Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Claudeclaude-3-5-sonnet-20241022· AnthropicHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

1. At the start of the game all players are given a number of tokens, the number of…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o3-2025-04-16’s answer.
  1. User
    1. At the start of the game all players are given a number of tokens, the number of tokens can’t increase the during the game
    2. When you die you immediately drop all tokens, dead players can’t own tokens. The dropped tokens stay in game
    3. A living player can spend 1 token to revive a player, the player is revived with 0 tokens. The token spent is removed form the game
    4. Players can trade tokens for anything, including agreements or nothing at all
    5. No agreements are binding
    6. The only use for tokens outside of trades and leverage is revivals, they do not improve your abilities
    7. First player alive alone wins

    The two main strategies are focused around.

    1. Reviving others
    2. Being revived

    What parts of the main game (the parts not listed in my list like how fighting works and stuff like that) does each strategy need to be skilled in to succeed

    This is a harder question than it seems so you should think for a while.

    End your response by saying which one requires more combat skill.

  2. Claude Assistant

    Let me think about this step by step:

    Strategy 1 - Focused on Reviving Others:

    • Must be highly skilled at survival/defense to keep their tokens safe
    • Needs good positioning to avoid being targeted while maintaining ability to reach corpses
    • Combat skill needed but primarily defensive/evasive
    • Must be good at reading the game state to know when to revive (not wasting tokens on someone who'll die immediately)
    • Requires strong negotiation skills to make alliances and avoid being targeted
    • Needs map awareness to track where bodies and tokens are

    Strategy 2 - Focused on Being Revived:

    • Must excel at aggressive combat to be worth reviving
    • Needs to be very good at quick positioning after revival (you're vulnerable with 0 tokens)
    • Has to be skilled at immediate threat assessment upon revival
    • Must be excellent at creating chaos/pressure to make others want to revive you
    • Requires strong social skills to convince others you're worth the token investment
    • Needs good timing sense to die in situations where revival is likely

    The strategy focused on being revived requires more combat skill. This is because when you're revived, you have zero tokens and must immediately prove your worth through pure combat ability. You can't rely on having tokens as leverage or bargaining chips - your only value is your fighting capability. Additionally, you need to be good enough at combat that others see you as worth spending their precious tokens on.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.