Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

best desktop for ubuntu ver24.04.02 ; make comparisontable between gdm3 and others

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219’s answer.
  1. User

    best desktop for ubuntu ver24.04.02 ; make comparisontable between gdm3 and others

  2. Assistant

    “Best” desktop experience on Ubuntu 24.04 (Noble Numbat)

    There is no single “best” desktop for every user; it depends on what you value most—speed, eye‑candy, workflow philosophy, hardware resources, etc. A quick cheat‑sheet:

    If you value…Grab this DEKey version in 24.04RAM @ idle*Notes
    Ubuntu’s default UXGNOME46.x900–1 100 MBSmooth Wayland session, robust extensions ecosystem.
    Maximum customizationKDE Plasma6.x700–900 MBNew Plasma 6 on Qt 6, per‑pixel scaling, powerful settings.
    Low resource usageXfce4.19450–550 MBClassic panel + whisker menu, very light on older HW.
    Ultra‑light & fastLXQt2.0350–450 MBQt‑based successor to LXDE, snappy on <2 GB RAM machines.
    Windows‑like comfortCinnamon6.2700–900 MBMint’s flagship shell; familiar taskbar, start‑menu feel.
    macOS-ish + modernBudgie10.9600–800 MBRaven sidebar, central notifications, beautiful out‑of‑box theming.

    *Idle RAM is taken from a fresh login on a clean install and can vary ±10 %.

    Feel free to mix & match—the display manager (login screen) you pick is independent of the desktop environment you log into.


    Display Managers: GDM3 vs. the rest

    Below is a side‑by‑side of the four most common login managers you’ll meet on Ubuntu derivatives.

    Feature / DMGDM3 (GNOME)LightDM (X‑DMCP)SDDM (Qt/KDE)LXDM (LXDE)
    Default in…Ubuntu GNOME, Pop!_OSXubuntu, Linux MintKubuntuLubuntu (18.04 era)
    Display protocolWayland and X11X11 (Wayland via lightdm-wayland-greeter — experimental)Wayland & X11X11 only
    Memory footprint*~75 MB~25 MB~55 MB~15 MB
    Themeing engineGNOME Shell CSSGreeter‑based (webkit, slick, unity)QML/QtQuickGTK2
    User switching (fast‑user)YesYesYesNo
    Remote X/Thin‑clientXDMCP, VNC (gdm flexiserver)XDMCP built‑inXDMCPNone
    Accessibility (a11y)High (AT‑SPI)Medium (depends on greeter)High (Qt a11y)Low
    Systemd integrationNativePartial (lightdm.service)NativeNone
    Autologin & guestYes (GUI toggle)Yes (conf file)Yes (GUI)Yes (conf)
    TTY fallback if DM failsDrops to graphical.target → text loginSameSameSame
    Config complexityLow (dconf / gsettings)Very Low (single /etc/lightdm/lightdm.conf)Medium (INI + themes)Very Low
    Best paired DEsGNOME, Budgie, CinnamonXfce, MATE, Cinnamon, BudgieKDE, LXQtLXDE, LXQt
    Wayland on NVIDIASupported (GBM w/NVIDIA 550+)Not recommendedSupportedN/A
    Package namegdm3lightdm + greetersddmlxdm

    *Resident Set Size right after boot, measured via systemd-cgtop.

    Quick take‑aways

    • Use GDM3 if you run GNOME or care about flawless Wayland + fingerprint + smartcard integration.
    • Use SDDM if your main desktop is KDE Plasma 6 or LXQt and you like QML theming.
    • Use LightDM for a lightweight, battle‑tested DM that works with “everything” (plenty of greeters).
    • Use LXDM (or even no DM, just .bash_profile && startx) on ultra‑old machines.


    Which combo should you pick?

    Scenario 1 – Modern laptop, touch‑screen, HiDPI:
    → GNOME 46 + GDM3 (Wayland on by default).

    Scenario 2 – 4 GB RAM netbook, just need browser & LibreOffice:
    → Xfce + LightDM (X11 session).

    Scenario 3 – Power user, three monitors, loves tweaking panels:
    → KDE Plasma 6 + SDDM (Wayland works nicely if GPU is supported).

    Scenario 4 – Minimal home‑server you SSH into 90 % of the time:
    → No display manager; enable systemd‐user linger and startx when needed.


    Installing / Switching DMs

    # Example: switch from gdm3 to lightdm
    sudo apt install lightdm lightdm-gtk-greeter
    sudo dpkg-reconfigure lightdm   # pick default DM
    sudo systemctl reboot
    

    To revert, run the same command and select gdm3. Multiple DMs can coexist; only one is enabled.


    Final recommendation

    For most users on Ubuntu 24.04 the default GNOME 46 + GDM3 provides the smoothest, most future‑proof experience (especially with Wayland becoming the norm). Opt for KDE Plasma 6 + SDDM if customization is your passion, or Xfce + LightDM if you’re resurrecting older hardware.

    Happy tweaking and enjoy Noble Numbat! 🐗

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.