Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gpt-4.1-2025-04-14· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

the roi from completing a computer science bachelors degree is arguably the highest…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.0-flash-001’s answer.
  1. User

    the roi from completing a computer science bachelors degree is arguably the highest among all majors today. when did this first happen, and what was the major before this turning point?

  2. Assistant

    Great question! The return on investment (ROI) for a bachelor’s degree in computer science is indeed considered among the highest today, thanks to high starting salaries, strong job growth, and relatively moderate educational costs compared to the payoff.

    When did Computer Science become the top ROI major?

    There is no single, universally agreed-upon year, but the shift happened gradually in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Here’s why:

    • Dot-com boom (late 1990s): Demand for software engineers and IT professionals skyrocketed.
    • Post-2008 financial crisis: Tech jobs rebounded faster and stronger than most other fields.
    • 2010s onward: Tech giants (Google, Facebook, Amazon, etc.) drove up salaries and demand for CS grads.

    By the early 2010s, most ROI studies and salary surveys (e.g., PayScale, Georgetown Center on Education and the Workforce) consistently showed computer science at or near the top for ROI among bachelor’s degrees.

    What was the top ROI major before Computer Science?

    Engineering (especially electrical, chemical, and petroleum engineering) was widely considered the best ROI major before computer science took the lead. Here’s the timeline:

    • 1970s–1990s: Engineering degrees, particularly in petroleum, chemical, and electrical engineering, offered the highest starting salaries and strong job prospects.
    • Business/Finance: In the 1980s and 1990s, business and finance degrees also offered high ROI, especially during the Wall Street boom, but engineering generally edged them out in most ROI analyses.

    Summary Table

    EraTop ROI Major(s)
    1970s–1990sEngineering (petroleum, chemical, electrical)
    Late 1990s–2000sEngineering, rising Computer Science
    2010s–presentComputer Science

    Sources

    In summary:
    Computer science overtook engineering as the top ROI major in the early 2010s, after a gradual rise that began in the late 1990s. Before that, engineering (especially petroleum, chemical, and electrical) was the top ROI field.

  3. User

    name the major in particular. it's not like i can leave college with a degree in general engineering or general business.

  4. Assistant

    Absolutely, you’re right—ROI comparisons are most meaningful at the specific major level.

    Before Computer Science: Which Specific Major Had the Highest ROI?

    Petroleum Engineering is widely recognized as the specific major with the highest ROI before Computer Science took the lead.

    Timeline and Details

    • 1970s–2000s:
      Petroleum Engineering consistently topped salary and ROI lists.
    • 2010s onward:
      Computer Science and related fields (e.g., Computer Engineering) began to match or surpass Petroleum Engineering in ROI, especially as tech salaries soared and the oil industry became more volatile.

    Why Petroleum Engineering?

    • High starting salaries (often $80,000+ right out of college, even in the 2000s)
    • Strong demand (especially during oil booms)
    • Relatively low supply of graduates

    Other High-ROI Majors (historically, but not #1)

    • Chemical Engineering
    • Electrical Engineering
    • Actuarial Science

    Summary Table

    EraTop ROI Major (Specific)
    1970s–2000sPetroleum Engineering
    2010s–presentComputer Science

    In summary:
    Petroleum Engineering was the specific major with the highest ROI before Computer Science took the top spot in the early 2010s.

  5. User

    one mentioned petroleum engineering; another mentioned finance or accounting. defend your choice.

  6. Assistant

    Great follow-up! Let’s compare petroleum engineering and finance/accounting as contenders for the highest ROI major before computer science, and defend why petroleum engineering is the stronger answer.


    1. Salary Data: Petroleum Engineering vs. Finance/Accounting

    Petroleum Engineering

    • Consistently ranked #1 in starting and mid-career salaries in PayScale and NACE reports from the 2000s and early 2010s.
    • Starting salaries: Often 70,000–70,000–100,000+ right out of undergrad, even in the 2000s.
    • Mid-career salaries: Frequently 150,000–150,000–200,000+.
    • Source: PayScale 2010 College Salary Report

    Finance/Accounting

    • Starting salaries: Typically 45,000–45,000–60,000 for new graduates in the 2000s.
    • Mid-career salaries: 80,000–80,000–120,000 for most, with only a small percentage (e.g., investment bankers, partners) earning much more.
    • Source: NACE Salary Survey, 2010

    2. Job Market and Supply/Demand

    Petroleum Engineering

    • Small number of graduates: Fewer programs, less competition.
    • High demand: Especially during oil booms, companies competed fiercely for talent.
    • Job offers: Many students received multiple offers before graduation.

    Finance/Accounting

    • Large number of graduates: Many universities offer these majors.
    • More competition: Entry-level jobs are plentiful, but high-paying roles (e.g., investment banking) are extremely competitive and not representative of the average outcome.

    3. ROI Calculation

    ROI = (Lifetime Earnings – Cost of Degree) / Cost of Degree

    • Petroleum Engineering: High salaries, similar tuition costs to other engineering/business degrees, and strong job placement = very high ROI.
    • Finance/Accounting: Lower average salaries, similar tuition costs, and more variable job placement = lower average ROI.

    4. Historical Rankings


    5. Exceptions and Outliers

    • Finance: Some individuals (e.g., investment bankers, hedge fund managers) can earn extremely high salaries, but these are outliers and not representative of the average finance/accounting graduate.
    • Petroleum Engineering: High salaries are the norm for most graduates, not just a select few.

    Conclusion

    Petroleum engineering is the clear choice for the highest ROI major before computer science, based on:

    • Consistently higher average starting and mid-career salaries
    • Strong demand and job placement
    • Smaller, less competitive graduate pool
    • Consistent top rankings in ROI studies

    Finance/accounting are strong, practical majors, but their average ROI is lower due to lower average salaries and greater competition for the highest-paying jobs.

    In summary:
    Petroleum engineering is the best-supported answer for the highest ROI major before computer science, based on salary data, job market dynamics, and historical rankings.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.