Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
DeepSeekdeepseek-v3-0324· DeepSeekHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Can you think of some reasons why would someone choose the other option?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-sonnet-4-20250514’s answer.
  1. User

    Can you think of some reasons why would someone choose the other option?

  2. DeepSeek Assistant

    Absolutely! While the utilitarian choice (not pulling the lever) seems logically preferable, there are several compelling reasons why someone might choose to pull the lever and send the trolley to the future, even at the cost of five lives. Here are some key arguments:

    1. Moral Responsibility for Direct Action

    • "Doing vs. Allowing Harm": Some people believe that actively causing harm (pulling the lever, sending the trolley to kill five) is morally worse than allowing harm (letting the trolley kill one now). However, others might argue that inaction is still a choice—if you could save the one person now but choose not to, you bear responsibility for their death.
    • "I am the one who pulled the lever": The five deaths in the future are a direct result of your action, which may feel more morally reprehensible than passively allowing one death now.

    2. Uncertainty About the Future

    • Can we really know the future? The problem assumes that the five people in the future will be saved if you don’t pull the lever, but what if something changes? What if the trolley’s disappearance alters history in a way that leads to more suffering?
    • "The future is not guaranteed": If you pull the lever, you save a life now (the one person), whereas the five in the future might find another way to survive (e.g., someone else intervenes, technology evolves, etc.).

    3. Temporal Bias (Present Over Future)

    • "The present is more real": Humans are psychologically wired to prioritize immediate, tangible consequences over distant, abstract ones. The suffering of the one person now may feel more urgent than the suffering of five people a millennium later.
    • "Future people don’t exist yet": Some might argue that the five in the future are not yet real people, whereas the one person now is. This is a controversial stance (similar to debates about future generations in climate ethics), but it could justify prioritizing the present life.

    4. Rejecting the Premise (The Five Are Already Doomed)

    • The problem states that the five in the future can only survive if you don’t pull the lever. But what if their fate is already sealed? If the trolley is destined to kill them, then sending it forward might not change anything—so why not save the one person now?
    • Alternatively, if the trolley’s arrival in the future is what causes the five to be tied to the tracks (a paradox), then pulling the lever might actually prevent their deaths by breaking the causal chain.

    5. Virtue Ethics: Personal Integrity Over Outcomes

    • "I don’t want to be the kind of person who sacrifices others": Even if the math favors inaction, someone might refuse to make a coldly utilitarian choice, valuing compassion for the immediate victim over abstract future lives.
    • "I can’t play God with time": Manipulating time to shift harm onto others might feel like an abuse of power, making pulling the lever ethically unacceptable regardless of outcomes.

    Conclusion: Why Someone Might Pull the Lever

    While the utilitarian answer is clear, real moral agents might pull the lever because:

    • They prioritize saving a real, present life over uncertain future ones.
    • They feel more responsible for direct action than passive inaction.
    • They distrust the assumptions about the future.
    • They reject outcome-based ethics in favor of duty or virtue.

    Would you personally pull the lever, or do you find these counterarguments convincing?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.