Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen-max-2025-01-25· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Whenever taking a combat injury, roll 3×1d12 and call the least roll X, the median roll…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-opus-4-20250514’s answer.
  1. User

    Whenever taking a combat injury, roll 3×1d12 and call the least roll X, the median roll Y, and the greatest roll Z. The injury heals after Z days less one day for every magical treatment. The danger of death is given by Y:

    • 1–2 (7.41% chance): No danger of death.
    • 3–4 (18.52% chance): Death after X weeks unless the injury is treated.
    • 5–6 (24.07% chance): Death after X days unless the injury is treated.
    • 7–8 (24.07% chance): Death after X hours unless the injury is treated.
    • 9–10 (18.52% chance): Death after X minutes unless the injury is treated.
    • 11–12 (7.41% chance): Death after X turns (1 turn = 6 s) unless the injury is treated.

    First aid administered within five minutes applies a -2 modifier to the Y roll, effectively extending the death timer.

    Mundane treatment is more than first aid; it represents proper attentions from a qualified surgeon, typically over the course of two hours. It can prevent death by marking an injury as treated, but does not accelerate the healing timer.

    One magical treatment is applied for every 200 mL of potion consumed, rounded down. As one liter of potion typically sells for a month's wages, this is not an everyday option for most adventurers, but also not terribly extravagant.

  2. Qwen Assistant

    This system for handling combat injuries and healing is rich with mechanical depth, balancing realism, urgency, and resource management. Let’s break it down step by step to understand its implications and how it can be used effectively in gameplay.


    Key Elements of the System

    1. Rolling for Injury Severity (3×1d12):

      • The rolls determine three values: X (least roll), Y (median roll), and Z (greatest roll).
      • These values drive the mechanics of both healing time and risk of death.
    2. Healing Time:

      • The injury heals after Z days, minus one day for every magical treatment applied.
      • This creates a tension between waiting for natural healing and expending valuable resources (potions) to accelerate recovery.
    3. Risk of Death:

      • The Y roll determines the danger level and the timeline for death if the injury is untreated.
      • The timeline ranges from weeks (least urgent) to turns (most urgent), creating escalating stakes depending on the severity of the injury.
    4. First Aid:

      • Administered within 5 minutes, first aid applies a -2 modifier to Y, reducing the urgency of death.
      • This makes first aid highly valuable for buying time before more advanced treatments can be applied.
    5. Mundane Treatment:

      • Represents professional medical care from a qualified surgeon, typically over 2 hours.
      • Prevents death by marking the injury as "treated" but does not affect the healing timer (Z).
    6. Magical Treatment:

      • Consuming potions reduces healing time by 1 day per 200 mL of potion.
      • Potions are expensive (1 liter = ~5 treatments costs a month's wages), making them a limited resource that must be used strategically.

    Probabilities and Implications

    Y Roll Probabilities

    The median roll (Y) determines the risk of death. Here’s a breakdown of the probabilities:

    RangeProbability (%)Death Timer
    1–27.41%No danger of death.
    3–418.52%Death after X weeks unless treated.
    5–624.07%Death after X days unless treated.
    7–824.07%Death after X hours unless treated.
    9–1018.52%Death after X minutes unless treated.
    11–127.41%Death after X turns (6 seconds each).
    • Low Rolls (1–4): These are relatively safe injuries, with little immediate threat to life.
    • Mid Rolls (5–8): These represent moderate injuries where timely intervention is critical.
    • High Rolls (9–12): These are life-threatening injuries requiring immediate action.

    X and Z Interplay

    • X: The least roll determines the death timer when Y is high. Lower X values give more time to act.
    • Z: The greatest roll determines healing time. Higher Z values mean longer recovery periods, which could impact adventuring schedules.

    Strategic Considerations

    1. Resource Management:

      • Players must decide whether to use potions to accelerate healing or save them for emergencies.
      • Mundane treatment is cheaper than magical treatment but requires access to a skilled surgeon, which may not always be feasible in the field.
    2. Time Pressure:

      • High Y rolls create intense time pressure, forcing players to prioritize actions like finding a healer, administering first aid, or using potions.
      • First aid is particularly valuable for high Y rolls because the -2 modifier can shift the death timer into a less urgent category.
    3. Party Composition:

      • Parties with healers or surgeons have an advantage, as they can stabilize injuries without relying on potions.
      • Parties without such skills may need to rely on expensive magical treatments or take greater risks.
    4. Pacing and Drama:

      • This system introduces dramatic tension, especially when rolling for injuries. Players will feel the weight of poor rolls and the relief of good ones.
      • It encourages creative problem-solving, such as finding ways to secure medical help or managing limited resources.

    Example Scenarios

    Scenario 1: Minor Injury

    • Rolls: 3, 5, 9 → X = 3, Y = 5, Z = 9
    • Healing Time: 9 days (reduced by 1 day per 200 mL of potion).
    • Risk of Death: Death after 3 days unless treated.
    • Action: A mundane treatment prevents death, and the party decides to wait for natural healing.

    Scenario 2: Severe Injury

    • Rolls: 2, 10, 12 → X = 2, Y = 10, Z = 12
    • Healing Time: 12 days (reduced by 1 day per 200 mL of potion).
    • Risk of Death: Death after 2 minutes unless treated.
    • Action: First aid is administered within 5 minutes, reducing Y to 8. The death timer shifts to 2 hours, giving the party time to stabilize the character with mundane or magical treatment.

    Scenario 3: Critical Injury

    • Rolls: 1, 12, 12 → X = 1, Y = 12, Z = 12
    • Healing Time: 12 days (reduced by 1 day per 200 mL of potion).
    • Risk of Death: Death after 1 turn (6 seconds) unless treated.
    • Action: Immediate first aid reduces Y to 10, shifting the death timer to 1 minute. The party uses a potion to stabilize the character, then seeks further treatment.

    Suggestions for Use

    1. Adjust Potion Costs:

      • If the cost of potions feels too prohibitive, consider scaling it to match the campaign’s economy. For example, make 1 liter of potion cost 2 weeks’ wages instead of 4.
    2. Add Variants for Mundane Treatment:

      • Introduce different tiers of mundane treatment, such as basic bandaging (slows bleeding) or advanced surgery (prevents infection), to give players more options.
    3. Incorporate Environmental Factors:

      • Allow environmental factors (e.g., extreme cold, lack of clean water) to increase the difficulty of healing or worsen injuries.
    4. Introduce Long-Term Effects:

      • For severe injuries, consider adding lingering effects like reduced Strength or Dexterity until fully healed, incentivizing players to seek magical treatment.

    Final Thoughts

    This system is elegant in its balance of randomness, player agency, and resource management. It ensures that combat injuries have meaningful consequences while providing tools for recovery. By emphasizing the importance of timely action and strategic decision-making, it enhances the immersion and tension of your game.

    Boxed Final Answer: This injury system works by rolling 3×1d12 to determine X, Y, and Z, which govern healing time and risk of death. First aid and treatments mitigate risks, while potions accelerate healing. Strategic resource management and timely interventions are key to survival.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.