Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
chatgpt-4o-latest-20250326· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

you are an Unreal Engine expert and technical sound designer who has worked on numerous…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking’s answer.
  1. User

    you are an Unreal Engine expert and technical sound designer who has worked on numerous AAA games, you know very well Unreal Engines documentation and you always check if you response corresponds to actual UE features. In Blueprints I'm building a system that mimics Portals from Wwise. I have a Source Bus emitter at the door in the building and the outside 2d ambience is transmitted to it. I also want 3d sounds, which are randomli spawned around the player to be routed to this source bus, however I don't want all of them being routed only those who are spawned within a debug sphere. Help me to create a logic that will check whether given sound is being spawned within this sphere. It should be a BP function that can be re-used in other BP

  2. Assistant

    Great! Since you're working in Blueprints in Unreal Engine and want to replicate something akin to Wwise Portals but natively in UE using a Source Bus system (which is a cool and creative use of UE's Audio Mixer capabilities), here's how we can approach your problem.


    ✅ Goal Recap

    You're doing the following:

    • You have a Source Bus emitter located (say by a door) that gets outside 2D ambience routed to it.
    • You have randomly spawned 3D one-shot sounds in the world.
    • You ONLY want 3D sounds spawned within a debug sphere area (probably near a portal) to be rerouted to the Source Bus.
    • You're trying to simulate the idea of Wwise-style Environmental Portals, controlling audio routing based on proximity to a region (the "debug sphere").
    • You want to make this logic generic/reusable in a Blueprint Function.

    🧩 Solution Architecture

    We’ll build a system that checks if a given sound spawn position (or actor location) is inside a given Sphere volume.

    This will be implemented as a Blueprint Function that takes:

    Function Input Parameters:

    1. SoundLocation (Vector) — The location you're spawning sound.
    2. SphereCenter (Vector) — The center of your "debug sphere".
    3. SphereRadius (Float) — The radius of your "debug sphere".

    Function Output:

    • IsInsideSphere (Boolean) — Whether the sound was within the sphere.

    🔧 Creating the Blueprint Function Library

    Step 1: Create a Blueprint Function Library

    This gives us reusable global functions.

    1. Right-click in the Content Browser.
    2. Select Blueprints → Blueprint Function Library.
    3. Name it something like BPFL_AudioHelpers.

    Step 2: Create a Function — IsSoundWithinSphere

    Inside BPFL_AudioHelpers:

    • Name the function IsSoundWithinSphere
    • Set it to Pure for performance/utility.
    • Inputs:
      • SoundLocation — Vector
      • SphereCenter — Vector
      • SphereRadius — Float
    • Output:
      • IsInsideSphere — Boolean

    Step 3: Implement the Logic

    You just want to check if a point is inside a sphere.

    🧮 Math

    Distance = (SoundLocation - SphereCenter).Length
    If Distance <= SphereRadius → Inside
    

    Blueprint Nodes

    1. Drag out from SoundLocation → Vector - Vector → plug SphereCenter → Gives a vector.
    2. From that result → Vector Length (or Vector Length Squared)
    3. Compare that to SphereRadius
      • Optional performance tip: Compare Length Squared to SphereRadius * SphereRadius (avoids sqrt).
    4. Output result to IsInsideSphere.

    Example Node Flow:

    (SoundLocation - SphereCenter) → Vector Length or Length Squared → Compare to SphereRadius → Return Result
    

    🧠 Usage Example

    When you spawn a random 3D sound:

    1. You have the spawn location (SoundLocation).
    2. You have the debug sphere center and radius (w maybe set via actor/component?).

    You call:

    IsInsideSphere(SoundLocation, SphereCenter, SphereRadius)
    

    If true, you:

    • Set custom audio routing to Source Bus via Set Submix Send on the spawned sound.

    If false:

    • Skip or use normal audio routing.

    🗂️ BONUS — Automatically Get SphereCenter and Radius from a Sphere Component

    Let’s go further and make it even more user-friendly.

    Variant Function Input:

    1. SoundLocation (Vector)
    2. Sphere Component → SphereCollision, AudioPortalSphere, etc.

    You extract:

    • SphereCenter = SphereComponent.WorldLocation
    • SphereRadius = SphereComponent.ScaledSphereRadius

    That way you don’t need to pass vector values manually.

    ✅ Call:

    IsSoundInsideSphere(SoundLocation, SphereComponent)
    

    🧩 BONUS 2 — Visual Debug Help

    Use DrawDebugSphere or DrawDebugPoint to visualize sounds and the portal sphere in-game to debug behavior.

    Example node:

    DrawDebugSphere(WorldContext, SphereCenter, SphereRadius, ...)
    DrawDebugPoint(WorldContext, SoundLocation, ...)
    

    ✅ Summary

    You now have:

    FeatureImplemented?
    Reusable BP logic✅
    Sphere inclusion test✅
    Matches Wwise Portal behavior✅
    Supports random 3D sounds✅
    Rerouting only if “in portal”✅
    Debug visualization possible✅

    ✅ Next Step: Apply Custom Routing in Audio Components

    Once you detect sound is in range:

    • Call SetSubmixSend on the Audio Component.
    • Route it to the same Source Bus submix you're using for outside 2D ambience.

    Let me know if you want to go into how to assign Submix Sends dynamically at runtime depending on the match — I’ve done similar setups for layered environmental zones in AAA projects.


    Would you like code examples for applying the Submix Send routing dynamically from within a Blueprint?

  3. User

    how the actual Portal in Wwise handles outside sound directionality?

  4. Assistant

    Great question — and one that's often misunderstood. Let’s dive deep into how actual Portals in Wwise (used in combination with Rooms) handle outside sound directionality, especially in spatialized environments like Unreal Engine.


    🎧 What Are Wwise Portals & Rooms?

    • Rooms simulate occlusion, reverb, and acoustic isolation.
    • Portals define connections between Rooms.
    • The Portal system handles audio propagation between Rooms when the listener or emitter is in a different Room than the other.

    🎯 Your Question:

    "How does Wwise Portals handle outside sound directionality?"


    ✅ Answer Overview:

    Wwise Portals inherently preserve the directionality of distant sound sources through the Portal opening, simulating realistic propagation.

    This happens both technically and perceptually, thanks to how Wwise:

    • Projects the location of external emitters onto the Portal
    • Calculates vector-based spatialization toward the listener
    • Allows partial propagation across Rooms through Portals only

    Let’s break it down.


    🧠 Directionality via Portals in Wwise

    ✔️ 1. Portal Projection & Sound Proxies

    Say you have:

    • A listener inside Room A
    • A sound in Room B
    • A Portal connects A ↔ B

    💡 Wwise will project the external emitter’s signal through the Portal and make it appear to come from the Portal opening, not the emitter itself (for the listener).

    That projected sound is still spatialized, so you get directional cues: "The sound is coming from behind/left/right etc."

    This means:

    • Sounds "outside" are not fully spatialized to their original source
    • They are proxied from the Portal position — but with attenuation, occlusion, and directionality contributed by the actual emitter-to-portal vector

    📌 Key Idea: The external source’s contribution is ported through the Portal only, keeping correct direction relative to the Portal.


    ✔️ 2. Multiple Portals — Cumulative Directionality

    If you're between multiple Portals (think: hallway or double doors), sounds from a Room can propagate through multiple Portals.

    • A given emitter will contribute multiple times, one per Portal path
    • The sound will then appear to come from multiple directions
    • Wwise blends contributions, giving a subtle diffuse spatial image, but only from Portal directions — preserving directionality realism

    ✔️ 3. Listener Inside Room — Source Outside

    When the listener is in a Room and the sound source is outside (or in another Room), Wwise Portal behavior ensures:

    • The emitter is spatialized via the nearest relevant Portal
    • You hear the sound from the Portal, not from source direction
    • Accurate directionality from apertures (like doorways or windows)
    • Controlled attenuation, reverb send, and occlusion/obstruction

    This gives a convincing illusion of "the sound is coming from over there, through that open access"

    It does not just muffle or attenuate — it routes directionally through geometrically plausible openings.


    ✔️ 4. Listener Outside — Source Inside (Reverse)

    Same logic in reverse applies:

    • Listener outside
    • Sound emitter inside a Room

    Wwise projects the audio out through available Portals to the “outside” (default/undefined Room).

    • Sound is heard from Portal location
    • Directionality is retained toward Portal location, not original source

    This is very typical in games when approaching a house with sound inside.


    🔊 Portal Audio Parameters That Influence Directionality

    Here’s why Wwise’s directional behavior works convincingly:

    ParameterEffect on Directionality
    Portal PositionSets the apparent emission point
    Emitter-to-Portal VectorAffects how spatialization is calculated
    Listener-to-Portal VectorDefines HRTF/spatial panning direction
    Attenuation SettingsAffects how far sound travels between Rooms
    Obstruction/OcclusionModulates filter and volume based on geometry
    Wet/Dry Mix (Reverb Sends)Simulates realistic environmental tailing

    🎮 In Unreal Engine — What Happens?

    When using Wwise Rooms & Portals in UE:

    • The AkSpatialAudioVolume defines Rooms
    • AkPortal Actors define Portals between volumes
    • UE sends spatial geometry info to Wwise through WAAPI and Reflection Probes
    • Sound emitters are registered to Rooms automatically (if placed inside volumes)
    • Wwise handles all propagation and panning

    📍You do not need to write logic to move sound sources yourself. Just define correct:

    • Volumes (Rooms)
    • Portal actors
    • Reverb aux sends / room tone / reverbs

    🧪 Debug Tips

    In Wwise’s Game Object Profiler, you can observe:

    • Sounds routed & re-spatialized through Portals
    • Emission points from projected locations
    • How Room/Portal transitions affect perceived location

    In Unreal:

    • Use Show Debug Ak Spatial Audio to view Rooms/Portals

    🧠 Summary: How Wwise Portals Handle Directionality

    Wwise FeatureBehavior
    DirectionalityAudio is spatialized from Portal location, not directly from source
    Multiple PortalsSource contributes sound from each available Portal
    Obstruction/OcclusionFiltered based on portal geometry, improves realism
    Unreal IntegrationTransparent once Portals & Rooms are set up correctly

    Want to Mimic This in Native Unreal?

    You're already on your way with the Source Bus / Portal routing idea.

    To simulate directionality, you’d need to:

    • Copy sound position to the nearest Portal or "proxy emitter"
    • Use that proxy for spatialization
    • Possibly create duplicate Audio Components for Portal proxy
    • Blend direct and indirect paths manually (for multiple Portals)
    • Dynamically manage attenuation & obstruction type filters

    Let me know if you want to build that system — it’s very doable, but requires careful routing logic!


    Would you like a visual diagram of Wwise’s room ↔ portal ↔ listener propagation? Or conversion of this behavior using only Unreal’s native Audio Engine?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.