Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

we say like dissolved like => polar disolves polar. but nh4+ dissolves in water. why?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-flash-preview-04-17’s answer.
  1. User

    we say like dissolved like => polar disolves polar. but nh4+ dissolves in water. why?

  2. Assistant

    “Like-dissolves-like” is a handy slogan, but it hides some nuance.
    Water doesn’t just like “polar” stuff; it also loves anything that can give it a strong electrostatic hug. Ions do that even better than neutral polar molecules. Here’s what’s going on with NH₄⁺:

    1. NH₄⁺ is not merely “polar” – it’s fully charged.
      • A polar molecule has a partial + and partial – end (dipole).
      • An ion has a whole-number charge. In terms of electrostatic attraction, ions are an extreme version of “polar.”

    2. Water molecules have a large dipole moment and a tight, 104.5° bent shape. The O end is δ–, the H ends are δ+.
      • When NH₄⁺ enters water, the O ends of many water molecules orient toward the positive ion.
      • These ion–dipole interactions are quite strong (stronger than ordinary dipole–dipole attractions).

    3. Hydration energy vs. lattice energy
      • For an ionic compound such as NH₄Cl(s), the crystal lattice must be pulled apart (costs energy: lattice energy).
      • That cost is compensated by hydration energy: the energy released when water molecules surround (solvate) the separated NH₄⁺ and Cl⁻ ions.
      • NH₄⁺ has a low charge density (because the charge is spread over four H atoms) → lattice energy of ammonium salts is relatively low; hydration energy is fairly high → net ΔH ≈ 0 or negative.
      • Entropy also increases when an ordered crystal becomes many free particles in solution → total ΔG < 0, so dissolution is spontaneous.

    4. Hydrogen bonding helps too
      • NH₄⁺ can donate up to four hydrogen bonds to water molecules (each N–H bond can act like an acidic H-bond donor).
      • That further stabilizes the hydrated ion.

    So the “like” water cares about is “can you give me strong Coulombic or hydrogen-bond interactions?” NH₄⁺ happily says “yes,” and the dissolution proceeds.

    Quick rule-of-thumb upgrade: • Non-polar ↔ dissolves in non-polar solvents (dispersion forces).
    • Polar molecules ↔ dissolve in polar solvents (dipole–dipole, H-bonding).
    • Ions ↔ dissolve in highly polar, high-dielectric solvents like water via ion–dipole forces.

    NH₄⁺ lands in the third category; that’s why it’s so water-soluble.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.