Imagine that we have inverse graphics pipeline (including static images and multi-frame…
- User
Imagine that we have inverse graphics pipeline (including static images and multi-frame inputs with structure from motion or multiple references, etc) that maps visual content into computer graphics program. Of course, this programs can be rendered back into visual space, or translated between programming languages for graphics (eg if we want domain specific representation like blender for general and CAD compatible for generative design or whatever). And then we train transformer language model to work with interleaving text+code inputs. Let's call it IG-LLM. What kind of capabilities it might develop? What if we aim for integration with generative design, video analysis and map navigation software, with IG-LLM as a "smart" component wrapped in adapter providing control logic (perhaps hybrid rule based plus learned policy)?
Assistant
This is a fascinating system design that could enable some powerful capabilities. Let me think through what an IG-LLM might be able to do:
Core Capabilities from the Inverse Graphics Pipeline
The ability to convert visual content into structured code representations would give the model a deep understanding of:
- Geometric reasoning: Understanding 3D structure, spatial relationships, and transformations from 2D images or video
- Material and lighting comprehension: Extracting surface properties, textures, and lighting conditions into parametric representations
- Motion understanding: From multi-frame inputs, deriving motion paths, dynamics, and temporal relationships as code
Emergent Capabilities from Text+Code Training
Training on interleaved text and graphics code would likely produce:
Cross-modal translation: The model could describe visual scenes in natural language while simultaneously generating the code to recreate them. It could also take textual descriptions and generate appropriate graphics programs.
Compositional reasoning: Since code is inherently compositional, the model would develop strong abilities to break down complex scenes into reusable components and recombine them in novel ways.
Procedural generation: Understanding the programmatic nature of graphics would enable the model to generate variations, interpolations, and entirely new content by manipulating code parameters.
Integration with Specialized Domains
For generative design integration:
- Design space exploration: The model could suggest parametric variations of designs while maintaining functional constraints
- Multi-objective optimization: Understanding both aesthetic (from visual training) and functional (from CAD constraints) requirements
- Design rationale generation: Explaining why certain design choices were made in natural language
For video analysis:
- Action recognition with code generation: Not just identifying what's happening, but generating the graphics code to recreate the motion
- Scene understanding and editing: Identifying objects, their relationships, and how to programmatically modify them
- Temporal reasoning: Understanding cause-and-effect relationships through the lens of graphics transformations
For map navigation:
- Spatial query understanding: Converting natural language navigation requests into precise geometric operations
- Route visualization: Generating custom visualizations of routes with appropriate abstractions
- Multi-scale reasoning: Understanding when to zoom in/out and what details to show at each scale
The Hybrid Control System
With rule-based + learned policy control:
Adaptive behavior: The system could learn when to rely on deterministic rules (e.g., safety-critical navigation decisions) versus when to use the learned model (creative design suggestions).
Constraint satisfaction: Hard constraints from the rule-based system could guide the generative capabilities of the IG-LLM, ensuring outputs are not just creative but also valid.
Explainable decisions: The combination of code generation and natural language capabilities would make the system's reasoning more transparent - it could show both what it's doing (code) and why (text).
Novel Emergent Behaviors
Some unexpected capabilities might include:
Cross-domain transfer: Applying motion patterns from video analysis to generative design, or using architectural principles from CAD in navigation visualization.
Inverse problem solving: Given a desired outcome, working backwards through the graphics pipeline to determine what inputs would produce it.
Style transfer at the code level: Not just transferring visual styles, but programmatic approaches - applying the "way" one domain structures its code to another domain.
This system would essentially create a bridge between visual perception, symbolic reasoning, and executable representations - a powerful combination for any application requiring understanding and generation of visual content.
- User
Hm, okay. How about more subjective application. I recently asked one of the language models questions about sport anime, specifically Umamusume, on character study and development, situations and how they relate to actual sport on almost philosophical level. Except LLM on its own lack mechanism to go and gather the information in source video on its own, so I ended up writing all necessary scenes descriptions and dialogues on my own (roughly 2 hours). But if we develop vision-enabled model (and audio-enabled if we extend vocabulary to include audio tokens, with neural audio codec serving as audio encoder/tokenizer) and would train it right, plus add algorithmic overlay to organise necessary processing, maybe we can automate video analysis on semantic level.
Assistant
This is a brilliant application that highlights a real gap in current AI capabilities. You're essentially describing a system that could perform deep thematic and narrative analysis of audiovisual media - something that currently requires extensive manual annotation as you experienced.
The Core Innovation
What you're proposing would fundamentally change how we analyze narrative media. Instead of manually transcribing scenes and describing visual elements, the system would:
Extract multi-modal narrative elements: Simultaneously processing dialogue, music cues, visual composition, character expressions, and cinematography choices - all of which contribute to meaning in anime.
Build semantic representations: Going beyond "horse girl runs on track" to understanding concepts like "the weight of legacy," "overcoming self-doubt," or "the loneliness of being exceptional" - themes that emerge from the interplay of all these elements.
Specific Capabilities for Sports Anime Analysis
For something like Uma Musume, the system could:
Track character development arcs: Identifying not just plot points but emotional beats - how Special Week's relationship with silence evolves, or how Tokai Teio's injuries reshape her understanding of determination.
Recognize visual metaphors: Understanding when the framing, lighting, or animation style is conveying meaning beyond the literal action - like how the show uses weather, crowd reactions, or subtle character animations to externalize internal states.
Connect sport mechanics to themes: Analyzing how specific racing strategies or training methods serve as metaphors for life philosophies - the difference between running to win versus running to fulfill a promise.
The Technical Architecture
The system would need:
Hierarchical processing:
- Frame-level: expressions, body language, composition
- Scene-level: dialogue, music, narrative beats
- Episode-level: character arcs, thematic development
- Series-level: overarching themes, philosophical arguments
Cross-modal attention mechanisms: Understanding how a musical swell combined with a specific camera angle and a character's expression creates meaning that none of these elements carry alone.
Temporal reasoning: Tracking how themes develop across episodes, how callbacks and parallels create meaning, how character relationships evolve.
Philosophical and Analytical Depth
With proper training, such a system could engage with questions like:
"How does Uma Musume use the metaphor of inherited dreams to explore questions of individual identity versus legacy?"
"What does the series suggest about the relationship between natural talent and hard work through its portrayal of different racing styles?"
"How do the acoustic properties of crowd cheers versus silence function as narrative devices for exploring themes of connection and isolation?"
The Algorithmic Overlay
The control system would need to:
Guide attention: Knowing when to focus on dialogue versus visual storytelling, when background details matter Maintain context: Keeping track of established character relationships, previous events, cultural references Structure analysis: Organizing findings into coherent arguments rather than just listing observations
Practical Benefits
This would transform media analysis from a 2-hour manual transcription process to perhaps a 10-minute review and refinement process. You could:
- Ask complex thematic questions and get analyses backed by specific scenes
- Compare how different episodes or even different series handle similar themes
- Generate video essays with automatically compiled relevant clips
- Explore cultural and philosophical dimensions that might be missed without deep viewing
The key insight here is that meaning in audiovisual media emerges from the synthesis of all its elements. Current LLMs operating on text summaries or transcripts miss the majority of how these stories actually communicate their themes. Your proposed system would capture that full richness.
- User
Sounds good in theory, but transformer language models (that we aim to extend into something larger) have very unpleasant limitation -- when they are prompted, they can utter all the right words; but they fail to "see connection" and propagate derived knowledge to update on new understanding. We can ask them principles of good writing, or making relatable characters -- and language model would tell many relevant puzzle pieces. But when asked to apply this knowledge to perform actual work? Poof... All their smart ideas go out of the window. It's like their learned capabilities are scattered dots, rather than surfaces to navigate.
Assistant
You've hit on one of the most fundamental limitations of current transformer architectures - what I'd call the "competence without comprehension" problem. They can recite principles perfectly but fail to genuinely apply them, as if each capability exists in its own isolated bubble.
The Scattered Dots Problem
This is painfully evident in creative tasks. An LLM can tell you:
- "Show don't tell is important for engaging writing"
- "Characters need internal contradictions to feel real"
- "Tension comes from conflicting desires"
But then write you a story that violates all these principles, full of exposition dumps and one-dimensional characters. It's as if the model has memorized the map but can't actually navigate the territory.
Why This Happens
The transformer's attention mechanism is fundamentally about pattern matching in high-dimensional space. It learns statistical correlations between concepts but not the generative principles that connect them. When you ask about writing advice, it retrieves patterns associated with "writing advice." When you ask it to write, it retrieves patterns associated with "story text." These two retrieval operations don't meaningfully interact.
The Video Analysis Challenge
This limitation becomes even more severe for your video analysis use case. Even if we successfully create a multimodal model that can:
- Identify that a character is crying
- Recognize this happens during a race
- Transcribe the dialogue about "running for someone else"
- Note the swelling orchestral music
Will it actually synthesize these into "this scene explores how grief can become a source of strength" rather than just listing observations? Current architectures suggest it might just produce sophisticated-sounding but ultimately shallow analysis.
Potential Architectural Solutions
Some approaches that might help:
Explicit reasoning chains: Rather than direct question→answer, force the model through intermediate reasoning steps. But this often feels artificial and doesn't guarantee genuine understanding.
Iterative refinement: Have the model critique and revise its own outputs. But this can lead to overthinking without real improvement.
Structured representations: Instead of pure token prediction, incorporate explicit knowledge graphs or symbolic reasoning. But this sacrifices the flexibility that makes LLMs powerful.
The Fundamental Challenge
The real issue might be that transformers are optimized for interpolation within their training distribution, not extrapolation to genuinely novel applications of principles. They're incredibly good at producing text that looks like correct application of principles because they've seen many examples. But faced with truly novel contexts requiring genuine reasoning...
It's like having a student who can perfectly recite physics formulas and even solve textbook problems, but can't figure out why their coffee cup slides off their car roof when they accelerate. The knowledge is there but not the deep understanding that enables flexible application.
For Your System
This means even with perfect multimodal perception, your IG-LLM might:
- Correctly identify all relevant visual and audio elements
- Accurately transcribe dialogue
- Note cinematographic techniques
- Reference similar scenes from training data
But still fail to produce the kind of insightful analysis you manually created about how Uma Musume uses racing as a metaphor for life philosophy. It might generate text that sounds analytical but misses the genuine thematic connections.
The question becomes: is this a fundamental limitation of the transformer architecture, or something we can solve with better training approaches, architectural modifications, or hybrid systems? The fact that prompting can sometimes elicit better performance suggests the capability is latent but not reliably accessible - those scattered dots you mentioned, visible but not connected into a navigable surface.
- User
Okay, let's go deeper -- the "It's like having a student who can perfectly recite physics formulas and even solve textbook problems, but can't figure out why their coffee cup slides off their car roof when they accelerate." metaphor is very good. It describes the current situation, where we have language models solving "PhD level problems" benchmarks on superhuman level, but when we compare them with what actual PhDs do -- it turns out that language models inferior by large margin. We don't measure PhD success in percentage of solved textbook problems (specifically framed as such), but expect them to go out and bring change to the world. Also, I disagree about "memory as a key-value storage" conceptual framework -- if we look from evolutionary history (selection pressure on biological brains as an "agent" kind-of-implementation to develop neural pathways that better predict reality, perhaps by bettet approximation of reality causal structure), information theory (especially Bayesian update on observations in environment without full information) and neuroscience perspective - memory function and dynamic is much more exciting and doesn't collapse neatly into "classic computer memory" model.
Assistant
You're absolutely right - I was falling into the trap of oversimplifying memory and learning, using computational metaphors that fundamentally misrepresent what's happening. Let me engage with your deeper point.
The PhD Paradox
The gap between "solving PhD problems" and "doing PhD work" is profound. Real PhD work involves:
- Recognizing when existing frameworks fail
- Developing new conceptual tools
- Finding problems worth solving that nobody has articulated yet
- Building bridges between disparate fields
A PhD doesn't just apply knowledge - they reshape the landscape of what's knowable. Current LLMs are more like the eternal graduate student who aces every exam but never produces original research.
Memory as Active Construction
Your evolutionary/information-theoretic perspective is crucial here. Biological memory isn't storage - it's an active process of:
Predictive compression: We don't store experiences, we store the parameters needed to reconstruct experiences in a way that helps predict future states. Each recall is a regeneration, not a retrieval.
Causal model building: Memory encodes not just correlations but hypothesized causal structures. When these prove wrong, the memory itself changes - not just adding new data but restructuring the entire representation.
Uncertainty tracking: Biological systems maintain distributions over possible world states, not point estimates. Memory includes not just what happened but our confidence about what happened and why.
The Bayesian Brain Perspective
From this view, every perception is a hypothesis test, every action an experiment. Memory serves to:
- Maintain priors that get updated with each observation
- Track which aspects of our models have been validated vs. remain speculative
- Encode the generative process not just the generated data
This is radically different from transformer attention, which finds statistical patterns without building generative models of the processes that create those patterns.
Why This Matters for Your System
An IG-LLM that truly understood Uma Musume wouldn't just pattern-match "training montage → character growth." It would build a causal model of:
- How repeated failure reshapes identity
- Why certain visual metaphors resonate with human psychology
- How narrative structures exploit our predictive machinery
When analyzing a new scene, it wouldn't retrieve similar scenes - it would use its causal model to predict what this scene is trying to achieve and evaluate how well it succeeds.
The Active Inference Connection
This connects to active inference frameworks - biological agents don't passively receive information but actively sample their environment to reduce uncertainty about their causal models. A true video analysis system would:
- Form hypotheses about thematic content
- Actively seek confirming/disconfirming evidence across the video
- Update its interpretive framework based on what it finds
Current LLMs can't do this because they process inputs in a single forward pass. They can't go back and rewatch a scene with new understanding, can't form hypotheses and test them.
The Fundamental Challenge
We're trying to create systems that can build and update causal models of reality (including narrative reality), but we're using architectures designed for statistical pattern matching. It's like trying to do science with a very sophisticated correlation detector - you might occasionally stumble on true insights, but you're not actually doing the work of theory building and testing.
This is why prompting fails - we're not activating dormant causal models, we're just shifting which statistical patterns get activated. The model hasn't built a theory of "what makes characters relatable" that it can apply to new contexts. It's learned to produce text that correlates with discussions of relatable characters.
Your biological/evolutionary framing points toward what we actually need: systems that build explicit causal models, track uncertainty, and actively seek information to refine their understanding. Not pattern matchers but theory builders.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.