Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
grok-3-preview-02-24· xAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Why is heating up a closed glass jar in a pot of boiling water a better method to open…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Mistralmagistral-medium-2506’s answer.
  1. User

    Why is heating up a closed glass jar in a pot of boiling water a better method to open it than banging it?

  2. Assistant

    Short answer

    Heating a closed glass jar in boiling water is better than banging it because heat expands the metal lid, loosening its grip on the jar, and can also reduce the internal vacuum pressure, making it easier to open without risking damage to the jar or injury. Banging the jar, on the other hand, can crack the glass, deform the lid, or even cause the jar to shatter, making it harder to open and potentially dangerous.


    What's going on step-by-step?

    Heating in Boiling Water

    StepWhat happensPhysics involved
    1You place the closed glass jar in a pot of boiling water (100°C).• Heat transfer: thermal energy flows from the hot water to the cooler jar and lid via conduction and convection.
    2The metal lid heats up faster than the glass jar because metal has a higher thermal conductivity and a higher coefficient of thermal expansion.• Thermal expansion: the metal lid expands more than the glass jar, slightly increasing the lid’s diameter and loosening its seal on the jar.
    3The air and contents inside the jar also heat up, increasing the internal pressure.• Ideal gas law (PV = nRT): as temperature (T) increases, pressure (P) inside the jar increases, partially counteracting the vacuum seal created during the jar’s original sealing process.
    4The combination of the expanded lid and reduced vacuum makes the lid easier to twist off.• Mechanics: the frictional force between the lid and jar is reduced due to the loosened fit and weakened vacuum seal.

    Banging the Jar

    StepWhat happensPhysics involved
    1You bang the jar or lid against a hard surface or strike it with an object.• Mechanics: impact forces are applied to the jar or lid, potentially deforming the lid or breaking the vacuum seal.
    2The impact may slightly deform the metal lid, temporarily breaking the vacuum seal by allowing air to enter.• Material stress: the lid’s metal may yield under the force, but this can also damage the lid’s threads or seal, making future use less effective.
    3If the impact is too strong, the glass jar may crack or shatter, especially if it strikes at a weak point or has microfractures.• Brittle fracture: glass is brittle and prone to sudden failure under high stress or impact, unlike ductile materials like metal.
    4Even if the jar opens, the process risks injury (from broken glass) or damage (to the jar or lid), and it may not work if the vacuum seal is particularly strong.• Risk assessment: the method is less controlled and more likely to cause harm or failure compared to heating.

    Why Heating is Better Than Banging

    1. Effectiveness

      • Heating: Reliably loosens the lid by expanding the metal and reducing the vacuum seal, making it easier to open without excessive force.
      • Banging: May not work if the vacuum seal is strong, and even if it does, it often requires multiple attempts, increasing the risk of damage.
    2. Safety

      • Heating: Controlled and safe if done properly (e.g., avoiding thermal shock by not submerging a cold jar directly into boiling water). No risk of broken glass or injury.
      • Banging: High risk of cracking or shattering the glass, deforming the lid, or causing injury from sharp edges or flying debris.
    3. Preservation

      • Heating: Preserves the integrity of the jar and lid for future use, as it doesn’t cause physical damage.
      • Banging: Can damage the lid’s threads or seal, making it harder to reseal the jar properly, and may render the jar unusable if it cracks.
    4. Physics Advantage

      • Heating: Leverages thermal expansion and pressure changes, which are predictable and work in harmony with the jar’s design (e.g., metal lids are designed to expand slightly when heated during the canning process).
      • Banging: Relies on brute force, which is less precise and more likely to exceed the material strength of the glass or lid, leading to failure.

    How to Safely Heat a Jar to Open It

    • Gradual Heating: Place the jar in warm water and gradually bring it to a boil to avoid thermal shock, which could crack the glass.
    • Lid Focus: Submerge only the lid area in the water, keeping the rest of the jar out to minimize stress on the glass.
    • Use Protection: Use tongs or a cloth to handle the hot jar and lid to avoid burns.
    • Cool Down if Needed: If the jar doesn’t open easily, let it cool slightly before trying again to avoid excessive pressure buildup.

    Key Takeaways

    • Heating a jar in boiling water is better because it uses thermal expansion and pressure changes to loosen the lid safely and effectively, without damaging the jar or lid.
    • Banging a jar is riskier, less effective, and more likely to cause injury or damage due to the brittle nature of glass and the unpredictability of impact forces.
    • Always prioritize safety and preservation of the jar by choosing the heating method over brute force.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.