Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

"<![CDATA[Evaluate the double integral: \[ \int{-\sqrt{6}}^{\sqrt{6}} \int{-4}^{2 - x^2}…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with DeepSeekdeepseek-v3-0324’s answer.
  1. User

    "<![CDATA[Evaluate the double integral:

    [ \int_{-\sqrt{6}}^{\sqrt{6}} \int_{-4}^{2 - x^2} x^2 , dx , dy. ] ]]>"

  2. Qwen Assistant

    We are given the double integral:

    ∫−66∫−42−x2x2 dx dy.\int_{-\sqrt{6}}^{\sqrt{6}} \int_{-4}^{2 - x^2} x^2 \, dx \, dy.

    Step 1: Understand the region of integration.

    The inner integral is with respect to xx and has bounds:

    • x=−6x = -\sqrt{6} to x=6x = \sqrt{6}
    • For each fixed xx, yy goes from y=−4y = -4 to y=2−x2y = 2 - x^2

    So the region of integration is defined by:

    R={(x,y)∣−6≤x≤6, −4≤y≤2−x2}R = \left\{(x, y) \mid -\sqrt{6} \le x \le \sqrt{6},\ -4 \le y \le 2 - x^2 \right\}

    This is a vertically simple region (i.e., we integrate over xx first). But in this current setup, we're integrating x2x^2 with respect to xx first, then yy. The integrand does not depend on yy, so switching the order of integration might simplify things.


    Step 2: Switch the order of integration.

    Let’s describe the region RR as a horizontally simple region (i.e., for fixed yy, find the range of xx).

    From the bounds:

    • y=−4y = -4 to y=2−x2y = 2 - x^2
    • Since x∈[−6,6]x \in [-\sqrt{6}, \sqrt{6}], the maximum value of x2x^2 is 6, so the minimum value of 2−x22 - x^2 is 2−6=−42 - 6 = -4, which matches the lower bound of yy.

    So the full range of yy is from y=−4y = -4 to y=2y = 2, because 2−x2≤22 - x^2 \le 2 for all xx.

    Now, for a fixed y∈[−4,2]y \in [-4, 2], solve for xx such that y≤2−x2y \le 2 - x^2:

    y≤2−x2⇒x2≤2−y⇒∣x∣≤2−y.y \le 2 - x^2 \Rightarrow x^2 \le 2 - y \Rightarrow |x| \le \sqrt{2 - y}.

    Thus, for fixed y∈[−4,2]y \in [-4, 2], x∈[−2−y,2−y]x \in [-\sqrt{2 - y}, \sqrt{2 - y}]


    Step 3: Rewrite the integral with the new limits.

    Now switch the order of integration:

    ∫−66∫−42−x2x2 dy dx=∫−42∫−2−y2−yx2 dx dy\int_{-\sqrt{6}}^{\sqrt{6}} \int_{-4}^{2 - x^2} x^2 \, dy \, dx = \int_{-4}^{2} \int_{-\sqrt{2 - y}}^{\sqrt{2 - y}} x^2 \, dx \, dy

    Note: The original integral had dx dydx \, dy, but it's more natural to interpret it as integrating over yy first, then xx, since the bounds for yy depend on xx. So likely there was a typo in the differential order. We'll proceed assuming the correct form is:

    ∫x=−66∫y=−42−x2x2 dy dx\int_{x = -\sqrt{6}}^{\sqrt{6}} \int_{y = -4}^{2 - x^2} x^2 \, dy \, dx

    But either way, since the integrand does not involve yy, we can evaluate directly.


    Step 4: Evaluate the inner integral.

    We evaluate:

    ∫−66∫−42−x2x2 dy dx\int_{-\sqrt{6}}^{\sqrt{6}} \int_{-4}^{2 - x^2} x^2 \, dy \, dx

    Since x2x^2 is constant with respect to yy, we can pull it out:

    =∫−66x2(∫−42−x2dy)dx=∫−66x2⋅[(2−x2)−(−4)]dx=∫−66x2(6−x2)dx= \int_{-\sqrt{6}}^{\sqrt{6}} x^2 \left( \int_{-4}^{2 - x^2} dy \right) dx = \int_{-\sqrt{6}}^{\sqrt{6}} x^2 \cdot \left[(2 - x^2) - (-4)\right] dx = \int_{-\sqrt{6}}^{\sqrt{6}} x^2 (6 - x^2) dx

    Step 5: Compute the final integral.

    ∫−66x2(6−x2)dx=∫−66(6x2−x4)dx\int_{-\sqrt{6}}^{\sqrt{6}} x^2 (6 - x^2) dx = \int_{-\sqrt{6}}^{\sqrt{6}} (6x^2 - x^4) dx

    Note that the integrand is even, so we can write:

    =2∫06(6x2−x4)dx= 2 \int_0^{\sqrt{6}} (6x^2 - x^4) dx

    Now compute:

    ∫066x2dx=6⋅x33∣06=2(6)3=2⋅66=126\int_0^{\sqrt{6}} 6x^2 dx = 6 \cdot \frac{x^3}{3} \Big|_0^{\sqrt{6}} = 2 (\sqrt{6})^3 = 2 \cdot 6\sqrt{6} = 12\sqrt{6} ∫06x4dx=x55∣06=(6)55=65/25\int_0^{\sqrt{6}} x^4 dx = \frac{x^5}{5} \Big|_0^{\sqrt{6}} = \frac{(\sqrt{6})^5}{5} = \frac{6^{5/2}}{5}

    Now compute 65/26^{5/2}:

    65/2=(6)5=(6)4⋅6=36⋅66^{5/2} = (\sqrt{6})^5 = (\sqrt{6})^4 \cdot \sqrt{6} = 36 \cdot \sqrt{6}

    So:

    ∫06x4dx=3665\int_0^{\sqrt{6}} x^4 dx = \frac{36\sqrt{6}}{5}

    Therefore:

    2(126−3665)=2(606−3665)=2⋅2465=48652 \left(12\sqrt{6} - \frac{36\sqrt{6}}{5}\right) = 2 \left(\frac{60\sqrt{6} - 36\sqrt{6}}{5}\right) = 2 \cdot \frac{24\sqrt{6}}{5} = \frac{48\sqrt{6}}{5}

    ✅ Final Answer:

    4865\boxed{\frac{48\sqrt{6}}{5}}

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.