Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Mistralmistral-medium-2505· Mistral AIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

whats a game that has dismantling for shards as a mechanic, and can roll for rare gear,…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Googlegemma-3-27b-it’s answer.
  1. User

    whats a game that has dismantling for shards as a mechanic, and can roll for rare gear, ults? online multiplayer

  2. Mistral Assistant

    If you're looking for an online multiplayer game with dismantling for shards as a core mechanic, random gear rolls, and ultimate abilities (ults), here are some great options:

    1. Warframe

    • Dismantling for Shards: You can dismantle (sell) unwanted gear for credits or resources.
    • Random Gear Rolls: Mods (which enhance gear) drop randomly and can be upgraded.
    • Ultimate Abilities: Each Warframe has unique ultimate abilities (e.g., Excalibur’s Exalted Blade).
    • Online Multiplayer: Co-op PvE missions with up to 4 players.
    • Free-to-Play: Available on PC, PlayStation, Xbox, and Nintendo Switch.

    2. Destiny 2

    • Dismantling for Shards: Unwanted gear can be dismantled for Legendary Shards, Enhancement Cores, and other materials.
    • Random Gear Rolls: Weapons and armor have randomized perks (though some are fixed in newer expansions).
    • Ultimate Abilities: Each class has a powerful Super ability (e.g., Titan’s Fists of Havoc).
    • Online Multiplayer: PvE (raids, strikes) and PvP (Crucible).
    • Free-to-Play (with expansions): Available on PC, PlayStation, Xbox.

    3. The Division 2

    • Dismantling for Shards: Unwanted gear can be broken down for crafting materials.
    • Random Gear Rolls: Loot has randomized stats and talents.
    • Ultimate Abilities: Skills like Seeker Mines or Turret act as powerful cooldown-based abilities.
    • Online Multiplayer: Co-op PvE and PvP (Dark Zone).
    • Buy-to-Play: Available on PC, PlayStation, Xbox.

    4. Borderlands 3

    • Dismantling for Shards: Unwanted gear can be sold for cash or broken down for parts.
    • Random Gear Rolls: Weapons have randomized stats, elements, and anointments.
    • Ultimate Abilities: Each Vault Hunter has a unique Action Skill (e.g., Amara’s Phasegrasp).
    • Online Multiplayer: Co-op PvE with up to 4 players.
    • Buy-to-Play: Available on PC, PlayStation, Xbox.

    5. Diablo IV (or Diablo III)

    • Dismantling for Shards: Salvaging gear gives crafting materials.
    • Random Gear Rolls: Loot has randomized stats and affixes.
    • Ultimate Abilities: Classes have powerful cooldown-based skills (e.g., Barbarian’s Call of the Ancients).
    • Online Multiplayer: Co-op PvE and PvP (in Diablo IV).
    • Buy-to-Play (Diablo IV) / Free-to-Play (Diablo Immortal): Available on PC, PlayStation, Xbox.

    Best Pick Based on Your Criteria:

    • For deep loot mechanics & co-op: Warframe or Destiny 2
    • For RPG-style loot & abilities: The Division 2 or Diablo IV
    • For chaotic fun & randomized guns: Borderlands 3

    Would you like recommendations based on a specific platform or playstyle?

  3. User

    narrow it down since it also has something to do with arrows and crits

  4. Mistral Assistant

    If you're looking for a game that combines:

    • Dismantling for shards
    • Random gear rolls (including crits)
    • Ultimate abilities (ults)
    • Online multiplayer
    • And has mechanics related to arrows or archery

    Here are the best matches from your list, narrowed down:

    1. Destiny 2 (Best Overall Fit)

    • Dismantling for Shards: Break down gear for Legendary Shards, Enhancement Cores, etc.
    • Random Gear Rolls: Weapons can roll with crit-based perks (e.g., Kill Clip, Rampage, Frenzy).
    • Ultimate Abilities: Each class has a powerful Super (e.g., Hunter’s Golden Gun or Deadshot for precision crits).
    • Arrows & Archery: The Hunter class has a bow-based Super (Silence & Squall in Stasis) and exotic bows like Le Monarque (poison arrows) or Ticuu’s Divination (explosive crit arrows).
    • Online Multiplayer: PvE (raids, dungeons) and PvP (Crucible).
    • Platforms: PC, PlayStation, Xbox.

    2. Warframe (Great for Archery & Crits)

    • Dismantling for Shards: Sell mods/gear for credits or resources.
    • Random Gear Rolls: Mods and Rivens (weapon upgrades) can roll crit-based stats.
    • Ultimate Abilities: Warframes have powerful abilities (e.g., Ivara’s Artemis Bow ult).
    • Arrows & Archery: Ivara is a bow-focused Warframe with stealth and crit-based abilities.
    • Online Multiplayer: Co-op PvE (up to 4 players).
    • Platforms: PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Nintendo Switch.

    3. The Division 2 (Tactical Archer Builds Possible)

    • Dismantling for Shards: Break down gear for crafting materials.
    • Random Gear Rolls: Weapons can roll with crit chance/damage.
    • Ultimate Abilities: Skills like Turret or Seeker Mine (not exactly "ults" but powerful cooldowns).
    • Arrows & Archery: Not a primary focus, but you can use bow-like weapons (e.g., crossbows in mods).
    • Online Multiplayer: Co-op PvE and PvP (Dark Zone).
    • Platforms: PC, PlayStation, Xbox.

    Best Pick for You:

    • If you want a deep looter-shooter with bows & crits: Destiny 2 (Hunter class + bows).
    • If you prefer a sci-fi ninja-archer experience: Warframe (Ivara).
    • If you like tactical cover-based shooters with some archery: The Division 2 (less focus on bows).

    Would you like a recommendation based on a specific playstyle (e.g., PvP vs. PvE, free-to-play vs. paid)?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.