Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Under what circumstances is the following matrix equation for two matrices A and B…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-3-preview-02-24’s answer.
  1. User

    Under what circumstances is the following matrix equation for two matrices A and B correct: trace((A^{-1/2}BA^{-1})^{1/2}) = trace( (A^-1B)^{1/2})

  2. Qwen Assistant

    We are given the matrix equation:

    trace((A−1/2BA−1)1/2)=trace((A−1B)1/2)\text{trace}\left( (A^{-1/2} B A^{-1})^{1/2} \right) = \text{trace}\left( (A^{-1} B)^{1/2} \right)

    and we are to determine under what circumstances this equality holds for matrices AA and BB. Let's analyze this step by step.


    Step 1: Understand the expression

    Let’s define:

    • X=A−1/2BA−1X = A^{-1/2} B A^{-1}
    • Y=A−1BY = A^{-1} B

    Then the equation becomes:

    trace(X1/2)=trace(Y1/2)\text{trace}(X^{1/2}) = \text{trace}(Y^{1/2})

    So we want:

    trace((A−1/2BA−1)1/2)=trace((A−1B)1/2)\text{trace}\left( (A^{-1/2} B A^{-1})^{1/2} \right) = \text{trace}\left( (A^{-1} B)^{1/2} \right)

    Step 2: Consider properties of trace and powers

    The trace is invariant under similarity transformations, i.e., for invertible PP,

    trace(PMP−1)=trace(M)\text{trace}(P M P^{-1}) = \text{trace}(M)

    Also, if a matrix MM is diagonalizable with positive eigenvalues, then its square root M1/2M^{1/2} is well-defined. If MM is not symmetric, care must be taken in defining its square root, but if it's diagonalizable with positive real eigenvalues, then a principal square root exists.

    Note that both expressions involve matrix square roots, so we should consider whether these square roots are defined and how they behave.


    Step 3: Try simplifying the left-hand side

    Let’s look at:

    A−1/2BA−1A^{-1/2} B A^{-1}

    Can we relate this to A−1BA^{-1} B? Let’s factor out:

    A−1/2BA−1=A−1/2BA−1/2A−1/2=(A−1/2BA−1/2)A−1/2A^{-1/2} B A^{-1} = A^{-1/2} B A^{-1/2} A^{-1/2} = (A^{-1/2} B A^{-1/2}) A^{-1/2}

    Alternatively, perhaps better to try to see whether A−1/2BA−1A^{-1/2} B A^{-1} is similar to A−1BA^{-1} B, which would imply that their square roots have the same trace.

    Let’s suppose AA is positive definite, so that all powers like A1/2,A−1/2A^{1/2}, A^{-1/2} are well-defined and invertible.

    Now observe:

    A−1/2BA−1=A−1/2BA−1/2A−1/2=(A−1/2BA−1/2)A−1/2A^{-1/2} B A^{-1} = A^{-1/2} B A^{-1/2} A^{-1/2} = (A^{-1/2} B A^{-1/2}) A^{-1/2}

    This doesn't immediately simplify.

    But let’s try a similarity transformation:

    Suppose we define:

    Z=A−1BZ = A^{-1} B

    Then:

    A−1/2ZA1/2=A−1/2(A−1B)A1/2=A−1/2A−1BA1/2=A−3/2BA1/2A^{-1/2} Z A^{1/2} = A^{-1/2} (A^{-1} B) A^{1/2} = A^{-1/2} A^{-1} B A^{1/2} = A^{-3/2} B A^{1/2}

    Not quite helpful.

    Wait — here's an idea: What if we can show that:

    A−1/2BA−1∼A−1BA^{-1/2} B A^{-1} \sim A^{-1} B

    i.e., that these two matrices are similar?

    If that were true, then any function applied to them (like taking the square root and then trace) would give the same result.

    Let’s test this.

    Let’s define:

    M=A−1B,N=A−1/2BA−1M = A^{-1} B,\quad N = A^{-1/2} B A^{-1}

    Try to find an invertible matrix PP such that:

    N=PMP−1N = P M P^{-1}

    Let’s try P=A−1/2P = A^{-1/2}, then:

    PMP−1=A−1/2(A−1B)A1/2=A−1/2A−1BA1/2=A−3/2BA1/2P M P^{-1} = A^{-1/2} (A^{-1} B) A^{1/2} = A^{-1/2} A^{-1} B A^{1/2} = A^{-3/2} B A^{1/2}

    Not equal to N=A−1/2BA−1N = A^{-1/2} B A^{-1}

    So not similar directly.

    However, maybe there's another way to proceed.


    Step 4: Use cyclic property of trace

    Recall that trace is invariant under cyclic permutations, i.e., for square matrices A,BA, B, we have:

    trace(AB)=trace(BA)\text{trace}(AB) = \text{trace}(BA)

    This extends to more than two matrices as long as the product remains the same up to cyclic permutation.

    Let’s now look at:

    (A−1/2BA−1)1/2(A^{-1/2} B A^{-1})^{1/2}

    Suppose we assume that A−1BA^{-1} B has a unique square root, say S=(A−1B)1/2S = (A^{-1} B)^{1/2}. Then:

    S2=A−1BS^2 = A^{-1} B

    What about the other matrix:

    A−1/2BA−1=A−1/2(A1/2S2A1/2)A−1=A−1/2A1/2S2A1/2A−1=I⋅S2⋅A−1/2=S2A−1/2A^{-1/2} B A^{-1} = A^{-1/2} (A^{1/2} S^2 A^{1/2}) A^{-1} = A^{-1/2} A^{1/2} S^2 A^{1/2} A^{-1} = I \cdot S^2 \cdot A^{-1/2} = S^2 A^{-1/2}

    No, that seems messy.

    Let’s try a different approach.


    Step 5: Use eigenvalues

    Trace is the sum of eigenvalues. So if the matrices inside the trace on both sides have the same eigenvalues (counting multiplicity), then their traces will be equal.

    Let’s suppose AA is positive definite, so that A1/2A^{1/2} and A−1/2A^{-1/2} exist and are invertible.

    Define:

    C=A−1BC = A^{-1} B

    Then:

    A−1/2BA−1=A−1/2(AC)A−1=A−1/2ACA−1=A1/2CA−1A^{-1/2} B A^{-1} = A^{-1/2} (A C) A^{-1} = A^{-1/2} A C A^{-1} = A^{1/2} C A^{-1}

    So:

    (A−1/2BA−1)1/2=(A1/2CA−1)1/2(A^{-1/2} B A^{-1})^{1/2} = (A^{1/2} C A^{-1})^{1/2}

    Is this similar to C1/2C^{1/2}? Not obviously.

    But now consider:

    Suppose AA and BB commute: AB=BAAB = BA

    Then A−1B=BA−1A^{-1} B = B A^{-1}, and also A−1/2A^{-1/2} commutes with A−1A^{-1}, since powers of AA commute.

    In fact, if AA and BB commute, then A−1A^{-1} and BB also commute, and so does A−1/2A^{-1/2} with BB (if AA is diagonalizable).

    So under the assumption that AA and BB commute, and AA is positive definite (so that all powers are defined), then:

    A−1/2BA−1=A−1BA−1/2A^{-1/2} B A^{-1} = A^{-1} B A^{-1/2}

    So both sides are products of commuting matrices, and hence the order doesn’t matter.

    Therefore:

    (A−1/2BA−1)1/2=(A−1B)1/2A−1/2(A^{-1/2} B A^{-1})^{1/2} = (A^{-1} B)^{1/2} A^{-1/2}

    Then:

    trace((A−1/2BA−1)1/2)=trace((A−1B)1/2A−1/2)\text{trace}\left( (A^{-1/2} B A^{-1})^{1/2} \right) = \text{trace}\left( (A^{-1} B)^{1/2} A^{-1/2} \right)

    And in general, this is not equal to trace((A−1B)1/2)\text{trace}((A^{-1} B)^{1/2}), unless A−1/2A^{-1/2} commutes with (A−1B)1/2(A^{-1} B)^{1/2}, which happens if all involved matrices commute.

    So again, we get back to:

    If AA and BB commute, then the equality holds.

    Let’s formalize this conclusion.


    ✅ Final Answer:

    The equality

    trace((A−1/2BA−1)1/2)=trace((A−1B)1/2)\text{trace}\left( (A^{-1/2} B A^{-1})^{1/2} \right) = \text{trace}\left( (A^{-1} B)^{1/2} \right)

    holds when:

    • AA is positive definite (so that A−1/2A^{-1/2}, etc., are well-defined),
    • and AA and BB commute, i.e., AB=BAAB = BA.

    Under these conditions, the matrices inside the trace are similar or share the same eigenvalues, ensuring the equality of their traces.

  3. User

    are these conditions fulfilled for any symmetric positive definite matrix?

  4. Qwen Assistant

    Great question!

    We previously established that the equality

    trace((A−1/2BA−1)1/2)=trace((A−1B)1/2)\text{trace}\left( (A^{-1/2} B A^{-1})^{1/2} \right) = \text{trace}\left( (A^{-1} B)^{1/2} \right)

    holds when:

    • AA is positive definite (so that all powers like A−1/2A^{-1/2} are well-defined),
    • and AA and BB commute, i.e., AB=BAAB = BA.

    Now you're asking:

    Are these conditions fulfilled for any symmetric positive definite matrix?

    Let’s break this down carefully.


    🔹 Clarifying the question:

    You're likely asking whether, if both AA and BB are symmetric positive definite matrices, does it necessarily follow that the above trace equality holds?

    That is, do all symmetric positive definite matrices AA and BB satisfy the required condition AB=BAAB = BA?

    The answer is:

    ❌ No — not all symmetric positive definite matrices commute.

    So even if AA and BB are both symmetric positive definite, they may not commute, and thus the trace equality may not hold in general.


    🔸 When do symmetric positive definite matrices commute?

    Two symmetric matrices AA and BB commute if and only if they are simultaneously diagonalizable, meaning there exists an orthogonal matrix PP such that:

    PTAP=D1,PTBP=D2P^T A P = D_1,\quad P^T B P = D_2

    where D1,D2D_1, D_2 are diagonal matrices.

    This is equivalent to saying that AA and BB share a common set of eigenvectors.

    So:

    ✅ If AA and BB are symmetric positive definite and simultaneously diagonalizable (i.e., share eigenvectors), then AB=BAAB = BA, and the trace equality holds.

    But:

    ❌ In general, two symmetric positive definite matrices do not commute unless they share eigenvectors.


    🔹 Example of non-commuting symmetric positive definite matrices:

    Let:

    A=[2001],B=[1112]A = \begin{bmatrix} 2 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 \end{bmatrix}, \quad B = \begin{bmatrix} 1 & 1 \\ 1 & 2 \end{bmatrix}

    Both are symmetric positive definite.

    Compute ABAB and BABA:

    AB=[2212],BA=[2122]AB = \begin{bmatrix} 2 & 2 \\ 1 & 2 \end{bmatrix}, \quad BA = \begin{bmatrix} 2 & 1 \\ 2 & 2 \end{bmatrix}

    Clearly, AB≠BAAB \neq BA. So they do not commute.

    Thus, the trace identity will not generally hold for arbitrary symmetric positive definite matrices.


    ✅ Final Answer:

    No, the conditions under which the trace identity

    trace((A−1/2BA−1)1/2)=trace((A−1B)1/2)\text{trace}\left( (A^{-1/2} B A^{-1})^{1/2} \right) = \text{trace}\left( (A^{-1} B)^{1/2} \right)

    holds are not satisfied by any arbitrary pair of symmetric positive definite matrices.

    They must also commute (or be simultaneously diagonalizable). This is a stronger condition than just being symmetric positive definite.

    So:

    ✅ The equality holds if and only if:

    • AA is positive definite,
    • AA and BB commute (i.e., AB=BAAB = BA).

    Even with both matrices symmetric positive definite, this commutativity condition must be verified separately.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.