Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

A constant-value resistor is connected in series with a sliding varistor (whose…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-3-preview-02-24’s answer.
  1. User

    A constant-value resistor is connected in series with a sliding varistor (whose resistance is proportional to its length). Its electric power is 0.8 W when the resistance of the sliding varistor is half its maximum resistance, and 0.9 W when the resistance of the sliding varistor is at its maximum resistance.What is the electric power of the constant-value resistor in the first case?

    (Circuit environment is ideal) (Translated, some description may be inaccurate) (The answer cannot be given directly, and there must be a process of calculation)

  2. Assistant

    Step 1 – decide what stays constant
    If the supply were a constant-voltage source, raising the total resistance (from R+Rm/2 to R+Rm) would make the total power fall, not rise from 0.8 W to 0.9 W.
    Therefore the circuit must be fed by a constant-current source I, so that

         P = I² · Rtotal
    

    Step 2 – write the two power equations
    Call the fixed resistance R and let Rm be the maximum value of the sliding resistor.

    Case 1 (slider at ½ Rm) Rtotal,1 = R + Rm/2
    I² ( R + Rm/2 ) = 0.8 (1)

    Case 2 (slider at Rm) Rtotal,2 = R + Rm
    I² ( R + Rm ) = 0.9 (2)

    Step 3 – eliminate I² and Rm
    Subtract (1) from (2):

        I² ( R + Rm ) – I² ( R + Rm/2 ) = 0.9 – 0.8  
        I² ( Rm/2 ) = 0.1                           →         I² Rm = 0.2       (3)
    

    Insert (3) into (2):

        I² ( R + Rm ) = 0.9  
        I² R + I² Rm = 0.9  
        I² R + 0.2    = 0.9               (from 3)  
        I² R = 0.7                                                (4)
    

    Step 4 – power in the fixed resistor in case 1
    Power in R is always PR = I²R, and from (4)

                        PR = 0.7 W
    

    Answer: the constant-value resistor dissipates 0.7 watts when the sliding resistor is set to half of its maximum value.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.