Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

in amazon kdp, what revenue to expect per month with 700 book coloring books in sub…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219’s answer.
  1. User

    in amazon kdp, what revenue to expect per month with 700 book coloring books in sub niches, with adertising budget 0.221 per click. we would be switchng off loss making campaign if 20 clicks doest yeild single sale. targeting an exact and phrase keywords only (2 keywords only). royality per book is $3.

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Excellent question. This is a very specific scenario, which allows for a detailed mathematical model. However, it's crucial to understand that this will be a projection based on assumptions, not a guarantee. The single biggest factor, which cannot be modeled, is the quality and appeal of your 700 coloring books.

    Let's break this down logically, starting with the math of your advertising strategy and then building out to monthly revenue scenarios.

    Part 1: The Core Math of Your Ad Strategy

    This is the most important part. Your entire strategy hinges on a few key metrics based on the numbers you provided.

    • Royalty per Sale: $3.00
    • Cost Per Click (CPC): $0.221
    • "Kill Switch" Rule: Turn off a campaign after 20 clicks with no sale.

    1. Calculating Your Breakeven Point: To not lose money on an ad-driven sale, your ad spend for that sale must be less than or equal to your royalty.

    • Breakeven Clicks: 3.00(Royalty)/3.00 (Royalty) / 0.221 (CPC) = 13.57 Clicks

    This is a critical number. It means you need to get a sale, on average, every 13-14 clicks to break even.

    2. Analyzing Your "20-Click Rule": Your rule is to stop a campaign at 20 clicks if there's no sale.

    • Cost of a Failed Test: 20 Clicks * 0.221/click=∗∗0.221/click = **4.42**
    • This means for every campaign you test that doesn't work, you lose $4.42.
    • Your rule is logical for data collection, but it's set beyond the breakeven point. You are consciously willing to lose $1.42 on a test to see if a book/keyword combination is a dud. This is a common and valid "data-buying" strategy.

    3. Defining a "Winning" Campaign: A "winning" campaign is one that gets a sale before 13 clicks. For this model, let's define a successful campaign as one with a Conversion Rate (CVR) of 10%.

    • 10% CVR = 1 sale for every 10 clicks.
    • Ad Cost for 1 Sale: 10 clicks * 0.221/click=0.221/click = 2.21
    • Profit per Ad-Driven Sale: 3.00(Royalty)−3.00 (Royalty) - 2.21 (Ad Cost) = $0.79 Profit
    • Advertising Cost of Sale (ACOS): (2.21/2.21 / 3.00) * 100 = 73.6%

    This ACOS is high, but profitable. Many KDP sellers aim for 30-40%, but with a high-volume strategy like yours, a higher ACOS can be acceptable as long as it's profitable and drives organic ranking (the "halo effect").


    Part 2: Monthly Revenue Scenarios

    Now, let's apply this math to your 700 books. The great unknown is: What percentage of your 700 books will become "winners"? This depends entirely on your niche research, keyword selection, and book quality.

    Let's model three scenarios.

    ** Assumptions for all scenarios:**

    • You are running an ad campaign (2 keywords) for all 700 books.
    • A "winning" campaign gets, on average, 1 sale per 10 clicks (10% CVR).
    • A "losing" campaign is turned off after spending $4.42 and generates 0 sales.

    Scenario 1: Pessimistic Outcome

    Only a small fraction of your books are in good niches with good keywords.

    • Winner Rate: 5% of your 700 books are winners.
    • Winning Books: 700 * 0.05 = 35 books
    • Losing Books: 700 * 0.95 = 665 books

    Calculations:

    • One-Time Cost of Failed Tests: 665 books * 4.42/test=∗∗4.42/test = **2,939.30** (This is your initial cost to find the losers).
    • Ongoing Performance of Winners:
      • Let's assume each winning campaign gets 3 clicks per day (low search volume niches).
      • Daily Clicks for Winners: 35 books * 3 clicks/day = 105 clicks/day
      • Daily Sales (at 10% CVR): 105 clicks * 0.10 = 10.5 sales/day (let's say 10)
      • Daily Ad Spend: 105 clicks * 0.221=0.221 = 23.21
      • Daily Revenue: 10 sales * 3.00=3.00 = 30.00
      • Daily Profit (from ads): 30.00−30.00 - 23.21 = $6.79

    Monthly Projection (Pessimistic):

    • Monthly Ad-Driven Revenue: 30.00/day∗30days=∗∗30.00/day * 30 days = **900**
    • Monthly Ad Spend: 23.21/day∗30days=∗∗23.21/day * 30 days = **696.30**
    • Monthly Profit (After Initial Testing): 6.79/day∗30days=∗∗6.79/day * 30 days = **203.70**

    Remember to subtract the one-time testing cost of ~$2,939 from your first month's profit.


    Scenario 2: Realistic Outcome

    Your niche and keyword research is solid, leading to a decent success rate.

    • Winner Rate: 15% of your 700 books are winners.
    • Winning Books: 700 * 0.15 = 105 books
    • Losing Books: 700 * 0.85 = 595 books

    Calculations:

    • One-Time Cost of Failed Tests: 595 books * 4.42/test=∗∗4.42/test = **2,629.90**
    • Ongoing Performance of Winners:
      • Assume each winning campaign gets 5 clicks per day (decent niche volume).
      • Daily Clicks for Winners: 105 books * 5 clicks/day = 525 clicks/day
      • Daily Sales (at 10% CVR): 525 clicks * 0.10 = 52.5 sales/day (let's say 52)
      • Daily Ad Spend: 525 clicks * 0.221=0.221 = 116.03
      • Daily Revenue: 52 sales * 3.00=3.00 = 156.00
      • Daily Profit (from ads): 156.00−156.00 - 116.03 = $39.97

    Monthly Projection (Realistic):

    • Monthly Ad-Driven Revenue: 156.00/day∗30days=∗∗156.00/day * 30 days = **4,680**
    • Monthly Ad Spend: 116.03/day∗30days=∗∗116.03/day * 30 days = **3,480.90**
    • Monthly Profit (After Initial Testing): 39.97/day∗30days=∗∗39.97/day * 30 days = **1,199.10**

    Scenario 3: Optimistic Outcome

    You've done an exceptional job with quality, niches, and keywords.

    • Winner Rate: 30% of your 700 books are winners.
    • Winning Books: 700 * 0.30 = 210 books
    • Losing Books: 700 * 0.70 = 490 books

    Calculations:

    • One-Time Cost of Failed Tests: 490 books * 4.42/test=∗∗4.42/test = **2,165.80**
    • Ongoing Performance of Winners:
      • Assume each winning campaign gets 7 clicks per day (strong niche, good ad relevance).
      • Daily Clicks for Winners: 210 books * 7 clicks/day = 1,470 clicks/day
      • Daily Sales (at 10% CVR): 1,470 clicks * 0.10 = 147 sales/day
      • Daily Ad Spend: 1,470 clicks * 0.221=0.221 = 324.87
      • Daily Revenue: 147 sales * 3.00=3.00 = 441.00
      • Daily Profit (from ads): 441.00−441.00 - 324.87 = $116.13

    Monthly Projection (Optimistic):

    • Monthly Ad-Driven Revenue: 441.00/day∗30days=∗∗441.00/day * 30 days = **13,230**
    • Monthly Ad Spend: 324.87/day∗30days=∗∗324.87/day * 30 days = **9,746.10**
    • Monthly Profit (After Initial Testing): 116.13/day∗30days=∗∗116.13/day * 30 days = **3,483.90**

    The Most Important Factor: Organic Sales

    The model above only calculates ad-driven sales. The entire purpose of Amazon Ads is to create a "flywheel" or "halo effect."

    1. An ad leads to a sale.
    2. That sale improves the book's Best Seller Rank (BSR).
    3. The improved BSR leads to higher organic visibility (showing up on the first page of search results).
    4. Higher organic visibility leads to organic sales, which have no ad cost attached.
    5. Organic Profit per Sale = $3.00 (100% of your royalty)

    Your "winning" books in the scenarios above will start generating organic sales. A truly successful book might get 1 ad sale and 2-3 organic sales per day. This would dramatically increase your total profit. The Realistic Scenario's profit of ~1,200/monthcouldeasilydoubleto∗∗1,200/month could easily double to **2,400-$3,000/month** once organic sales kick in for those 105 winning books.

    Summary & Final Advice

    It is impossible to give you one number, but we can give you a framework. Your monthly revenue from this strategy could plausibly range from 900(Pessimistic)to900 (Pessimistic) to 13,230 (Optimistic), with a realistic target likely in the 4,000−4,000 - 5,000 range.

    Your success will be determined by:

    1. Book Quality: Are the covers and interiors genuinely appealing to the target audience in each sub-niche? A great cover can take your conversion rate from 5% to 15%.
    2. Keyword Research: Your 2-keyword strategy is laser-focused. This is great if they are the right two keywords (e.g., "gothic fairy coloring book"). It's a disaster if they are too broad ("coloring book") or have no traffic.
    3. Budget Management: You must be disciplined in cutting the losers and have the initial capital (~2,000−2,000 - 3,000) to fund the testing phase.
    4. Patience: It will take a month or two for the data to come in, for you to kill the losing campaigns, and for the organic flywheel to start spinning on the winners.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.