Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
DeepSeekdeepseek-v3-0324· DeepSeekHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

We are writing a comedy, The Greek gods (from before the Trojan War) find a book about…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219’s answer.
  1. User

    We are writing a comedy, The Greek gods (from before the Trojan War) find a book about 21 st new york. Some of them decide to read ,others just ignore it, others just diminish it as madness. They don't have a way to travel to modern New York nor to verify if what the book says is true.

  2. DeepSeek Assistant

    This is a fantastic premise for a comedy! The clash between the ancient Greek gods and the absurdity, chaos, and mundanity of 21st-century New York—filtered only through a book—is ripe for humor. Here’s how you could structure it:

    Title Ideas:

    • Gods Behaving Badly (But in New York)
    • Zeus Reads the New York Times
    • The Iliad vs. The Subway
    • Mount Olympus Book Club

    Key Characters & Their Reactions:

    1. Zeus – Reads the book and is obsessed with the idea of "skyscrapers" (he thinks they’re temples to him). He keeps demanding mortals build him one, not realizing they already have.

      • "A tower that scrapes the sky? Finally, mortals acknowledge my greatness!"
      • "Wait… they built hundreds? For banks?!"
    2. Hera – Reads about divorce rates and female CEOs and is thrilled that women are overthrowing men.

      • "So you’re telling me, Zeus, that in this world, you would be the one paying me alimony?"
    3. Ares – Sees descriptions of modern warfare (drones, nukes) and is horrified that war has become so impersonal.

      • "Where’s the glory? The blood? The screaming? This is just… buttons and radiation!"
    4. Athena – Loves the idea of universities but is furious that students take out loans to learn.

      • "You mean to tell me they pay for wisdom? In my day, I just turned people into spiders for free!"
    5. Dionysus – Reads about nightclubs, influencer culture, and 24-hour partying and declares New York his spiritual home.

      • "They have bars that never close? I must go. I must."
    6. Apollo – Sees modern music (autotune, mumble rap) and has an existential crisis.

      • "This isn’t art! This is… this is… what is this?!"
    7. Hermes – Reads about the internet and is fascinated by the idea of "instant messages."

      • "So mortals finally invented something faster than me? Unacceptable."
    8. Poseidon – Sees a picture of the New York sewer system and is offended.

      • "They built a river of filth beneath their city and didn’t even ask me?!"
    9. Hades – Reads about Wall Street and assumes it’s a new underworld.

      • "Ah, so they do have a place where souls are tormented for eternity. Good for them."
    10. Artemis – Reads about animal rights activists and is torn between approval and outrage at hunting laws.

      • "You can’t hunt deer… but you can keep tiny wolves in your home? MAKE IT MAKE SENSE."

    Potential Plot Beats:

    • The gods argue over whether the book is prophecy, madness, or some mortal trick.
    • Zeus tries to summon a skyscraper to Olympus, accidentally creating a weird, half-formed monstrosity.
    • Dionysus starts a toga-party trend in New York (via vague divine influence), confusing mortals.
    • Hermes keeps stealing the book and leaving fake edits in it (e.g., "Actually, pigeons are sacred messengers of the gods").
    • Ares tries to start a war to "bring back real combat," but the other gods stop him because they’re too invested in the book now.

    Ending Options:

    • The gods still don’t know if the book is real, but they keep arguing about it forever.
    • The book vanishes one day (Hermes took it to mess with them).
    • A mortal (maybe a classics professor) somehow ends up in Olympus, sees them debating NYC, and just says, "You guys are way overthinking this."

    Would you want to lean more into satire, slapstick, or witty dialogue? Any specific gods you’d want to focus on?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.