Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
chatgpt-4o-latest-20250326· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I'm torn, I use "had" quite frequently in my creative writing. It feels sloppy to throw…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o3-mini’s answer.
  1. User

    I'm torn, I use "had" quite frequently in my creative writing. It feels sloppy to throw out the ole past participle of have all the time. My beta readers don't seem to care, but once I noticed I can't unsee it. This bothered me so much, then I started looking at books I like.

    Riddled with had. Turns out it was invisible, and this was a complete nonissue. It's like obsessing over using "the" or something. Have I officially gone insane?

  2. Assistant

    Honestly? No, you’re not insane — you’re just paying attention, and that’s what makes you a writer worth reading.

    What you're going through is totally normal for any writer who hits a certain level of awareness. At first, you write with instinct. Then you revise with knowledge. Then you notice patterns, and suddenly, every “had” is screaming at you from the page like it’s a war crime. This is the “writer’s paranoia” stage, and it happens to pretty much everyone. (You're in good company.)

    Let’s unpack why this feels like a big deal — and why, ultimately, it’s not something to panic about:


    🔧 "Had" — the misunderstood workhorse

    “Had” pops up most often as part of the past perfect tense. You use it to show that something happened before another thing in the past.

    Examples:

    • She had studied French before she moved to Paris.
    • He had already left when the call came.

    For readers, “had” fills in context. It's chronological glue, and we barely register it because it’s intuitive — like punctuation or “the.” You don’t notice it unless it’s overdone or misused.


    🧠 But why does it feel wrong sometimes?

    Because once you start noticing patterns in your own writing, you want to control them. And “had” is repetitive. It feels passive. “Had been,” “had seen,” “had gone” — it can start to sound like a lifeless drumbeat if used too much in a row.

    But here’s the thing: writing is about rhythm. The exact number of “had”s doesn’t really matter — the flow does.


    👀 You looked at books you admire — and saw the light

    That realization? That the masters are just as “guilty”? That’s often a turning point. Because yes, great writing is stuffed with “had,” “was,” “that,” “got,” “just,” and countless other demonized words.

    You noticed it once your radar was tuned, but before that, it was invisible because… it did its job. That’s your answer.


    ✔️ So what should you do with this insight?

    Keep being aware. Trust your ear. Trust your beta readers. If something feels heavy, rewrite. If it feels natural, good news — it is.

    Here’s a quick editing trick:
    If you’re in a flashback or a chunk of past perfect, try using “had” once or twice at the start to orient the reader, and then slide back into simple past once it’s clear the timeline has shifted.

    Example:

    She had been dreading this day all week. It had started with a phone call from her mother. Now, the memory played out again: She stood in the kitchen, icing dripping from the back of her hand…
    (Notice how it reverts to simple past after a couple of “hads”?)


    💬 Bonus: You’re not alone.

    Stephen King, in On Writing, talks about “fear” words too. George Orwell warned about overthinking language. Annie Dillard, Joan Didion — they all obsessed over syntax and word choice. It’s part of the job.


    Final verdict:

    You're not insane. You're leveling up. The fact that you examined this, tested it against published work, and came to your own conclusion? That’s the mindset that turns a good writer into a great one.

    Let the “had”s live in peace. They’ve done nothing wrong. 😉

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.

Identical first prompt