Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.0-flash-001· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

have a scanned book as pdf, want to straighten it and shrink file size (possible with…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14’s answer.
  1. User

    have a scanned book as pdf, want to straighten it and shrink file size (possible with conversion of images to avif?). scantailor isnt in debian repos

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's break down how to straighten and reduce the file size of your scanned PDF, especially since ScanTailor isn't readily available. We'll explore alternatives and cover converting images to AVIF.

    1. Alternatives to ScanTailor (and workflow)

    Since ScanTailor is not easily available in Debian, we will try an alternative which can be done with free and easily accessible software in Debian.

    • PDFsam Basic (For splitting and merging): A simple tool for splitting the PDF into single pages. This will allow you to process each page individually.

    • ImageMagick (For straightening and basic cleanup): A powerful command-line tool for image manipulation. It can handle straightening, cropping, and basic adjustments.

    • GIMP (For manual straightening, cropping, and more advanced adjustments): A graphical image editor. Good for pages that require manual intervention.

    • OCRmyPDF (For adding searchable text layer and optimization): Excellent for creating a searchable PDF and further optimizing the file size.

    Here's the general workflow:

    1. Split PDF into individual images: This is essential for processing each page independently.
    2. Straighten and Clean Up Images: Use ImageMagick or GIMP to correct skew, crop, and adjust contrast/brightness as needed.
    3. Convert Images to AVIF: Convert to AVIF to reduce file size (optional but highly recommended).
    4. Reassemble into PDF: Combine the processed images back into a PDF.
    5. OCR and Optimize: Use OCRmyPDF to make the PDF searchable and further compress it.

    Detailed Steps

    A. Installation:

    First, let's install the necessary software:

    sudo apt update
    sudo apt install pdfsam-basic imagemagick gimp ocrmypdf
    

    B. Splitting the PDF:

    1. Open PDFsam Basic.
    2. Select "Split."
    3. Choose your input PDF file.
    4. Choose to "Split after every page".
    5. Specify an output directory.
    6. Click "Run". This will create a folder containing individual image files (likely in PDF or PNG format) numbered sequentially.

    C. Straightening and Cleaning Images (Using ImageMagick)

    This is where you'll spend the most time. The best approach is to create a script to automate as much as possible.

    1. Detect Skew:

    ImageMagick can automatically detect the skew angle:

    angle=$(identify -format "%[skew:angle]" page001.png)  # Replace page001.png with your first page
    echo "Skew angle: $angle"
    
    1. Deskew (Straighten) and Crop:

    Based on the detected angle, use ImageMagick to rotate and crop. You'll likely need to fine-tune the parameters for your specific document. Here's an example:

    convert page001.png -deskew 40% -trim page001_straight.png
    
    • -deskew 40%: Deskews the image. The percentage controls the sensitivity of the deskew algorithm. Adjust as needed.
    • -trim: Removes excess border. This often helps after rotating.
    1. Batch Processing (Important!):

    Create a script to process all pages in a directory. Here's a basic example (save this as process_images.sh and make it executable with chmod +x process_images.sh):

    #!/bin/bash
    
    input_dir="input_images" # Directory containing the split PDF pages
    output_dir="output_images" # Directory to store processed images
    
    mkdir -p "$output_dir"
    
    for image in "$input_dir"/*.*; do
        filename=$(basename "$image")
        filename_no_ext="${filename%.*}" # Remove extension
    
        echo "Processing: $filename"
    
        angle=$(identify -format "%[skew:angle]" "$image")
        echo "Skew angle: $angle"
    
        convert "$image" -deskew 40% -trim "$output_dir/${filename_no_ext}_straight.png"
    done
    
    echo "Processing complete.  Check the '$output_dir' directory."
    

    How to use the script:

    • Create a directory named input_images and move all the split image files into it.
    • Run the script: ./process_images.sh
    • The straightened images will be in the output_images directory.
    1. Manual Correction with GIMP (If Needed):

      For pages where the automatic deskew fails, use GIMP:

      • Open the image in GIMP.
      • Use the "Rotate Tool" (Shift+R) to manually adjust the angle.
      • Use the "Crop Tool" (Shift+C) to crop the image.
      • Use "Colors -> Brightness-Contrast" or "Colors -> Levels" to adjust the image's appearance.
      • Export the image, overwriting the original (or saving a new version).

    D. Converting Images to AVIF (and why this is good)

    AVIF provides excellent compression, often significantly better than JPEG or PNG for scanned documents. This will dramatically reduce the final PDF size.

    1. Install AVIF support for ImageMagick (if needed):
      sudo apt install libavif-bin
      
    2. Convert Images to AVIF (using ImageMagick):

    Modify the process_images.sh script to convert to AVIF instead of PNG. The key change is in the convert command:

    #!/bin/bash
    
    input_dir="input_images"
    output_dir="output_avif"
    mkdir -p "$output_dir"
    
    for image in "$input_dir"/*.*; do
        filename=$(basename "$image")
        filename_no_ext="${filename%.*}"
    
        echo "Processing: $filename"
    
        angle=$(identify -format "%[skew:angle]" "$image")
        echo "Skew angle: $angle"
    
        convert "$image" -deskew 40% -trim -quality 60 "$output_dir/${filename_no_ext}.avif"
    done
    
    echo "Processing complete.  Check the '$output_avif' directory."
    
    • -quality 60: Sets the AVIF quality. Experiment with this value. Lower values give smaller files but potentially lower quality. 60 is a good starting point.
    • Change the output directory to something like output_avif.
    • Make sure the input images are in the input_images folder (or adjust the script to point to the correct one).

    E. Reassembling into a PDF

    1. Using ImageMagick:

    ImageMagick can create a PDF from a series of images. Make sure the images are named sequentially (e.g., page001.avif, page002.avif, page003.avif).

    convert output_avif/*.avif output.pdf
    

    This will create a PDF named output.pdf from all the AVIF images in the output_avif directory.

    F. OCR and Optimization with OCRmyPDF

    This is a crucial step to make the PDF searchable and further reduce the file size.

    ocrmypdf --output-type pdf output.pdf output_ocr.pdf
    
    • output.pdf: The input PDF file (the one you created from the images).
    • output_ocr.pdf: The output PDF file (the searchable, optimized PDF).
    • --output-type pdf: Specifies that the output should be a PDF (not a sidecar OCR file).

    Important Considerations and Tips:

    • Image Quality: When converting to AVIF, experiment with the -quality setting. Too low, and the images will look bad. Too high, and you won't see much file size reduction.
    • Intermediate Files: Consider deleting the intermediate PNG or JPG files after you've converted them to AVIF to save disk space.
    • Memory: ImageMagick can be memory-intensive, especially with large images. If you run into memory errors, try processing the images in smaller batches or reducing the image resolution.
    • Scripting: The key to efficiently processing a large number of scanned pages is scripting. Take the time to refine the process_images.sh script to automate as much as possible. You can add error handling, logging, and more advanced image processing steps.
    • Parallel Processing: If you have a multi-core processor, you can speed up the ImageMagick processing by using the parallel command. However, be careful not to overload your system.
    • Experiment: Every scanned document is different. The ideal settings for deskewing, cropping, and compression will vary. Experiment to find what works best for your specific document.
    • Backup: Always work on copies of your original PDF files.
    • Monitor Progress: Use top or htop to monitor CPU and memory usage while the scripts are running.

    This detailed guide should help you straighten, compress, and make your scanned PDF searchable using readily available tools on Debian. Start with a few test pages to get the process right before processing the entire document. Good luck!

  3. User

    its a 2sided pdf

  4. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, handling a two-sided (duplex) PDF adds a few more wrinkles to the process. You need to account for potential differences in skew and alignment between the front and back sides of each page. Here's how to adapt the previous workflow to deal with this:

    1. Splitting the PDF into Individual Pages (as before):

    As before, use PDFsam Basic to split the PDF into individual pages. This will give you files like page001.png, page002.png, page003.png, etc. (or whatever format you choose). Each page image will represent one side of a sheet of paper.

    2. Straightening and Cleaning (The Key Modification):

    • Pair Processing: You must process the front and back pages of each sheet together, or at least keep track of them. The goal is to apply consistent straightening and cropping to both sides.

    • Modified Script: Here's a modified process_images.sh script that takes this into account. It assumes the files are named sequentially (e.g., page001.png is the front, page002.png is the back, page003.png is the front of the next page, and so on).

    #!/bin/bash
    
    input_dir="input_images"
    output_dir="output_avif"
    mkdir -p "$output_dir"
    
    # Function to process a single page
    process_page() {
      image="$1"
      filename=$(basename "$image")
      filename_no_ext="${filename%.*}"
    
      echo "Processing: $filename"
    
      angle=$(identify -format "%[skew:angle]" "$image")
      echo "Skew angle: $angle"
    
      convert "$image" -deskew 40% -trim -quality 60 "$output_dir/${filename_no_ext}.avif"
    }
    
    # Loop through the images in pairs (front and back)
    image_list=($(ls -v "$input_dir"/*.*))  # -v for natural sorting (page001, page002, not page1, page10)
    
    for ((i=0; i<${#image_list[@]}; i+=2)); do
      front_image="${image_list[$i]}"
      back_image="${image_list[$i+1]}"
    
      echo "Processing pair: Front - $(basename "$front_image"), Back - $(basename "$back_image")"
    
      #Process front and back images
      process_page "$front_image"
      process_page "$back_image"
    
    done
    
    echo "Processing complete.  Check the '$output_avif' directory."
    
    • Important Script Changes:

      • ls -v: The script now uses ls -v when creating the image list. The -v option ensures natural sorting of the image filenames. This is absolutely crucial if your files are named with numbers (e.g., page1.png, page2.png, ..., page10.png). Without -v, ls might sort page10.png before page2.png, which will ruin the pairing.
      • Looping in Pairs: The script now loops through the images in increments of 2 (i+=2).
      • process_page Function: To avoid repetitive code.
      • Assumes Even Number of Pages: If you have an odd number of pages, the script will error on the last image. Make sure to have an even number of images (add a blank page if necessary).
    • Skew Angle Consistency: This script assumes that the skew angle is similar for both the front and back sides of the same page. If the skew is significantly different, you'll need a more sophisticated approach (possibly detecting the skew angle separately for each side within the loop and adjusting the convert command accordingly). That would make the script much more complex.

    • Manual Fine-Tuning: Even with this script, you'll likely need to manually inspect the processed images. If the automatic deskew isn't working well for a particular page, you'll need to use GIMP to manually correct it.

    3. Converting to AVIF (No Change Required)

    The AVIF conversion process remains the same (assuming you've modified the process_images.sh script as described above): you process each image (which now represents one side of the page) individually.

    4. Reassembling into PDF (Small Change Required)

    When reassembling, you need to ensure that the images are in the correct order (front, back, front, back, etc.). If you've used the modified process_images.sh script correctly, the AVIF files should be named and ordered correctly.

    convert output_avif/*.avif output.pdf
    

    5. OCR and Optimization (No Change Required)

    The OCRmyPDF step remains the same. It will process the entire PDF and add a searchable text layer.

    Important Considerations for Two-Sided Documents:

    • Paper Alignment: Inconsistencies in how the paper feeds through the scanner are your biggest enemy. If the pages are consistently misaligned or skewed, you'll have a lot of manual work to do.
    • Lighting: Uneven lighting can also cause problems. If one side of a page is darker than the other, it can affect the automatic deskew and cropping.
    • Black Borders: Sometimes, scanning creates annoying black borders around the edges of the page. The -trim option in ImageMagick is designed to remove these, but you may need to adjust the trimming parameters to get the best results.
    • Test Thoroughly: Always test the entire workflow on a small sample of pages before processing the entire document.

    Advanced Scripting (If Needed):

    If you're dealing with a lot of two-sided documents, and the skew and alignment are consistently problematic, you might consider these more advanced techniques:

    • Separate Skew Detection: Detect the skew angle separately for the front and back sides of each page. This will require modifying the script to run the identify command twice for each pair of images.
    • Feature Matching: More advanced image processing techniques can be used to align the front and back sides of the page. This involves identifying common features in the images (e.g., corners of text blocks) and using these features to warp and align the images. This is much more complex and would likely require using a dedicated image processing library (like OpenCV).

    By adapting the workflow and paying close attention to the details of two-sided scanning, you can create high-quality, searchable, and compressed PDFs.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.