Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I am working doing due diligence on a skilled nursing facility and am curious on how…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14’s answer.
  1. User

    I am working doing due diligence on a skilled nursing facility and am curious on how they run, I have never worked with one and need better insight on their standard EBITDA, revenue generation, and cost of sales

  2. Assistant

    Below is a “quick-start” primer you can take to your spreadsheet. Everything is U.S.-centric and based on 2023-2024 operator surveys (NIC, AHCA, CliftonLarsonAllen, HUD LEAN filings) plus what lenders and PE funds commonly see when underwriting SNFs. Numbers are medians—you will always find outliers.

    🚩 1. How a Skilled Nursing Facility (SNF) Makes Money

    Revenue streams (rough national mix)
    • Medicare Part A “skilled” stays (12-18 % of census, highest rate)
    • Medicare Advantage / Managed Care (8-12 %)
    • Medicaid long-term custodial (60-70 %, lowest rate)
    • Private-pay & other (5-10 %)
    • Part B therapy, pharmacy mark-ups, lab/ancillary, VBP/QIP bonuses (<5 %)

    Key levers
    • Census (occupied beds ÷ licensed beds)
    • Case-mix index (acuity) → drives PDPM rate for Medicare
    • Payer mix → drives average daily rate (ADR)

    Typical per-diem reimbursement ranges (2024)
    • Medicare PDPM: 530–530–600 / patient-day
    • Medicare Advantage: 420–420–520 (negotiated)
    • Medicaid: 190–190–260 (state dependent, sometimes add-ons)
    • Private-pay: 300–300–400

    🚩 2. Cost Structure (a.k.a. “Cost of Sales”)

    Direct patient-care costs (COGS-like)
    • Nursing & CNA wages/agency  45-55 % of revenue
    • Therapy labor & contract rehab  5-8 %
    • Medical supplies, drugs, DME  4-6 %
    • Dietary (food + kitchen labor)  3-4 %
    • Ancillary / other direct     2-3 %
    Subtotal direct         60-70 %

    Facility & G&A
    • Admin & back-office wages    5-7 %
    • Facility maintenance / utilities 3-5 %
    • Insurance (prof. & gen. liab.)  1-3 %
    • Marketing, travel, other    2-3 %
    • Rent / ground lease (if OpCo/PropCo split) 6-9 %
    • Management fee (if 3rd-party)  1-3 %

    🚩 3. EBITDA / Margin Benchmarks

    Metric       Median   Top-quartile
    EBITDA margin (after rent) 5-10 %  12-15 %
    EBITDAR margin (before rent) 10-14 % 15-18 %
    Labor cost ÷ revenue     58-64 % <55 %
    Rent-coverage (EBITDAR ÷ Rent) 1.2–1.4× >1.6×

    Note: In high-Medicaid states or post-COVID labor crunch, many facilities are breakeven or negative EBITDA.

    🚩 4. Illustrative 100-Bed Facility P&L

    Assumptions
    • 85 % average occupancy (31,025 pt-days/yr)
    • Payer mix: 15 % Medicare, 5 % MA, 70 % Medicaid, 10 % Private
    • Rates: 560/560 / 480 / 225/225 / 350 → Weighted ADR ≈ $296

    Annual $000      % Rev
    Revenue    9,180  100 %

    Direct Costs
     Nursing labor 4,140  45 %
     Therapy labor  580   6 %
     Supplies & drugs 450   5 %
     Food & dietary  330   4 %
     Ancillary other  150   2 %
    Total Direct  5,650  62 %

    Gross Profit  3,530  38 %

    Facility & G&A
     Admin wages   550   6 %
     Maintenance/Util 370   4 %
     Insurance    180   2 %
     Other G&A    120   1 %
     Rent (REIT)   680   7 %
    EBITDA     930  10 %

    Cap-ex “keep-up” (not in EBITDA) typically 500–500–1,500 per bed annually.

    🚩 5. Operational KPIs to Pull During Due Diligence

    1. Daily census trend (12-24 mo) & admission/discharge logs
    2. Payer mix & rate sheets; verify MA contract terms/length
    3. Labor: hours-per-patient-day (HPPD) by discipline, agency %
    4. State survey history & CMS 5-Star ratings (quality & staffing)
    5. Therapy provider contract and PDPM performance reports
    6. Rent schedule / escalators; related-party real-estate issues
    7. CapEx backlog (roof, HVAC, life-safety) & HUD Physical Needs Assessment if available
    8. Litigation & liability claims run
    9. Cost reports (Medicare & Medicaid) – reconcile to internal books
    10. Cash collections vs. billed (DSO); look for Medicaid pending

    🚩 6. Valuation Touch-points (if helpful)

    • SNF OpCo transactions: 5–8× forward EBITDA (post-COVID spread is wide)
    • Stabilized real-estate (PropCo): 10–13× rent or 7.5–9.0 % cap rate depending on market quality
    • Lenders focus on EBITDAR rent-coverage >1.25× and occupancy >80 %

    ⚠️ Current Headwinds
    • Agency nursing costs up 50-100 % since 2020
    • PDPM parity adjustments & sequestration resumed (−2 %)
    • Proposed federal minimum staffing rule (~3.48 HPPD) could add 2-4 pp to labor-to-revenue ratio
    • Medicaid rebasing is uneven; some states add IGT/QIPP payments that mask true margins

    ✅ Quick sanity check when you open the financials

    1. Labor + rent > 70 % of revenue? Tough to turn a profit.
    2. EBITDA margin <5 % + heavy cap-ex needs? High risk.
    3. Medicare census <10 %? Less rate cushion, but also less therapy risk under PDPM.

    Feel free to drop in more specifics (state, census sheet, cost report line items) and I can help refine the model or pressure-test assumptions.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.