Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
grok-3-preview-02-24· xAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I need a simple Ansible project that enabled automated commit recovery in Palo Alto…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o4-mini-2025-04-16’s answer.
  1. User

    I need a simple Ansible project that enabled automated commit recovery in Palo Alto Panorama.

  2. Assistant

    Below is a simple Ansible project to automate commit recovery in Palo Alto Panorama. This project will use Ansible to interact with Panorama's API to perform a commit recovery (revert to the last successful commit). This is useful in scenarios where a commit fails or causes issues, and you need to roll back to a stable state.

    Prerequisites

    1. Ansible Installed: Ensure Ansible is installed on your control node.
    2. Palo Alto Panorama Access: You need API access to Panorama (API key, Panorama IP/hostname, and credentials).
    3. Python Modules: Install the required Python modules:
      pip install pan-python requests
      
    4. Ansible Collections: Install the Palo Alto Networks Ansible collection:
      ansible-galaxy collection install paloaltonetworks.panos
      

    Project Structure

    Create the following directory structure for your Ansible project:

    panorama_commit_recovery/
    ├── inventory.yml
    ├── playbook.yml
    ├── group_vars/
    │   └── all.yml
    └── README.md
    

    Step-by-Step Explanation

    1. Inventory File (inventory.yml)

    This file defines the Panorama device you want to manage.

    ---
    all:
      hosts:
        panorama:
          ansible_host: <PANORAMA_IP_OR_HOSTNAME>  # Replace with your Panorama IP or hostname
          ansible_connection: local  # Use local connection since we're using API
    

    2. Group Variables File (group_vars/all.yml)

    This file stores variables such as the API key, credentials, and other settings.

    ---
    # Panorama API credentials
    panorama_username: "admin"  # Replace with your Panorama admin username
    panorama_password: "<YOUR_PASSWORD>"  # Replace with your Panorama admin password
    panorama_api_key: "<YOUR_API_KEY>"  # Replace with your Panorama API key (optional, if using API key instead of username/password)
    
    # Panorama settings
    panorama_port: 443  # Default HTTPS port
    panorama_timeout: 30  # API timeout in seconds
    

    Note: For security, avoid hardcoding sensitive data like passwords or API keys in plain text. Use Ansible Vault to encrypt sensitive data or store them in a secure location.

    3. Playbook File (playbook.yml)

    This playbook performs the commit recovery on Panorama. It uses the paloaltonetworks.panos collection to interact with Panorama's API.

    ---
    - name: Perform Commit Recovery on Palo Alto Panorama
      hosts: panorama
      gather_facts: no
      collections:
        - paloaltonetworks.panos
    
      tasks:
        - name: Revert to the last successful commit
          panos_commit:
            provider:
              ip_address: "{{ ansible_host }}"
              username: "{{ panorama_username }}"
              password: "{{ panorama_password }}"
              # api_key: "{{ panorama_api_key }}"  # Uncomment if using API key instead of username/password
              port: "{{ panorama_port }}"
            revert_to_last_saved: yes
          register: commit_result
    
        - name: Display commit recovery result
          debug:
            msg: "{{ commit_result }}"
    
        - name: Ensure commit recovery was successful
          assert:
            that:
              - commit_result is success
            fail_msg: "Commit recovery failed!"
            success_msg: "Commit recovery completed successfully!"
    

    4. README File (README.md)

    Add a README file to document the project and provide instructions.

    # Panorama Commit Recovery Ansible Project
    
    This Ansible project automates commit recovery (reverting to the last successful commit) on Palo Alto Panorama.
    
    ## Prerequisites
    - Ansible installed on the control node.
    - Palo Alto Networks Ansible collection (`paloaltonetworks.panos`).
    - API access to Panorama (API key or username/password).
    
    ## Setup
    1. Update the `inventory.yml` file with your Panorama IP or hostname.
    2. Update the `group_vars/all.yml` file with your Panorama credentials and settings.
    3. Install the required Python modules:
       ```bash
       pip install pan-python requests
    
    1. Install the Palo Alto Networks Ansible collection:
      ansible-galaxy collection install paloaltonetworks.panos
      

    Running the Playbook

    Run the playbook using the following command:

    ansible-playbook -i inventory.yml playbook.yml
    

    Notes

    • For security, use Ansible Vault to encrypt sensitive data like passwords or API keys.
    • Ensure network connectivity between the Ansible control node and Panorama.
    
    ---
    
    ### Running the Project
    
    1. **Navigate to the Project Directory**:
       ```bash
       cd panorama_commit_recovery
    
    1. Run the Playbook:

      ansible-playbook -i inventory.yml playbook.yml
      
    2. Verify the Output: The playbook will output the result of the commit recovery operation. If successful, it will display a message indicating that the commit recovery was completed.


    Security Best Practices

    • Use Ansible Vault: Encrypt sensitive data like passwords and API keys using Ansible Vault:
      ansible-vault create group_vars/all.yml
      
      Then run the playbook with the --ask-vault-pass flag:
      ansible-playbook -i inventory.yml playbook.yml --ask-vault-pass
      
    • Restrict Access: Ensure the Ansible control node and project files are accessible only to authorized users.
    • API Key vs. Username/Password: Prefer using an API key over username/password for better security.

    Troubleshooting

    • Connection Issues: Ensure the Panorama IP/hostname is reachable and the API is enabled.
    • Authentication Errors: Verify the username, password, or API key in group_vars/all.yml.
    • Module Errors: Ensure the paloaltonetworks.panos collection is installed correctly.

    This simple Ansible project provides a foundation for automating commit recovery in Panorama. You can extend it further by adding error handling, logging, or additional tasks (e.g., validating the commit state before and after recovery).

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.