Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

What are the chances of rolling to a total cumulative value of 20 or higher with a d4…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct’s answer.
  1. User

    What are the chances of rolling to a total cumulative value of 20 or higher with a d4 dice if you keep rolling if you land a 2 or higher.

  2. Qwen Assistant

    To determine the probability of rolling a total cumulative value of 20 or higher using a d4 (four-sided die), with the rule that you continue rolling if you roll a 2, 3, or 4, and stop when you roll a 1, we need to model the process as a random walk that terminates when a 1 is rolled.


    Understanding the Process

    Each roll of the die results in:

    • 1 (with probability 1/4): the game ends, and the total includes this 1.
    • 2, 3, or 4 (each with probability 1/4): the game continues, and the value is added to the total.

    This means the total sum S is the sum of all die rolls until the first 1 is rolled, including the final 1.

    We are asked to compute:

    P(S≥20)P(S \geq 20)

    Reformulating the Problem

    Let’s define:

    • Z=sum of all rolls before the final 1Z = \text{sum of all rolls before the final 1}
    • Then, S=Z+1S = Z + 1

    So, the problem becomes:

    P(S≥20)=P(Z≥19)P(S \geq 20) = P(Z \geq 19)

    We can now define a recursive function Q(k)=P(Z≥k)Q(k) = P(Z \geq k), which satisfies the recurrence:

    Q(k)=14Q(k−2)+14Q(k−3)+14Q(k−4)Q(k) = \frac{1}{4} Q(k - 2) + \frac{1}{4} Q(k - 3) + \frac{1}{4} Q(k - 4)

    with the base condition:

    Q(k)=1for k≤0Q(k) = 1 \quad \text{for } k \leq 0

    This recurrence arises from the fact that each roll of 2, 3, or 4 (each with probability 1/4) adds that value to the total and continues the process.


    Computing the Desired Probability

    We compute Q(k)Q(k) for k=1k = 1 to 1919 using the recurrence above. After performing the recursive computation step-by-step, we find:

    Q(19)=1557551048576≈0.1485Q(19) = \frac{155755}{1048576} \approx 0.1485

    Thus, the probability that the total cumulative value S=Z+1≥20S = Z + 1 \geq 20 is:

    0.1485\boxed{0.1485}

    Final Answer

    The probability of rolling to a total cumulative value of 20 or higher under the given rules is approximately:

    0.1485\boxed{0.1485}
  3. User

    Another LLM gave this as a reponse:

    Let's compute (W 0 ​ +⋯+W 18 ​ ) using the calculated values: W 0 ​ =1 W 1 ​ =0 W 2 ​ =1/4 W 3 ​ =1/4 W 4 ​ =1/4 W 5 ​ =1/8 W 6 ​ =3/16 W 7 ​ =5/32 W 8 ​ =9/64 W 9 ​ =15/128 W 10 ​ =31/256 W 11 ​ =53/512 W 12 ​ =97/1024 W 13 ​ =175/2048 W 14 ​ =327/4096 W 15 ​ =581/8192 W 16 ​ =1065/16384 W 17 ​ =1935/32768 W 18 ​ =3535/65536

    Let's sum these numerators and divide by the common denominator if we align them to the largest denominator (65536).

    Sum of W k ​ numerators (adjusted to common denominator): W 0 ​ =65536/65536 W 1 ​ =0 W 2 ​ =16384/65536 W 3 ​ =16384/65536 W 4 ​ =16384/65536 W 5 ​ =8192/65536 W 6 ​ =12288/65536 W 7 ​ =10240/65536 W 8 ​ =9216/65536 W 9 ​ =7680/65536 W 10 ​ =7936/65536 W 11 ​ =6784/65536 W 12 ​ =6176/65536 W 13 ​ =5600/65536 W 14 ​ =5232/65536 W 15 ​ =4648/65536 W 16 ​ =4260/65536 W 17 ​ =3870/65536 W 18 ​ =3535/65536

    Sum of numerators: 65536+0+16384+16384+16384+8192+12288+10240+9216+7680+7936+6784+6176+5600+5232+4648+4260+3870+3535=194305

    So, ∑ k=0 18 ​ W k ​ =194305/65536.

    Now, P(S<20)=(∑ k=0 18 ​ W k ​ )/4=(194305/65536)/4=194305/262144.

    Finally, the probability of rolling 20 or higher is: P(S≥20)=1−P(S<20) P(S≥20)=1−(194305/262144) P(S≥20)=(262144−194305)/262144 P(S≥20)=67839/262144

    Let's convert this to a decimal: 67839/262144≈0.25877

    Therefore, the chances of rolling a cumulative sum of 20 or higher are approximately 25.88%.

    Thoughts?

  4. Qwen Assistant

    The discrepancy between the two answers arises from differences in the modeling approach and recurrence definitions. Here's a breakdown of the correct analysis and why the other LLM's result is incorrect:


    Correct Approach

    We define Q(k)=P(Z≥k)Q(k) = P(Z \geq k), where ZZ is the cumulative sum before rolling a 1. The recurrence relation for Q(k)Q(k) is:

    Q(k)=14[Q(k−2)+Q(k−3)+Q(k−4)],for k>0,Q(k) = \frac{1}{4} \left[ Q(k-2) + Q(k-3) + Q(k-4) \right], \quad \text{for } k > 0,

    with Q(k)=1Q(k) = 1 for k≤0k \leq 0. This accounts for the fact that each roll of 2, 3, or 4 (each with probability 14\frac{1}{4}) adds to the total and continues the process.

    Computation of Q(19)Q(19): Using the recurrence, we compute Q(k)Q(k) iteratively from k=1k = 1 to k=19k = 19. The final value is:

    Q(19)≈0.1483⇒P(S≥20)=Q(19)≈14.85%.Q(19) \approx 0.1483 \quad \Rightarrow \quad P(S \geq 20) = Q(19) \approx \boxed{14.85\%}.

    Why the Other LLM's Answer Is Incorrect

    The other LLM defined WkW_k as the number of "ways" to reach sum kk, then summed these values and normalized. However, this approach fails to correctly model the probabilistic nature of the process. Key issues include:

    1. Misinterpretation of WkW_k:

      • The LLM treated WkW_k as counts of sequences, but probabilities require weighting by (1/4)n(1/4)^n for sequences of length nn. Their values (e.g., W2=1/4W_2 = 1/4) do not align with the correct probabilities derived from the recurrence.
    2. Incorrect Normalization:

      • The LLM summed W0W_0 to W18W_{18}, divided by 4, and subtracted from 1 to get P(S≥20)P(S \geq 20). This normalization does not properly account for the geometric distribution of the number of rolls or the decreasing probabilities of longer sequences.
    3. Recurrence Error:

      • The LLM's recurrence for WkW_k did not include the necessary 14\frac{1}{4} factor for each roll, leading to inflated probabilities. For example, their value W2=1/4W_2 = 1/4 should correspond to P(Z=2)=1/16P(Z=2) = 1/16 in the correct model.

    Conclusion

    The correct probability of rolling a cumulative sum of 20 or higher is approximately 14.85%, derived from the recurrence relation for Q(k)Q(k). The other LLM's result of 25.88% is incorrect due to flawed assumptions in modeling the probabilities and improper normalization.

    Final Answer:

    14.85%\boxed{14.85\%}

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.