a specific task.
Think of it like this: a pre-trained LLM knows a lot about language in general. Fine-tuning helps it become an expert in a specific niche without needing to grow its brain.
-
- User
what about pre training on a existing model?
- Assistant
Pre-training on an existing model is a bit of a nuanced case. Here's a breakdown of how it can (and mostly doesn't) affect the parameter size:
Scenario 1: Continuing Pre-training (Most Common)
- What it is: You take an already pre-trained LLM and continue training it on a larger or different corpus of data, using the same training objectives (e.g., masked language modeling, next token prediction).
- Effect on Parameter Size: No change. You are simply further optimizing the existing parameters based on a new dataset. The model architecture, and therefore the number of parameters, remains the same.
- Why it's done: To improve the model's general knowledge, adapt it to a different domain (e.g., training a general-purpose LLM further on scientific text), or address limitations observed in the initial pre-training.
Scenario 2: Expanding the Model During "Pre-training" (Less Common, but Possible)
- What it is: You start with a smaller pre-trained LLM and intentionally increase its capacity (e.g., add layers, increase hidden layer size) while continuing to pre-train it.
- Effect on Parameter Size: Parameter size increases. This is essentially building a larger model from a smaller one.
- Why it's done: This is less common because it's computationally expensive. It might be done if you initially underestimated the required model size or if you want to incrementally scale up a model. In this case, this is not merely a continuation of pretraining but a combination of growing the model and training it.
- Important Note: This would more accurately be described as a hybrid approach: architectural expansion combined with continued pre-training. You're not strictly just pre-training; you're fundamentally changing the model architecture.
Scenario 3: Specialized Modules or Heads
-
What it is: Add task specific heads to the pretrained LLM to make it capable of multiple tasks.
-
Effect on Parameter Size: Increases (slightly). This is similar to adapters, where you are adding new layers to the model and therefore adding new parameters.
Key Takeaway:
The term "pre-training" itself doesn't inherently imply a change in parameter size. It's the process of updating parameters based on a large dataset. Whether the parameter size changes depends on whether you are also modifying the model's architecture during the process. In the vast majority of cases, when people talk about "continuing pre-training" or "further pre-training," they mean optimizing the existing parameters, not expanding the model's architecture. If the architecture is changed (e.g., adding layers), the parameter size will increase.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.