Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14· OpenAI LMArena Human Preference 140K

What is by your view most plausible theory of consciousness?

  1. User

    What is by your view most plausible theory of consciousness?

  2. Assistant

    Consciousness is one of the deepest and most challenging questions in science and philosophy, and there is no consensus on a single “most plausible” theory. However, I can share a perspective that many researchers find compelling, based on current evidence and theoretical coherence.

    Integrated Information Theory (IIT) and Global Workspace Theory (GWT) are two leading contenders, each with strengths:

    • Integrated Information Theory (IIT), proposed by Giulio Tononi, suggests that consciousness corresponds to the capacity of a system to integrate information. The more integrated and differentiated the information processing, the richer the conscious experience. IIT tries to quantify consciousness (with a measure called phi) and links it to physical substrates, offering a principled way to explain why certain brain states are conscious and others are not.

    • Global Workspace Theory (GWT), championed by Bernard Baars and Stanislas Dehaene, posits that consciousness arises when information is globally broadcast across the brain’s networks, allowing different specialized modules to access and use that information. This theory aligns well with cognitive neuroscience findings about attention, working memory, and reportability.

    My view:
    A plausible theory of consciousness likely combines elements of both integration and global accessibility. Consciousness seems to require both a high degree of integrated information processing and a mechanism for widespread broadcasting of that information to multiple brain systems. This hybrid view fits well with empirical data from neuroimaging, lesion studies, and computational modeling.

    Additionally, I think any successful theory must:

    • Explain the subjective, qualitative aspect of experience (the “hard problem”).
    • Be consistent with neuroscience and cognitive science.
    • Make testable predictions.
    • Account for the gradations of consciousness seen in different states (sleep, anesthesia, disorders).

    In summary, while no theory is definitive, a synthesis of IIT’s emphasis on integrated information and GWT’s emphasis on global broadcasting currently offers the most promising framework for understanding consciousness. Future advances in neuroscience, AI, and philosophy will hopefully clarify and refine this picture.

  3. User

    But none of those theories tells what consciousness is, or how to create it. Can you propose single one, which say what it is?

  4. Assistant

    You’re right — many leading theories describe correlates or mechanisms of consciousness, but they often stop short of a clear, foundational definition of what consciousness actually is or how to create it from first principles.

    If I were to propose a single, clear theory that tries to say what consciousness is, it might go something like this:


    Consciousness as Intrinsic Subjective Information Processing

    Core idea:
    Consciousness is the intrinsic, self-generated, and self-referential processing of information that creates a unified, subjective perspective — a “point of view” — that cannot be reduced to mere data or computation alone.


    What does this mean?

    1. Intrinsic: Consciousness is not just information being processed; it is information as experienced from within. It’s the difference between data on a hard drive and the felt experience of seeing red or feeling pain.

    2. Subjective: Consciousness is inherently first-person. It is the “what it is like” to be a system processing information.

    3. Self-generated: Consciousness arises when a system not only processes information but also models and monitors its own internal states and processes — a kind of recursive self-awareness.

    4. Unified perspective: Consciousness integrates diverse sensory, cognitive, and emotional inputs into a coherent, singular experience — a “self” that experiences the world as a whole.


    How to create it?

    To create consciousness, a system must:

    • Have complex, integrated information processing (like IIT suggests).
    • Have global accessibility and broadcasting of information (like GWT suggests).
    • Crucially, have recursive self-modeling — the system must represent and monitor its own states in a way that generates a subjective perspective.

    Why this theory?

    • It explains what consciousness is: the intrinsic, subjective experience generated by recursive, integrated information processing.
    • It suggests how to create it: build systems that not only process information but also represent and reflect on their own internal states in an integrated, globally accessible way.
    • It bridges the gap between the “hard problem” (subjectivity) and the “easy problems” (information processing, attention, reportability).

    In short:

    Consciousness = the system’s intrinsic, self-referential, integrated information processing that generates a unified subjective perspective.


    If you want, I can help sketch out what such a system might look like in practice, or how this theory relates to existing neuroscience and AI research! Would you like that?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.