Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash-lite-preview-06-17-thinking· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

teach me how does transformers work, explain the entire workflow

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-4-maverick-03-26-experimental’s answer.
  1. User

    teach me how does transformers work, explain the entire workflow

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's break down how Transformer models work, step by step. The Transformer architecture was introduced in the paper "Attention Is All You Need" and revolutionized Natural Language Processing (NLP) and beyond.

    The Core Problem Transformers Solve:

    Before Transformers, models like Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) and LSTMs were state-of-the-art for sequence data (like text). However, they process data sequentially (one word after another), which is slow and struggles to capture long-range dependencies (how a word at the beginning of a long sentence relates to a word at the end).

    Transformers overcome this using self-attention, allowing them to look at all parts of the input sequence simultaneously and weigh the importance of different parts relative to each other.

    The Overall Architecture:

    Transformers typically have an Encoder-Decoder structure, especially for tasks like machine translation (translating from one language to another).

    1. Encoder: Reads the input sequence and generates a rich, contextual representation (understanding) of it.
    2. Decoder: Takes the encoder's representation and generates the output sequence, one element at a time.

    Note: Some Transformer variants, like BERT, only use the Encoder part, while others, like GPT, primarily use the Decoder part.

    The Entire Workflow (using Machine Translation as an example):

    Let's translate the French sentence "Je suis étudiant" (I am a student) to English.

    Step 1: Input Processing

    1. Tokenization: The input sentence is broken down into tokens (words or sub-words).
      • ["Je", "suis", "étudiant"]
    2. Embedding: Each token is converted into a numerical vector using an embedding lookup table. These vectors initially represent the meaning of the words but don't know their position.
      • [vector_Je, vector_suis, vector_étudiant]
    3. Positional Encoding: Since the model doesn't process words sequentially (like RNNs), it needs information about the position of each token. Positional encoding vectors are added to the token embeddings. These vectors are calculated based on the position, giving the model a sense of word order.
      • Input Vector Sequence = [vector_Je + pos_enc_0, vector_suis + pos_enc_1, vector_étudiant + pos_enc_2]

    Step 2: The Encoder

    The input vector sequence is passed through a stack of identical Encoder layers (e.g., 6 layers). Each layer has two main sub-layers:

    • Sub-layer 1: Multi-Head Self-Attention:
      • Goal: To understand the context of each word by looking at all other words in the input sentence.
      • Mechanism (Simplified):
        • For each word's vector, create three vectors: Query (Q), Key (K), and Value (V). Think of it like searching a database:
          • Query (Q): Represents the current word asking "What is relevant to me?"
          • Key (K): Represents each word (including itself) saying "This is what I contain."
          • Value (V): Represents the actual content/meaning of each word.
        • Calculate a score between the Query of the current word and the Key of every other word (including itself). This score determines relevance (often using dot product).
        • Scale these scores (divide by the square root of the dimension of Key vectors) to stabilize gradients.
        • Apply Softmax to the scores to get weights (probabilities) that sum to 1. A higher weight means higher relevance.
        • Multiply the weights by the corresponding Value vectors and sum them up. This results in a new vector for the current word, which is enriched with contextual information from relevant words in the sentence.
      • Multi-Head: Instead of doing this once, the process is done multiple times (multiple "heads") with different, learned Q, K, V projections. Each head can focus on different aspects of the relationships between words. The results from all heads are concatenated and linearly projected back to the original dimension.
    • Sub-layer 2: Position-wise Feed-Forward Network (FFN):
      • Goal: To further process the output from the attention layer.
      • Mechanism: A simple fully connected neural network applied independently to each position's vector. It usually consists of two linear transformations with a ReLU activation in between. FFN(x) = max(0, xW1 + b1)W2 + b2
    • Add & Norm (Residual Connections and Layer Normalization):
      • After each sub-layer (Attention and FFN), the input to that sub-layer is added to its output (a "residual connection"). This helps prevent vanishing gradients and allows deeper networks.
      • Then, Layer Normalization is applied to stabilize the activations.

    Encoder Output: After passing through all N encoder layers, the output is a sequence of vectors, where each vector represents a token in the input sentence, but now deeply contextualized by the entire input sequence.

    Step 3: The Decoder

    The Decoder also consists of a stack of identical layers, but with an additional sub-layer. It generates the output sequence ("I", "am", "a", "student") one token at a time.

    • Start: The decoder receives the encoder's output and a special <SOS> (Start Of Sentence) token as its initial input (embedded and positionally encoded, just like the encoder input).
    • Decoder Layers: Each layer has three main sub-layers:
      1. Masked Multi-Head Self-Attention:
        • Similar to the encoder's self-attention, but applied to the output sequence generated so far.
        • Crucial difference: Masking. During training and generation, the decoder should only attend to previous positions in the output sequence, not future ones (otherwise, it would be cheating!). The masking step sets the attention scores for future positions to negative infinity before the softmax, effectively making their weights zero.
      2. Multi-Head Encoder-Decoder Attention (Cross-Attention):
        • Goal: To allow the decoder to focus on relevant parts of the input sentence (from the encoder's output) while generating the output sentence.
        • Mechanism:
          • Query (Q): Comes from the output of the previous decoder sub-layer (masked self-attention). It represents what the decoder needs next for the output sequence.
          • Key (K) & Value (V): Come from the final output of the Encoder. They represent the contextualized information from the input sentence.
          • The calculation is the same as self-attention (softmax(QK^T / sqrt(d_k)) * V), but the Q is from the decoder and K/V are from the encoder. This lets each position in the decoder "look back" at the entire input sequence and extract relevant information.
      3. Position-wise Feed-Forward Network (FFN):
        • Identical in function to the FFN in the encoder. Processes the output from the cross-attention layer.
    • Add & Norm: Applied after each sub-layer, just like in the encoder.

    Step 4: Final Output Generation

    1. Linear Layer: The output vector from the final decoder layer (corresponding to the current time step) is passed through a final linear layer. This layer projects the vector into a much larger vector, where the size equals the vocabulary size (all possible output words). Each element in this large vector represents a "score" for a word in the vocabulary.
    2. Softmax: The scores are converted into probabilities. The word with the highest probability is predicted as the next token in the output sequence.

    Step 5: Iteration

    • For the first output token (e.g., "I"): The decoder takes <SOS> and the encoder output. It generates "I".
    • For the second output token: The decoder takes <SOS> and "I" (embedded & positionally encoded) and the encoder output. It generates "am".
    • For the third output token: The decoder takes <SOS>, "I", "am" and the encoder output. It generates "a".
    • ...and so on, until the decoder predicts a special <EOS> (End Of Sentence) token or reaches a maximum length.

    Summary of the Flow:

    1. Encode Input: Input tokens -> Embeddings + Positional Encoding -> Pass through N Encoder layers (Self-Attention -> Add&Norm -> FFN -> Add&Norm).
    2. Decode Output (Iteratively):
      • Start with <SOS> token.
      • Feed previous output tokens (embedded + positional encoded) and Encoder output into N Decoder layers (Masked Self-Attention -> Add&Norm -> Cross-Attention -> Add&Norm -> FFN -> Add&Norm).
      • Project the final decoder output using Linear layer + Softmax to predict the next token probabilities.
      • Select the next token.
      • Feed the selected token back into the decoder for the next step.
      • Repeat until <EOS> is predicted.

    Key Concepts Recap:

    • Self-Attention: Allows the model to weigh the importance of different tokens within the same sequence (input or output).
    • Multi-Head Attention: Runs attention multiple times in parallel to capture different types of relationships.
    • Positional Encoding: Injects information about the position of tokens since the architecture itself doesn't have recurrence.
    • Encoder-Decoder Structure: Encoder understands the input, Decoder generates the output using Encoder's understanding.
    • Masking: Ensures the Decoder only attends to valid (past) positions in the output sequence.
    • Residual Connections & Layer Norm: Crucial for training deep Transformer models effectively.

    This layered, attention-based approach allows Transformers to handle long sequences efficiently and capture complex dependencies, making them incredibly powerful for various tasks.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.