There are two rating systems in which the same players play. Why are they different?…
- User
There are two rating systems in which the same players play. Why are they different? Namely.
Sytstem A System B 500 1500 600 1600 700 1700 800 1800 900 1900 1000 2000 1100 2100 1150 2150 1200 2200 1250 2250 1300 2300 1350 2350 1400 2400 1450 2450 1500 2500 1550 2550 1600 2600 1650 2650 1700 2700 1750 2750 1800 2800 1850 2850 1900 2900 1950 2950 2000 3000 2100 3100 2200 3200 2300 3300 2400 3400 2500 3500 2600 3600 2700 3700 2800 3800 2900 3900 3000 4000Why wouldn't the two systems converge with the same rating? Note that in system A the starting rating is 1500, in system B it is 2500. Some say because the two systems are identical, only they are scaled of a factor of 1000 points between each other.
Yet two other different rating systems where more or less the same players play in both converge! chess.com blitz has a starting rating around 1000 while lichess blitz has a starting rating around 1500, and they have those rating ranges.
Chess.com Lichess Blitz Blitz (+/- 75) N=2620 500 945 600 1030 700 1115 800 1205 900 1305 1000 1395 1100 1485 1150 1520 1200 1560 1250 1600 1300 1630 1350 1685 1400 1720 1450 1760 1500 1795 1550 1825 1600 1855 1650 1895 1700 1925 1750 1960 1800 2000 1850 2025 1900 2060 1950 2100 2000 2120 2100 2205 2200 2270 2300 2330 2400 2405 2500 2495 2600 2585 2700 2630 2800 2715 2900 2830 3000 2925So why one systems does not converge and the other does? It feels like something is not working. As a additional point, imagine lichess starting with a rating of 3000. I could not believe it would converge to the chess.com ratings after a while because the points in the system (for each player) will be just massive.
Assistant
Okay, let's break down why these rating systems behave differently. The core reason lies in whether the systems are truly identical except for the starting point, or if there are other underlying differences.
Scenario 1: System A vs. System B (Perfect Offset)
-
Identical Mechanics: The data
Rating_B = Rating_A + 1000strongly suggests that System A and System B use the exact same underlying rating algorithm and parameters. This means:- They use the same formula (e.g., Elo, Glicko, Glicko-2).
- They use the same parameters within that formula (e.g., the same K-factor in Elo, or the same system constants and initial deviation/volatility settings in Glicko).
- Crucially, the calculation for expected score depends only on the difference in ratings between two players.
- The rating update formula applies the same change based on the difference between the actual score and the expected score.
-
Why the Offset is Maintained: If Player X has rating
R_Ain System A and Player Y has ratingS_A, their difference isR_A - S_A. In System B, their ratings areR_B = R_A + 1000andS_B = S_A + 1000. Their difference in System B isR_B - S_B = (R_A + 1000) - (S_A + 1000) = R_A - S_A.- Since the rating difference is identical in both systems, the expected outcome of a match between them is calculated identically in both systems.
- If they play a game and the actual outcome is determined, the rating change (delta) calculated by the identical formula will be the same in both systems.
- Therefore, if
New_R_A = R_A + DeltaandNew_S_A = S_A + Delta', thenNew_R_B = R_B + Delta = (R_A + 1000) + Delta = New_R_A + 1000, and similarly for Player Y. - The 1000-point difference is perfectly preserved for every player after every game assuming they play the exact same games with the exact same results in both hypothetical systems.
-
Starting Point vs. Offset: You mentioned starting ratings of 1500 (A) and 2500 (B). This means new players are seeded with a 1000-point difference. Since the mechanics preserve this difference, the entire rating distribution just shifts up by 1000 points in System B compared to System A. They don't converge because there's no mechanism within the identical systems to erode that initial offset.
Scenario 2: Chess.com Blitz vs. Lichess Blitz (Non-Linear Relationship)
This is different because, despite having largely overlapping player pools, the systems are not identical implementations. Here's why they don't maintain a simple offset and exhibit the complex relationship shown in your table:
-
Different Rating Algorithms/Parameters:
- Lichess uses the Glicko-2 rating system.
- Chess.com uses a Glicko-1 based system (details may be proprietary but it's known to be Glicko-based, likely Glicko-1).
- Even if both used Glicko-2, they likely use different parameters within the system (like the
τ(tau) constant controlling volatility change, different initial Rating Deviations (RD), or different initial volatilities (σ)). These parameters affect how quickly ratings change and stabilize. Lichess starts new accounts at 1500 rating, 350 RD, 0.06 volatility. Chess.com starts new accounts at different ratings depending on self-assessment (e.g., 400, 800, 1200, etc.) and likely uses different initial RD/volatility parameters.
-
Different K-Factor Equivalents: Both Glicko systems have mechanisms similar to the K-factor in Elo, determining the magnitude of rating changes. These likely differ between the sites and might vary differently based on a player's rating or number of games played.
-
Different Player Pools & Behavior: While largely overlapping, the player pools aren't identical.
- Some players are exclusive to one platform.
- Players may play differently or different amounts on each site. Someone might play casually on Chess.com but seriously on Lichess, or vice versa.
- The distribution of opponents a player faces at a given rating level might differ slightly between the sites.
-
Different Initial Seeding and Inflation/Deflation:
- Lichess starts everyone at 1500. Chess.com uses self-reported skill to start players at various levels (often lower than 1500 for beginners). This injects points into the system differently.
- Rating systems can naturally inflate or deflate over time based on how new players are added, how points are exchanged, and how inactivity is handled. Chess.com and Lichess likely have different inflation/deflation dynamics. Lichess, for example, has historically had a higher degree of rating inflation than Chess.com or FIDE.
-
Implementation Details: Subtle differences in how rating periods are defined, how provisional ratings are handled, or how timeouts/aborts affect ratings can contribute to divergence.
Why No "Convergence" in the Sense of Becoming Identical?
- The Chess.com/Lichess systems aren't "converging" to the same number. They are settling into a relatively stable relationship or mapping between the two systems, which your table illustrates. This relationship is non-linear precisely because of the differences listed above.
- Your intuition about Lichess starting at 3000 is correct. If Lichess hypothetically started everyone at 3000 but kept its Glicko-2 system, the ratings would eventually spread out, but the average rating and the mapping to Chess.com would be significantly higher. A 1500 Chess.com player might correspond to a 3200 Lichess player (just a guess), not converge down near 1500. The total points in the system matter, and the rating algorithms don't inherently destroy points to force convergence to a lower baseline. They just redistribute points based on results relative to expectations.
In Summary:
- System A vs. B: Identical algorithms and parameters + different starting offset = maintained offset.
- Chess.com vs. Lichess: Different algorithms/parameters + different starting points/distributions + different player pool dynamics = complex, non-linear relationship, not convergence to identical values.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.