Skip to content
The Chat Archive
mistral-medium-2505· Mistral AI LMArena Human Preference 140K

Okay I am actually adding funds every month, so I'm not sure that CAGR is the best…

  1. User

    Okay I am actually adding funds every month, so I'm not sure that CAGR is the best metric for me to track to represent how my investments portfolio is performing (and importantly try and predict how it might grow in the coming years). Should I be using TWR or IRR instead?

  2. Assistant

    Since you're adding funds every month, CAGR is not the best metric for tracking your portfolio's performance or predicting future growth. Instead, you should use either:

    1. Time-Weighted Return (TWR) – Best for Performance Tracking

    • What it does: Measures the compound growth rate of your investments independent of cash flows (i.e., ignores when you add/remove money).
    • Why it’s better for you:
      • Shows the true performance of your investments without distortion from contributions.
      • Useful for comparing your returns to benchmarks (e.g., S&P 500).
    • How to calculate it:
      • Break your portfolio into sub-periods (e.g., monthly).
      • Calculate the return for each sub-period.
      • Chain-link the returns to get the overall TWR.

    Example (Simplified Monthly TWR Calculation)

    MonthStart ValueEnd ValueCash FlowMonthly Return
    Jan$10,000$10,500+$1,000(10,500 - 1,000)/10,000 = 5%
    Feb$11,500$11,800+$1,000(11,800 - 1,000)/11,500 ≈ 2.61%
    Mar$12,800$13,200+$1,000(13,200 - 1,000)/12,800 ≈ 2.34%

    TWR = (1 + 0.05) × (1 + 0.0261) × (1 + 0.0234) - 1 ≈ 10.3% annualized

    (This is a simplified example; real TWR requires precise timing adjustments.)


    2. Internal Rate of Return (IRR) – Best for Predicting Future Growth

    • What it does: Calculates the annualized return considering all cash flows (contributions & withdrawals).
    • Why it’s better for you:
      • Accounts for when you add money, which affects compounding.
      • Helps predict future portfolio growth based on your contribution pattern.
    • How to calculate it:
      • Use Excel/Google Sheets: =XIRR(values, dates)
      • Requires a list of all cash flows (investments & current value) with dates.

    Example (IRR Calculation)

    DateCash Flow
    Jan 1-$10,000
    Jan 31-$1,000
    Feb 28-$1,000
    Mar 31$13,200

    IRR = XIRR([-10000, -1000, -1000, 13200], [dates]) ≈ 1.2% monthly → ~15.4% annualized

    (This is a rough estimate; actual IRR depends on exact dates.)


    Which One Should You Use?

    MetricBest ForLimitations
    TWRComparing investment skill (ignores cash flows)Doesn’t reflect personal return if you add money
    IRRPredicting future growth (accounts for contributions)Sensitive to cash flow timing; can be misleading if contributions are irregular
    • If you want to track performance vs. benchmarks → Use TWR.
    • If you want to predict future portfolio growth → Use IRR.

    Final Recommendation

    1. Track TWR to see how well your investments are performing independently of contributions.
    2. Use IRR to estimate how your portfolio might grow based on your contribution pattern.
    3. Avoid CAGR unless you’re analyzing a single lump-sum investment.

    Would you like help setting up a spreadsheet for TWR or IRR calculations?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.