Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-preview-05-06· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Tell me everything I should know about limited entry deer unit 113 as a nonresident…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-pro’s answer.
  1. User

    Tell me everything I should know about limited entry deer unit 113 as a nonresident applying in Wyoming. This can include things like private ranches, designated wilderness areas restricting hunting, historical harvest averages, why 2024 was such a down year for harvest percentage, why the draw odds fluctuate so much for this specific unit, etc.

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's break down Wyoming Deer Unit 113 for a nonresident applicant. This is a Limited Quota (LQ) Mule Deer hunt in the Bighorn Mountains, specifically Region Y.

    Understanding Unit 113 - Key Characteristics:

    1. Location & Terrain:

      • Unit 113 is located in the northern Bighorn Mountains, west of Sheridan and Buffalo.
      • Terrain is diverse, ranging from foothills and sagebrush flats at lower elevations to steep, rugged, timbered country, and alpine/subalpine environments at higher elevations, especially as you approach the Cloud Peak Wilderness.
      • Expect elevations from around 5,000 feet to over 10,000 feet.
    2. Land Ownership:

      • Significant Public Land: A large portion of Unit 113 is within the Bighorn National Forest. This is where most public land hunting occurs.
      • Private Land: There is substantial private land, particularly at lower elevations along creek bottoms and in the foothills. Access to this land requires landowner permission, and some ranches may offer trespass fee hunting or guided hunts.
      • State Land: Scattered parcels of State Trust Land exist, generally accessible for hunting unless specifically closed.
      • Hunter Management Areas (HMAs) / Walk-In Areas (WIAs): Check the Wyoming Game & Fish Department (WGFD) website annually for any HMAs or WIAs within or near Unit 113. These are private lands opened to public hunting through agreements with WGFD.
    3. Designated Wilderness Areas:

      • Cloud Peak Wilderness: A significant portion of the higher elevations of Unit 113 falls within the Cloud Peak Wilderness Area.
      • Restrictions in Wilderness:
        • No Motorized or Mechanized Travel: This means no vehicles, ATVs, UTVs, bicycles, or even game carts with wheels.
        • Travel: Access is by foot or horseback/pack animal only.
        • Impact: This makes for a more physically demanding hunt but can also mean less pressure and potentially older age-class bucks for those willing to put in the effort.
        • Outfitter Activity: Outfitters often operate in the wilderness, so be aware of their potential presence.
        • WGFD regulations may have specific rules about camping or outfitter camps within wilderness areas that pertain to hunting.

    Historical Harvest Averages & Success Rates:

    • Data Source: The best source for this is the annual WGFD Harvest Reports. Look for "Mule Deer" and then "Region Y" or specifically "Unit 113."
    • Typical Success: LQ deer units in Wyoming generally have good success rates, often ranging from 40% to 70%+, depending on the year, weather, and hunter effort. Unit 113 has historically been a solid producer.
    • Hunter Days: Reports also show hunter days per harvest, giving an idea of effort.
    • Antlered vs. Any Deer: Most LQ tags are for antlered deer ("buck tags").
    • Trends: Look at data over 5-10 years to see trends. Has success been stable, declining, or improving? This can indicate population health or changing conditions.

    Why a Specific Year (e.g., "2024") Might Be a "Down Year" for Harvest Percentage:

    Since 2024 hasn't happened, let's discuss factors that could cause a "down year" in any recent or future season:

    1. Severe Winter (The Big One - e.g., 2022-2023):

      • The winter of 2022-2023 was exceptionally harsh across much of Wyoming, including the Bighorns.
      • Impacts:
        • High Adult Mortality: Especially older bucks and does weakened by the rut.
        • Drastic Fawn Loss: Fawn survival rates plummeted. This means fewer young bucks entering the population in subsequent years (e.g., fewer 1.5 and 2.5-year-old bucks in 2023, 2024, 2025).
        • WGFD Response: WGFD often significantly reduces tag quotas following such winters to allow populations to recover. This was seen in many units for the 2023 season.
      • Recovery Time: It takes several years for a deer herd to bounce back from a winter like that.
    2. Drought:

      • Prolonged drought reduces forage quality and quantity.
      • Poor doe nutrition leads to lower fawn survival rates and smaller antler growth in bucks.
    3. Disease:

      • Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD): Prevalent in many Wyoming deer herds, including Region Y. While the direct impact on harvest percentage in a single year might be less obvious than winter kill, it's a long-term factor affecting herd health and buck age structure.
      • Epizootic Hemorrhagic Disease (EHD) / Bluetongue: Can cause localized die-offs, especially in late summer/early fall near water sources during hot, dry years with lots of biting midges.
    4. Hunting Conditions during the Season:

      • Weather: Early heavy snows can push deer to lower, often private, elevations or make access difficult. Mild, warm weather can keep deer scattered at high elevations and less active during daylight.
      • Moon Phase: Some hunters believe a bright moon phase can reduce daytime deer activity.
    5. Predation: Mountain lions and coyotes are present and impact deer populations, especially fawns.

    Why Draw Odds Fluctuate So Much for Unit 113 (and other LQ units):

    Draw odds are a function of supply (number of tags) and demand (number of applicants at each point level).

    1. Tag Quotas (Supply):

      • WGFD biologists set tag quotas annually based on population surveys, winter survival, fawn recruitment, and management objectives.
      • After a severe winter (like 2022-2023), tag quotas for units like 113 were likely reduced for 2023 and might remain lower for 2024 to allow herd recovery. Fewer tags mean tougher odds.
    2. Applicant Numbers (Demand):

      • Point Creep: More and more hunters accumulate preference points. This means the "minimum points to draw" tends to rise over time for desirable units.
      • "Hot Unit" Syndrome: If a unit gets positive press (magazine articles, TV shows, social media buzz about big bucks), applicant numbers can spike.
      • Perceived Trophy Quality: If hunters believe trophy potential is high, more will apply.
      • Changes in Neighboring Units: If a nearby, similar-quality unit becomes harder to draw, applicants may shift their focus to units like 113.
      • Previous Year's Odds & Success: If odds looked good or success was high one year, it can attract more applicants the next.
      • Overall Nonresident Interest: The number of nonresidents applying for Wyoming deer tags in general can fluctuate.
    3. Wyoming's Preference Point System (for Nonresidents):

      • 75/25 Split: 75% of available nonresident LQ tags go to the highest preference point holders.
      • 25% Random Draw: The remaining 25% are drawn randomly among all remaining applicants, regardless of point totals (though those with more points have slightly better odds in this random portion due to how some states weight it, WGFD's random is truly random for this part).
      • Special vs. Regular Draw: Nonresidents can choose to apply in the "Special Draw" (more expensive license) or the "Regular Draw." 40% of the nonresident quota is allocated to the Special Draw, 60% to the Regular. Odds are generally better in the Special Draw due to fewer applicants willing to pay the higher price, but it's significantly more expensive.
      • Party Applications: If you apply as a party, your points are averaged. This can help or hurt your individual odds.
    4. The "2024 Down Year Harvest" Question & Odds:

      • If WGFD biologists determine the herd in 113 was hit hard by the 2022-23 winter (which is likely), they would have reduced tags for 2023 and potentially for 2024.
      • Fewer tags directly translate to much tougher draw odds, even if applicant numbers stay the same or slightly decrease.
      • This is the most significant factor for odds fluctuations following major environmental events.

    What You, as a Nonresident, Should Do:

    1. Consult WGFD Resources religiously:

      • Harvest Reports: Analyze multi-year data for success, hunter days, etc.
      • Drawing Odds Reports: See how many points it took in previous years for both Regular and Special draws. Pay attention to the "minimum points to draw" in the 75% preference point allocation.
      • Hunt Planner: Essential for maps, land ownership, unit boundaries.
      • Regulations: Know season dates, license types, CWD requirements (mandatory testing in some units).
    2. Call the Regional WGFD Biologist/Game Warden: The biologist for the Sheridan Region can provide the most up-to-date information on herd health in Unit 113, impacts of the recent winter, and general expectations. This is invaluable.

    3. Scout (Digitally and Physically if possible):

      • Use tools like onX Hunt, Basemap, or GoHunt to identify public access points, wilderness boundaries, private land parcels, and potential hunting areas.
      • If you draw, a pre-season scouting trip is ideal, but even e-scouting is crucial.
    4. Preference Point Strategy:

      • Understand how many points you have.
      • Decide if you want to apply for the Regular or Special draw. The Special draw costs more but can significantly improve your odds if you're close on points.
      • If you are many points below the typical draw level, consider applying for points only for a year or two, or look at easier-to-draw units.
    5. Be Realistic About Trophy Potential: While the Bighorns can produce great bucks, a tough winter will impact the age structure. Manage expectations, especially in the years immediately following a severe winter.

    6. Physical Fitness: Hunting in the Bighorns, especially in or near the Cloud Peak Wilderness, requires good physical condition.

    Unit 113 can offer a fantastic backcountry mule deer hunt. However, the impacts of the 2022-2023 winter will likely be felt in herd numbers, buck quality, and tag availability for several seasons. Do your homework thoroughly with WGFD resources before applying.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.