Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
DeepSeekdeepseek-r1-0528· DeepSeekHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

In the double slit experiment, we can see the particle nature of the photon when a…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o3-mini’s answer.
  1. User

    In the double slit experiment, we can see the particle nature of the photon when a device that detects the photons is placed on the slits. But were there any studies where the devices was placed there, it was capturing data but the data was never recorded? I'm asking this because one of the running hypothesis is that the photons of light collapse into strict classical travel paths when they are observed, and don't when they are not observed. So, if we have a device that observes them, but the device itself never record any data (ei the data cable is unplugged), I wonder what the photons would do

  2. DeepSeek Assistant

    That's a fascinating question that cuts to the heart of quantum measurement! The scenario you describe – a detector physically present and interacting with the photons at the slits, but its data never recorded or accessed by any conscious observer – has been explored both theoretically and experimentally. The results strongly support the interpretation that it's the physical interaction causing quantum decoherence, not the conscious act of "looking" at the data, that destroys the interference pattern.

    Here's the breakdown:

    1. The Core Principle: Decoherence, Not Consciousness:

      • The dominant view in quantum mechanics (supported by vast experimental evidence like the Quantum Eraser experiment) is that "measurement" or "observation" is a physical process called decoherence.
      • When a quantum system (like a photon) interacts with a macroscopic, complex system (like a detector), information about its state (e.g., which slit it went through) becomes entangled with and dispersed into the countless degrees of freedom of the detector and its environment.
      • This entanglement irreversibly destroys the delicate phase relationships necessary for quantum interference. The photon effectively "collapses" into a particle-like state with a definite path because of this interaction, not because a human later looks at a screen.
    2. Your Scenario: Detector On, Data Cable Unplugged:

      • In this setup, the detector is physically interacting with the photon as it passes through the slit. For example:
        • It might absorb and re-emit the photon.
        • It might cause an electron in the detector to flip its spin state.
        • It might trigger an avalanche in a photodiode.
      • This physical interaction is the measurement event. It causes decoherence. Information about the photon's path is imprinted onto the detector's internal state.
      • Whether or not that internal state is subsequently read out, amplified, digitized, sent down a cable, stored, or viewed by a human is irrelevant for the collapse. The damage to the quantum coherence is already done at the moment of interaction. The wavefunction has decohered.
    3. Experimental Evidence & Analogous Setups:

      • Quantum Eraser Experiments: These experiments explicitly test the role of information access. They involve:
        1. Marking the photon's path (e.g., tagging it with orthogonal polarizations depending on which slit it takes) – this destroys the interference pattern.
        2. Later, erasing the path information (e.g., using a polarizer set at 45 degrees to mix the polarization states) before the photon hits the final screen.
        3. Result: The interference pattern reappears when the path information is erased, even though the detector interaction initially happened! Crucially, the erasure happens after the photon has passed the slits and interacted with the path-marking device, but before its position is recorded. This proves the initial interaction did cause decoherence (destroying interference), but reversing the information allows coherence to be recovered.
      • Implication for Your Scenario: If the detector interacts and marks the path (like step 1 above), but the "erasure" step never happens (because the data cable is unplugged, meaning the path information exists within the detector system but is inaccessible), then the interference pattern remains destroyed. The information exists in the environment, causing decoherence. The lack of recording doesn't erase it.
      • "Which-Way" Detectors Without Recording: While perhaps not explicitly leaving the cable unplugged in every case, countless variations of the double-slit experiment confirm that any reliable which-way detector placed at the slits destroys the interference pattern, regardless of whether the data is actively monitored or stored. The physical presence and interaction of the detector are sufficient.

    Conclusion:

    If a device capable of detecting which slit a photon passes through is physically present, activated, and interacting with the photons, the photons will behave like particles and no interference pattern will form on the screen, even if the data cable from the detector is unplugged and no information is ever recorded or accessed.

    • Why? The physical interaction between the photon and the detector causes decoherence. Information about the photon's path becomes entangled with the detector's state, destroying the quantum superposition necessary for interference.
    • What matters is the interaction, not the recording. The collapse happens at the point of interaction with the macroscopic measuring device. The subsequent fate of the data (recorded, ignored, cable unplugged) does not retroactively change the fact that the measurement interaction occurred and decohered the system.
    • Quantum Eraser Relevance: Experiments like the Quantum Eraser show that if path information is actively erased or rendered fundamentally inaccessible before the final detection, interference can return. However, simply not recording the data does not constitute erasure. The information still exists within the detector system, maintaining the decoherence.

    Your question highlights a crucial distinction: quantum mechanics describes a reality governed by interactions and information flow within the physical world, not dependent on conscious observation or data logging. The "observer effect" is a physical phenomenon of interaction and entanglement, not a mystical one.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.

Identical first prompt