Evaluate the accuracy of this: When a bank gives out a mortage, for every 100 dollars of…
- User
Evaluate the accuracy of this:
When a bank gives out a mortage, for every 100 dollars of mortage it gives out, it needs to put 8 dollars in reserve at the central bank. That means it will need to borrow 108 dollars on the market, so for a credit towards a client, they're is a bigger debit towards a financier... No money is created.
This infact reduces the amount of money in circulation, and forces the bank to borrow from the central bank. This gives the central bank power over the interest rates and that is one of the underpinning principles in the fraction reserve system.
Banks still use the fractional reserve system
Assistant
Okay, let's break this down. The provided text contains several significant inaccuracies and misunderstandings about how banking, mortgages, and money creation work.
Overall Accuracy: Largely Inaccurate.
Here's a point-by-point evaluation:
-
"When a bank gives out a mortgage, for every 100 dollars of mortgage it gives out, it needs to put 8 dollars in reserve at the central bank."
- Partially Inaccurate/Outdated/Misleading:
- Reserve Requirements Vary: The 8% figure is arbitrary. Reserve requirements differ by country and have changed over time. For instance, in the United States, the reserve requirement was reduced to 0% for all depository institutions in March 2020. Other countries like Canada, the UK, Australia, and Sweden also have 0% reserve requirements. Some countries still have them, but the percentage varies.
- Reserves are against Deposits, not Loans Directly: While loans create deposits, the reserve requirement (when it exists) is technically against certain types of deposit liabilities, not directly against the loan asset itself. When a bank makes a loan, it simultaneously creates a deposit in the borrower's account. It's this new deposit that would be subject to reserve requirements.
- Partially Inaccurate/Outdated/Misleading:
-
"That means it will need to borrow 108 dollars on the market, so for a credit towards a client, they're is a bigger debit towards a financier..."
- Incorrect: This is a fundamental misunderstanding.
- If a bank makes a 8 in reserves *against the newly created 108. The 100 deposit (created for the borrower) is a liability. The bank needs to fund the 108.
- Banks fund their lending through various sources: existing deposits, attracting new deposits, equity capital, and borrowing on interbank markets or from the central bank if necessary. But the idea of borrowing 100 loan plus its reserve is incorrect.
- Incorrect: This is a fundamental misunderstanding.
-
"No money is created."
- Fundamentally Incorrect: This is the biggest error. Commercial banks create money (in the form of bank deposits) when they make loans. When a bank approves a 100 from its vault. It credits the borrower's (or seller's) account with $100. This new deposit is new money that didn't exist before. This is a core concept of modern banking. The "money supply" (like M1 or M2) largely consists of these bank deposits.
-
"This infact reduces the amount of money in circulation, and forces the bank to borrow from the central bank."
- Incorrect:
- As stated above, lending increases the amount of money (deposits) in circulation.
- Banks are not automatically "forced" to borrow from the central bank for every loan. They manage their liquidity through various means. Borrowing from the central bank (e.g., at the discount window) is one option, often used as a backstop or for specific monetary policy purposes.
- Incorrect:
-
"This gives the central bank power over the interest rates and that is one of the underpinning principles in the fraction reserve system."
- Partially Correct, but the preceding logic is flawed:
- Central banks do have power over interest rates. They typically achieve this by setting a target for the overnight interbank lending rate (e.g., the Federal Funds Rate in the US) and using tools like open market operations (buying/selling government bonds to influence the supply of reserves in the banking system) and setting the interest rate on reserves (if applicable) or the discount rate.
- The fractional reserve system (or more broadly, the system where banks create credit and hold reserves/settlement balances at the central bank) provides the framework within which the central bank can exert this influence. By controlling the ultimate supply or price of reserves, the central bank influences the cost of funds for commercial banks, which then affects other interest rates in the economy.
- So, the conclusion is somewhat true, but the explanation given in the text for how this happens is incorrect.
- Partially Correct, but the preceding logic is flawed:
-
"Banks still use the fractional reserve system."
- Nuanced:
- If "fractional reserve system" means banks hold reserves that are only a fraction of their deposit liabilities, then yes, this is broadly true. Even with 0% required reserves, banks still hold reserves (balances at the central bank) for payment settlement purposes.
- However, the term is often associated with the "money multiplier" model, which is an oversimplified and somewhat misleading description of how money is created in modern economies. Banks are not primarily constrained by reserves when deciding to lend; they are more constrained by their capital adequacy, creditworthy borrowers, profitability, and overall liquidity management. They lend first, then find the reserves if needed.
- So, while they operate by holding fractions of deposits as reserves, the causal mechanism implied by older fractional reserve textbook models is not entirely accurate for how modern banking works.
- Nuanced:
Summary of Inaccuracies:
- Money Creation: The biggest error is the claim that "no money is created." Banks create money when they lend.
- Borrowing Mechanics: The idea that a bank needs to borrow 100 loan due to an $8 reserve is incorrect.
- Impact on Money Supply: Lending increases, not reduces, money in circulation.
- Reserve Requirement Details: The 8% is arbitrary, and in some major economies, the requirement is 0%.
The statement understands that central banks influence interest rates and that reserves play a role, but its understanding of the mechanics of bank lending, money creation, and reserve management is flawed.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.