Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Tell me about how much would it cost to build a 129 story building in downtown Edmonton…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Qwenqwen3-30b-a3b’s answer.
  1. User

    Tell me about how much would it cost to build a 129 story building in downtown Edmonton alberta.

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Building a 129-story skyscraper in downtown Edmonton, Alberta, would be an unprecedented, monumentally complex, and extraordinarily expensive undertaking. It would be one of the tallest buildings in the world (a "megatall" skyscraper, exceeding 600 meters or nearly 2,000 feet), far surpassing anything currently existing or planned in Canada.

    Given the scale, unique challenges, and Edmonton's market, providing an exact figure is impossible without detailed architectural, engineering, and financial studies. However, we can break down the likely cost components and provide a very broad speculative estimate.

    Key Factors Influencing the Cost:

    1. Building Type & Use:

      • Mixed-Use (Most Likely): Typically a combination of residential (condos, luxury apartments), office space, retail, and possibly a hotel. This is the most financially viable model for such a large structure.
      • Luxury vs. Standard Finishes: High-end materials, custom designs, and state-of-the-art technology significantly increase costs.
    2. Gross Floor Area (GFA):

      • Assuming an average floor plate of 15,000-25,000 sq ft (common for tall towers with large cores), a 129-story building could have a GFA of 2 million to 3.25 million square feet. This is a massive amount of space.
    3. Location & Land Costs:

      • Downtown Edmonton has prime land, but a footprint for such a tower would require significant acquisition, possibly even assembling multiple parcels.
      • Land Acquisition: Could range from 50millionto50 million to 200 million+ CAD, depending on the specific site and existing structures.
    4. Structural Engineering & Foundations:

      • This is where a supertall/megatall building differentiates itself. Extreme wind loads, seismic considerations (even moderate), and the sheer weight require innovative and incredibly robust structural systems (e.g., concrete core, steel framing, outriggers, tuned mass dampers for sway control).
      • Edmonton's soil conditions (clay, till) would require deep and extensive piling/foundations, potentially adding significant cost.
    5. Specialized Systems:

      • Elevators: High-speed, multi-zone, double-deck elevators are required, costing significantly more than standard systems.
      • HVAC: Complex systems for heating, ventilation, and air conditioning across extreme heights and varying internal loads.
      • Fire & Life Safety: Advanced fire suppression, smoke control, and evacuation systems are paramount and highly regulated.
      • Building Maintenance Units (BMUs): Specialized window washing and exterior maintenance equipment for extreme heights.
    6. Materials & Labor:

      • High-Strength Materials: Specialized concrete, steel, and glass would be required.
      • Specialized Labor: Skilled workers for complex assembly at height.
      • Logistics: Moving materials and people up 129 stories efficiently is a major logistical challenge and cost.
      • Winter Construction: Edmonton's harsh winters would require significant winterization costs (hoarding, temporary heating) to maintain progress.
    7. Soft Costs:

      • Architectural & Engineering Fees: Design for such a building would involve world-renowned firms, leading to very high fees (often 10-15%+ of construction cost).
      • Permits, Fees & Levies: City of Edmonton, provincial, and other regulatory fees would be substantial.
      • Project Management & Consulting: Extensive oversight and specialized consultants.
      • Legal & Insurance: Complex legal agreements and comprehensive insurance policies for such a high-risk project.
      • Marketing & Leasing: Costs associated with attracting tenants/buyers for millions of square feet.
    8. Financing Costs:

      • Servicing a multi-billion dollar loan over a potentially 5-8+ year construction period would accrue massive interest payments.
    9. Contingency:

      • For a project of this scale and complexity, a high contingency (15-25% of total costs) would be essential to cover unforeseen issues, material price fluctuations, and delays.

    Speculative Cost Estimate:

    Based on other megatall buildings worldwide and adjusting for Canadian costs and Edmonton's market, a rough breakdown could be:

    • Construction Costs (Hard Costs): This is the largest component, typically estimated on a per-square-foot basis.

      • For standard high-rises in major North American cities, construction can range from 400−400-700 CAD/sq ft.
      • For supertall/megatall buildings, due to extreme complexity, specialized materials, and unique systems, this can easily jump to 800−800 - 1,500+ CAD per square foot.
      • Estimated Construction Cost:
        • Low: 2,000,000 sq ft * 800/sqft=∗∗800/sq ft = **1.6 Billion CAD**
        • High: 3,250,000 sq ft * 1,500/sqft=∗∗1,500/sq ft = **4.875 Billion CAD**
        • (Let's use a conservative average for the rest of the calculation: 2.5Billion−2.5 Billion - 4 Billion CAD)
    • Land Acquisition: 50million−50 million - 200 million CAD

    • Architectural, Engineering, & Design (Soft Costs): 10-15% of construction = 250million−250 million - 600 million CAD

    • Permits, Fees, Taxes, & Levies: 1-3% of total project = 30million−30 million - 150 million CAD

    • Financing Costs (Interest, Fees): 5-10% of total project = 150million−150 million - 500 million CAD

    • Project Management, Legal, Insurance, Contingency: 15-25% of total project = 450million−450 million - 1.25 billion CAD

    Putting it all together, a 129-story building in downtown Edmonton could realistically cost anywhere from: 3.5BillionCADto3.5 Billion CAD to 6.5 Billion+ CAD

    Feasibility in Edmonton:

    While fascinating to consider, a project of this magnitude in Edmonton currently faces enormous practical and economic hurdles:

    • Market Demand: There isn't current demand to absorb millions of square feet of high-end office, retail, and residential space in downtown Edmonton. Existing office vacancy rates are already a challenge.
    • Economic Viability: The return on investment for a multi-billion dollar project like this would be extremely difficult to justify without massive, long-term, and guaranteed pre-leasing or sales.
    • Infrastructure: While downtown Edmonton has infrastructure, the sheer scale of a 129-story building would put immense strain on local power, water, sewer, and transportation networks, requiring significant (and costly) upgrades.
    • Regulatory Environment: The City of Edmonton would need to approve a height variance of an unprecedented scale, and fire codes, emergency services, and flight paths would all need extensive review.
    • Construction Expertise: While Canada has world-class construction firms, only a handful have experience with "megatall" structures, and they would likely need international partnerships.

    In summary, while technically possible to build, the economic and market realities make a 129-story building in downtown Edmonton highly improbable at this time. The cost would be comparable to the construction of a major national infrastructure project.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.