Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
chatgpt-4o-latest-20250326· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

From the data you know, what are the top 5 glues (in terms of price/strength) for…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-sonnet-4-20250514-thinking-32k’s answer.
  1. User

    From the data you know, what are the top 5 glues (in terms of price/strength) for woodworking joinery? Could you also give some details on their strength level?

    Please try to recall data from independent tests, not the declared strength.

  2. Assistant

    Sure! In independent tests—especially those conducted by sources like Fine Woodworking, Popular Woodworking, and others—several types of adhesives consistently come out on top when measured by bond strength, clamp time, water resistance, and value (price-to-strength ratio). Here’s a rundown of the top 5 woodworking glues by actual performance and price/strength ratio:


    🏆 Top 5 Woodworking Glues (Price/Strength Performance)

    1. Titebond III Ultimate Wood Glue

    • Type: PVA (polyvinyl acetate) — waterproof (ANSI Type I)
    • Tested Strength: ~4,000+ PSI (wood failure in most stress tests)
    • Cost: 8–8–10 per 16 oz (0.50–0.50–0.60/oz)
    • Pros:
      • Waterproof (Type I)
      • Long open time (~10 mins)
      • Easy cleanup
      • Very high strength in independent stress/shear tests
    • Top Performer In: Fine Woodworking Glue Test (2007) and follow-ups
    • Price/Performance Ratio: ★★★★★

    ✅ Best Overall for General Use, Outdoor Durability, and Strength


    2. Titebond II Premium Wood Glue

    • Type: PVA (ANSI Type II water-resistance)
    • Tested Strength: ~3,600–4,000 PSI
    • Cost: ~6per16oz( 6 per 16 oz (~0.37/oz)
    • Pros:
      • Water-resistant (Type II)
      • Slightly lower cost than Titebond III
      • Fast setting
    • Downsides:
      • Slightly less heat/water resistance than Titebond III
    • Price/Performance Ratio: ★★★★★

    ✅ Best for Interior and Semi-Exterior Use If Budget-Sensitive


    3. Original Gorilla Glue (Polyurethane)

    • Type: Polyurethane
    • Tested Strength: ~3,000–3,600 PSI (independent lab tests)
    • Cost: 7–7–8 per 8 oz ($1/oz)
    • Pros:
      • Excellent for non-wood or exotic wood joins (foam, metal, plastics)
      • Waterproof (Type I)
    • Cons:
      • Foams up during cure—messier
      • Requires clamping and moisture
      • Brittle under shear stress relative to top PVA glues
    • Best Use: Mixed materials, outdoor joints, heavy-duty bonding
    • Price/Performance Ratio: ★★★☆☆

    ✅ Useful for Unique or Challenging Materials


    4. Liquid Hide Glue (Franklin or Old Brown Glue)

    • Type: Animal protein (hide glue)
    • Tested Strength: ~2,800–3,200 PSI
    • Cost: 10–10–12 per 16 oz (0.62–0.62–0.75/oz)
    • Pros:
      • Long open time
      • Reversible with heat (great for repairs)
      • Historical/restoration accuracy
    • Cons:
      • Requires warm temperatures
      • Less water-resistant
    • Price/Performance Ratio: ★★★★☆

    ✅ Best for Antique Restoration, Veneering, and Gapped Joints


    5. Epoxy (e.g., System Three or West System)

    • Type: Two-part epoxy
    • Tested Strength: ~3,500–4,500 PSI depending on formulation
    • Cost: ~20+perquart( 20+ per quart (~0.62+/oz)
    • Pros:
      • Fills large gaps
      • Very water-resistant
      • Bonds wood, metal, stone, fiberglass
    • Cons:
      • Expensive
      • Can be brittle if not formulated flexibly
      • More prep required
    • Price/Performance Ratio: ★★★★☆

    ✅ Best for Structural Gaps or Marine Applications


    🔬 Summary Table:

    Glue TypeAvg Strength (PSI)Water ResistanceCost/OzBest Use Case
    Titebond III4,000+Type I (waterproof)~$0.55All-around, exterior-quality furniture
    Titebond II3,600–4,000Type II (resistant)~$0.37Interior woodworking, cabinetry
    Gorilla Polyurethane~3,200–3,600Type I~$1.00Mixed materials or unusual joins
    Liquid Hide Glue~2,800–3,200None (not waterproof)~$0.70Restoration, musical instruments
    System Three Epoxy~4,500Fully waterproof~$0.70+Boats, structural, gap-filling applications

    🧪 Notes from Independent Tests:

    • In repeated destructive shear and tensile tests, Titebond III generally causes wood failure before glue failure, which is the gold standard.
    • Epoxies often win in strength but lose on price and complexity.
    • Polyurethane glues bond many materials but are not better than PVA for clean wood-to-wood bonds.
    • Hide glue remains popular for its reversibility and traditions, despite lower strength.

    Would you like references or more detail from specific test articles?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.