When we use MJ/mile for cars as a universal metric, aren't we forgetting the cost of…
- User
When we use MJ/mile for cars as a universal metric, aren't we forgetting the cost of electricity transmission versus cost of gas transportation?
Assistant
That's an excellent and critical point! You are absolutely right.
Using MJ/mile strictly as the energy consumed by the vehicle itself (often referred to as "Tank-to-Wheels" for gasoline or "Plug-to-Wheels" for electric) provides a measure of the vehicle's efficiency, but it does not capture the full energy picture.
Here's a breakdown of why this is important:
-
Vehicle Efficiency vs. System Efficiency:
- MJ/mile (Plug/Tank-to-Wheels): Measures how effectively the car converts the energy stored onboard (in the battery or fuel tank) into motion. EVs are inherently much more efficient in this step (typically 70-90%) than Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) vehicles (typically 15-30%).
- "Well-to-Wheels" (WTW) or "Source-to-Wheels" (STW): This is the comprehensive measure that accounts for all energy used from the primary source (crude oil well, coal mine, natural gas well, solar panel, wind turbine) to the vehicle's wheels. This includes extraction, processing, transportation, generation (for electricity), transmission/distribution, and finally, the vehicle's own consumption.
-
Electricity Transmission & Distribution (T&D) Losses:
- Energy is lost as heat when electricity travels through power lines from the generation source to the charging point.
- These losses vary but are typically estimated to be around 5-10% in developed countries, although they can be higher in some areas or under heavy load.
- There are also energy losses during the electricity generation process itself, which vary hugely depending on the source (e.g., a coal plant might be 35-45% efficient, a combined cycle gas plant 50-60%, while solar/wind efficiency is measured differently but has no fuel cost/loss).
-
Gasoline Production & Transportation Losses:
- Significant energy is consumed in:
- Extracting crude oil.
- Transporting crude oil (pipelines, tankers).
- Refining crude oil into gasoline (a very energy-intensive process).
- Transporting gasoline to distribution terminals and then to gas stations (trucks).
- Estimates vary, but the energy losses in getting gasoline from the well to the vehicle's tank are often cited as being around 15-25% of the energy contained in the final gasoline product.
- Significant energy is consumed in:
-
Why the Distinction Matters:
- A simple MJ/mile (vehicle only) comparison makes EVs look dramatically better due to their much higher motor efficiency.
- A full Well-to-Wheels analysis provides a fairer comparison of the total energy required.
- Even with T&D losses and potential inefficiencies in fossil fuel-based electricity generation, EVs often still come out ahead on a WTW basis in many regions. This is because the ~75% energy loss within the gasoline engine itself is so substantial that it often outweighs the upstream losses associated with electricity.
- However, the source of the electricity is crucial. An EV charged primarily by coal power will have a much higher WTW energy footprint (and carbon footprint) than one charged by renewables or nuclear power.
Conclusion:
You are correct to point out the limitation. MJ/mile, when used only for the vehicle's consumption, ignores significant upstream energy costs. For a truly universal and fair comparison of the total energy impact, a Well-to-Wheels (WTW) analysis is necessary, which accounts for both electricity transmission/generation losses and gasoline refining/transportation losses. While MJ/mile (vehicle level) is useful for comparing car efficiency, it doesn't tell the whole energy story.
-
- User
Holistically, it's becomes not THAT bad in a natural gas -> EV energy flow, right? Gas pipes really don't demand much energy per MJ/s (weird metric, i know) of flow.
Assistant
Okay, let's break down the natural gas -> power plant -> grid -> EV pathway holistically, considering energy efficiency at each step. You're right to focus on the pipeline aspect initially.
- Natural Gas Extraction & Processing: Some energy is used, but let's consider this roughly comparable or slightly less energy-intensive than crude oil extraction/transport initially.
- Natural Gas Pipeline Transport: You are absolutely correct here. Transporting natural gas via pipeline is highly energy-efficient. The main energy cost is for compressor stations along the line, but relative to the vast amount of energy (in MJ) being moved, the energy input for transport is small. Significantly more efficient than trucking gasoline or even shipping crude oil over long distances.
- Electricity Generation (Natural Gas Power Plant): This is the major conversion loss step.
- Combined Cycle Gas Turbine (CCGT) plants, which are common and relatively efficient for gas, typically achieve 50-60% thermal efficiency. This means 40-50% of the energy in the natural gas is lost as heat during electricity generation.
- Older or simpler "peaker" gas plants can be much less efficient (30-40%).
- Electricity Transmission & Distribution (T&D): As discussed, losses are typically 5-10% from the power plant to the point of charging.
- EV Charging: Losses occur in the EVSE (charger) and the battery itself during charging, typically around 10-15% combined.
- EV Operation (Plug-to-Wheels): Very efficient, typically 75-85% of the energy from the battery makes it to the wheels.
Putting it Together (Approximate Well-to-Wheels for NG -> EV):
Let's use optimistic/typical numbers for a modern system:
- Start with 100 MJ of Natural Gas energy at the wellhead.
- Assume 2% loss for extraction/processing/pipeline transport = 98 MJ arrives at the power plant.
- Assume 58% CCGT efficiency = 98 MJ * 0.58 = 56.8 MJ of electricity generated.
- Assume 7% T&D loss = 56.8 MJ * (1 - 0.07) = 52.8 MJ arrives at the charger.
- Assume 12% charging loss = 52.8 MJ * (1 - 0.12) = 46.5 MJ stored in the battery.
- Assume 80% vehicle efficiency = 46.5 MJ * 0.80 = 37.2 MJ delivered to the wheels.
Overall Well-to-Wheels Efficiency (NG -> EV) ≈ 37%
Compare to Gasoline ICE (Approximate Well-to-Wheels):
- Start with 100 MJ of Crude Oil energy at the wellhead.
- Assume 20% loss for extraction/transport/refining/delivery = 80 MJ of gasoline energy in the tank.
- Assume 25% average Tank-to-Wheels efficiency for the ICE vehicle = 80 MJ * 0.25 = 20 MJ delivered to the wheels.
Overall Well-to-Wheels Efficiency (Gasoline ICE) ≈ 20%
Conclusion:
Even accounting for the significant energy losses (~40-50%) when converting natural gas to electricity in a power plant, the overall "Well-to-Wheels" energy efficiency of the Natural Gas -> EV pathway (~37%) is substantially better than the traditional Crude Oil -> Gasoline -> ICE pathway (~20%).
Your intuition is partially correct: the transport of natural gas is very efficient. However, the biggest bottleneck is the thermal efficiency limit of generating electricity from heat. Despite this bottleneck, the enormous efficiency advantage of the electric motor over the internal combustion engine still makes the NG->EV route more energy-efficient overall.
So, holistically, using natural gas to power EVs is significantly less bad from an energy efficiency standpoint than using gasoline to power ICE cars. It's not perfect, as there are still large conversion losses, but it's a marked improvement over the incumbent technology.
- User
Of course, the pretty part about PV is that we can reduce the transportation losses. Significantly? Not by that much. But it compounds if every charger has a PV roof, every garage has a PV roof and so on.
Assistant
You've hit on another key advantage of distributed renewable generation like rooftop solar (PV)!
You are absolutely right. Installing PV at or near the point of consumption (like on the roof of a house with an EV charger, or on the canopy of a charging station) directly addresses the electricity Transmission and Distribution (T&D) losses.
Here's the breakdown:
- Eliminating Long-Distance Transmission: When electricity is generated miles away at a large power plant (whether it's natural gas, coal, nuclear, or a large solar/wind farm), it has to travel through high-voltage transmission lines and then lower-voltage distribution networks to reach the end-user. This journey incurs energy losses (typically 5-10%).
- Local Generation, Local Use: PV panels on a home or charging station generate electricity right where it's needed. If an EV is charging while the sun is shining, that solar energy goes directly into the car (via the inverter and charger) with minimal distance traveled, effectively bypassing most or all of the grid's T&D losses for that specific energy.
- "Not by THAT much" - Per kWh Perspective: You're right that saving 5-10% on T&D losses might not seem huge compared to the massive efficiency gains of an EV motor over an ICE engine, or the ~40-50% loss in thermal power generation.
- Compounding Effect - System Perspective: This is where it gets significant.
- Reduced Grid Load: Every kWh generated and consumed locally means one less kWh that needs to be generated centrally and pushed through the grid. This reduces overall grid congestion and wear.
- Aggregate Loss Reduction: If millions of homes and charging points generate even a portion of their own energy, the total reduction in energy lost across the entire grid system becomes substantial.
- Beyond T&D Losses: Critically, local PV doesn't just reduce T&D losses; it also displaces generation from other sources. If that displaced source was a fossil fuel plant (like the natural gas plant we discussed), you are also avoiding the ~40-50% thermal efficiency loss associated with generating that electricity in the first place, plus the upstream energy used for fuel extraction and transport. This is where the truly significant holistic energy savings come from with PV.
In summary:
Local PV directly reduces T&D losses for the energy consumed locally, which is a tangible efficiency gain (5-10%). While perhaps not dramatic on its own compared to other factors, the real power lies in:
- Compounding: The aggregate effect across many installations significantly reduces overall grid losses.
- Displacement: It replaces centrally generated power, often avoiding much larger thermal generation inefficiencies and upstream fuel energy costs associated with fossil fuels.
So yes, widespread distributed PV makes the energy pathway to EVs (and other appliances) considerably more efficient from a "Well-to-Wheels" or "Source-to-Socket" perspective.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.