Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Googlegemma-3-27b-it· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

write a website governance section on Content - include section on overview, annual…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-pro-preview-05-06’s answer.
  1. User

    write a website governance section on Content - include section on overview, annual content calendar, content roles, recommended publishing process and best practices, content archiving and retirement and content audit plan. This is for a housing and food services department at a large university.

  2. Google Assistant

    Okay, here's a website governance section focused on Content, tailored for a Housing & Food Services department at a large university. I've aimed for a balance of detail and practicality. I've included notes in brackets [ ] to highlight areas you'll definitely want to customize with your specific details. This is a substantial section, so feel free to adapt it to fit your overall governance document's style and length.


    Website Governance: Content

    Department: Housing & Food Services [University Name] Document Version: 1.0 Date of Last Revision: October 26, 2023 Owner: [Name & Title - e.g., Director of Marketing & Communications]

    1. Overview

    This section outlines the policies and procedures for creating, managing, publishing, maintaining, archiving, and auditing content on the Housing & Food Services website ([website address]). The goal is to ensure our website provides accurate, consistent, accessible, and engaging information to students, parents, faculty, staff, and other stakeholders. High-quality content is crucial for supporting student success, enhancing the university experience, and maintaining a positive departmental reputation. This governance ensures content aligns with the university's brand guidelines, legal requirements, and departmental strategic goals.

    Key Principles:

    • User-Centered: Content should be written with the user's needs and questions in mind.
    • Accuracy: All information must be factually correct and up-to-date.
    • Clarity: Content should be easy to understand and free of jargon.
    • Consistency: Maintain a consistent voice, tone, and style across all pages.
    • Accessibility: All content must adhere to [University Accessibility Policy/WCAG guidelines - link to policy].
    • Search Engine Optimization (SEO): Content should be optimized for relevant keywords to improve search visibility.

    2. Annual Content Calendar

    To ensure proactive content management and alignment with key dates, an annual content calendar will be maintained.

    • Purpose: The calendar will map out planned content updates, new content creation, and promotional activities throughout the academic year. It will consider important dates like:
      • Housing application deadlines
      • Meal plan enrollment periods
      • Move-in/Move-out dates
      • Major events (e.g., Welcome Week, Family Weekend)
      • University holidays
      • Key policy changes
    • Ownership: [Name/Team - e.g., Marketing & Communications Team] is responsible for developing and maintaining the content calendar.
    • Collaboration: Input will be solicited from all relevant departments within Housing & Food Services (e.g., Residence Life, Dining Services, Business Office). A call for content ideas will be sent out [frequency - e.g., annually in October/November].
    • Tool: The content calendar will be maintained using [Tool - e.g., Google Calendar, Asana, Trello, shared spreadsheet].
    • Review & Approval: The calendar will be reviewed and approved by [Name/Title - e.g., Director of Marketing & Communications] by [Date - e.g., December 15th] each year.

    3. Content Roles & Responsibilities

    RoleResponsibilitiesAccess Level (CMS)
    Content Strategist [Typically Marketing/Comms Lead]Develops and maintains the content strategy, oversees the content calendar, ensures content aligns with departmental goals.Admin
    Content Creator [Designated staff from various departments]Writes, edits, and creates content (text, images, videos) according to established guidelines.Editor/Author (depending on content area)
    Content Editor [Marketing/Comms Team Member]Reviews content for accuracy, clarity, consistency, and accessibility before publishing. Ensures adherence to brand guidelines.Editor
    Content Publisher [Marketing/Comms Team Member]Publishes approved content to the website using the Content Management System (CMS).Publisher
    Subject Matter Expert (SME) [Staff with specific knowledge - e.g., Dining Director, Residence Life Coordinator]Provides accurate and up-to-date information on specific topics. Reviews content for factual correctness.Reviewer
    Website Administrator [IT/Web Team]Manages the technical aspects of the website, including CMS maintenance, security, and performance.Admin

    Note: Access levels refer to permissions within the CMS ([CMS Name - e.g., Drupal, WordPress, Sitecore]).

    4. Recommended Publishing Process

    1. Content Request/Idea: A content request or idea is submitted to [Email address/Form link].
    2. Assignment: The Content Strategist assigns the task to a Content Creator and SME (if needed).
    3. Content Creation: The Content Creator drafts the content.
    4. SME Review (if applicable): The SME reviews the content for accuracy and provides feedback.
    5. Content Editing: The Content Editor reviews the content for clarity, consistency, accessibility, and brand adherence.
    6. Approval: The Content Strategist approves the final content.
    7. Publishing: The Content Publisher publishes the content to the website.
    8. Promotion: [Marketing/Comms Team] promotes the new/updated content through relevant channels (e.g., social media, email newsletters).

    Workflow Tool: [Tool - e.g., Asana, Trello, project management software] will be used to track content through this process.

    5. Content Best Practices

    • Writing Style: Use plain language, short sentences, and active voice. Follow the [University Style Guide - link to guide].
    • SEO: Conduct keyword research and incorporate relevant keywords naturally into content. Use descriptive headings and alt text for images.
    • Images & Media: Use high-quality, relevant images and videos. Ensure all media is properly licensed and accessible (alt text, captions).
    • Accessibility:
      • Use proper heading structure (H1, H2, H3, etc.).
      • Provide alt text for all images.
      • Use sufficient color contrast.
      • Ensure content is navigable using a keyboard.
      • Provide transcripts for videos.
    • Links: Regularly check for broken links. Use descriptive link text.
    • File Naming: Use clear and descriptive file names for all documents and media.
    • Mobile Responsiveness: Ensure all content is displayed correctly on all devices.

    6. Content Archiving and Retirement

    Content that is outdated, inaccurate, or no longer relevant will be archived or retired.

    • Archiving: Content that may be useful for historical purposes but is no longer actively maintained will be archived. Archived content will be removed from the main navigation but may be accessible through a search function or a dedicated archive section.
    • Retirement: Content that is completely obsolete or contains inaccurate information will be retired (deleted).
    • Process:
      1. Identification: Content is identified for archiving/retirement during content audits (see Section 7) or by content owners.
      2. Review: The Content Strategist reviews the recommendation.
      3. Approval: The Content Strategist approves the archiving/retirement.
      4. Implementation: The Content Publisher archives or retires the content in the CMS.
      5. Redirection (if applicable): If content is retired, consider implementing a 301 redirect to a relevant page.
    • Retention Policy: Archived content will be retained for [Number] years, after which it will be reviewed for permanent retirement.

    7. Content Audit Plan

    Regular content audits will be conducted to ensure the website remains accurate, relevant, and effective.

    • Frequency: A full content audit will be conducted [Frequency - e.g., annually, bi-annually]. Spot checks will be conducted [Frequency - e.g., quarterly] on high-traffic pages or areas prone to change.
    • Scope: The audit will cover all pages on the Housing & Food Services website.
    • Process:
      1. Inventory: Create a complete inventory of all website content.
      2. Evaluation: Evaluate each page based on the following criteria:
        • Accuracy: Is the information still correct?
        • Relevance: Is the content still relevant to our audience?
        • Performance: Is the page receiving traffic? Is it achieving its goals? (Use Google Analytics or similar tools).
        • Accessibility: Does the page meet accessibility standards?
        • SEO: Is the page optimized for relevant keywords?
      3. Action Plan: Develop an action plan to address any issues identified during the audit (e.g., update content, archive content, retire content, improve SEO).
      4. Implementation: Implement the action plan.
      5. Reporting: A report summarizing the audit findings and action plan will be submitted to [Name/Title - e.g., Director of Marketing & Communications].
    • Tools: [Tools - e.g., Screaming Frog, Sitebulb, Google Analytics, CMS reporting features] will be used to assist with the content audit.

    Important Notes:

    • Training: Provide training to all content creators and editors on website governance policies, CMS usage, and content best practices.
    • Communication: Regularly communicate updates to this governance document to all stakeholders.
    • Review & Update: This governance document will be reviewed and updated [Frequency - e.g., annually] to ensure it remains relevant and effective.

    I hope this comprehensive outline is a good starting point for your Housing & Food Services website content governance! Remember to fill in the bracketed information with your specific details. Let me know if you'd like me to refine any part of this further.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.