If the uk were to replace all of the employee paid tax on income (i.e. income tax and…
- User
If the uk were to replace all of the employee paid tax on income (i.e. income tax and national insurance) with a flat income tax, what would the income tax rate have to be to raise the same amount of money? Consider this with and without the no tax paid income limit.
- Assistant
Here’s a back‐of‐the‐envelope way to see how a single flat‐rate income tax would stack up against the current system of Income Tax + Employee National Insurance (NI).
-
Pick a recent UK financial year (FY 2022–23, say).
• Income-Tax receipts: £256 bn
• Employee NI receipts: £153 bn
⇒ Combined “take” from employees ≃ £409 bn -
Estimate the total wage‐bill (all PAYE earnings).
ONS tells us total gross PAYE pay ≃ £1.36 trn in 2022–23. -
Two scenarios:
A) No personal‐allowance threshold (“everyone taxed on £1 of earnings”)
B) Keep the current Personal Allowance (£12 570/yr) as a zero‐tax band
Scenario Tax-base (≈) Required flat rate ≃ A) No allowance (everyone taxed) £1 360 bn 409/1 360 ≃ 30.1 % B) With £12 570 allowance preserved (1 360 − 405) ≃ 955 bn 409/955 ≃ 42.8 % – In (A) you tax every pound at about 30 %.
– In (B) you exempt the first £12 570 (per person), so you’d need roughly 43 % on all earnings above that to hit the same £409 bn.Of course these figures move around a bit if you pick a different year’s receipts or a different allowance population—but as a rule of thumb:
• Flat tax on all earnings → ≈ 30 %
• Flat tax “above £12 570” → ≈ 43 %Let me know if you’d like to tweak any of the assumptions! 😊
-
- User
Include considerations of reductions in people using income tax loopholes and the reduced administrative burden
- Assistant
Below is an updated “back‐of‐the‐envelope” sketch that folds in two dynamic effects of moving to a single flat tax:
- A broader, more compliant base (fewer avoidance/loopholes).
- Lower HMRC admin & collection costs.
—
1. Baseline numbers (FY 2022–23)
• Income-tax receipts: £256 bn
• Employee NI receipts: £153 bn
→ Combined yield ≃ £409 bn
• Gross PAYE pay (taxable base): £1 360 bn
• Personal allowance: £12 570 ≃ £405 bn of “zero band” if everyone claims it2. Static flat-rate requirement
Scenario Tax base (≃) Static flat rate A) Everyone taxed (no allowance) £1 360 bn 409 / 1 360 ≃ 30.1 % B) £12 570 allowance retained £1 360 − 405 ≃ 955 bn 409 / 955 ≃ 42.8 % 3. Dynamic effects
- Better compliance & looser loopholes
• Simplification tends to catch more income in the net; estimate a 5 – 10 bn ↑ in annual yield (≈ 1.2 – 2.4 % on our £409 bn take). - Lower administrative burden
• HMRC currently spends ~£3–4 bn/yr on PAYE/IT/NIC systems & enforcement.
• A truly flat system could trim out complexity (fewer bands, codes, appeals), say a £0.5 – 1 bn saving.
4. Adjusted flat-rate after dynamic gains
Scenario Static rate +5 bn extra yield +10 bn extra yield A) No allowance 30.1 % 29.6 % 29.1 % B) With allowance 42.8 % 42.2 % 41.8 % Notes:
- We’ve converted “extra yield” into a %-point rate reduction by dividing the extra £ by the same tax-base.
- Adding in the £1 bn admin-saving simply offsets £1 bn of required yield, shaving another ~0.1 % off the flat rate in either scenario.
5. Qualitative plus-points
• Fewer avoidance vehicles – e.g. dual-class shares, managed-service companies, pie-invoicing.
• Simplified compliance – payrolls only run one rate; self-assessments slimmed down.
• Transparency & fairness – everyone literally pays “X % of earnings,” no hidden charges.
• Economic incentives – flatter marginal rate could boost hours worked or take-home pay certainty.—
Bottom-line:
– Pure flat tax on all pay: ≈ 30 % (static) ➔ 28.5 – 29.5 % (with dynamic gains)
– Flat tax above £12 570: ≈ 43 % (static) ➔ ≈ 41.5 – 42.5 % (with dynamic gains)Happy to tweak any of the assumptions (e.g. size of compliance bonus, allowance level, base-year yields…)! 😊
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.