Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

between all these combinations, which ones are more likely to act as S/R levels on a…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-3-mini-beta’s answer.
  1. User

    between all these combinations, which ones are more likely to act as S/R levels on a 5min chart (possibly on 15, 30 and 60m charts as well)? you can pick the top 3 combinations

    [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 SMA, 34 SMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 SMA, 34 EMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 EMA, 34 SMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 EMA, 34 EMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 SMA, 50 SMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 SMA, 50 EMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 EMA, 50 SMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 EMA, 50 EMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 34 SMA, 50 SMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 34 SMA, 50 EMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 34 EMA, 50 SMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 34 EMA, 50 EMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 20 SMA, 34 SMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 20 SMA, 34 EMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 20 EMA, 34 SMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 20 EMA, 34 EMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 20 SMA, 50 SMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 20 SMA, 50 EMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 20 EMA, 50 SMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 20 EMA, 50 EMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 34 SMA, 50 SMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 34 SMA, 50 EMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 34 EMA, 50 SMA]
    
    [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 34 EMA, 50 EMA]
    
  2. Assistant

    Great question! When considering moving averages (MAs) as potential support/resistance (S/R) levels, especially on lower timeframes like 5-minute charts but also possibly on 15, 30, and 60-minute charts, some key factors come into play:

    • Longer period MAs (like 200 SMA/EMA) tend to be stronger S/R levels because they represent a longer-term consensus.
    • Simple Moving Averages (SMA) often act as stronger S/R levels than EMAs because they weigh all data points equally, making them more "stable" and widely watched.
    • Commonly used MAs like 20, 34, 50, and 200 are popular among traders, so combinations involving these tend to be more significant.
    • EMA vs SMA: EMAs react faster to price changes, so they can be more dynamic but sometimes less reliable as static S/R compared to SMAs.

    Top 3 Combinations Most Likely to Act as S/R Levels on 5m (and possibly 15, 30, 60m):


    1. [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 SMA, 50 SMA]

    • Why?
      • 200 SMA is a classic long-term S/R level.
      • 50 SMA is a widely watched intermediate level.
      • 20 SMA is a popular short-term level.
      • 9 EMA adds a fast-moving average for dynamic support/resistance.
    • This combination balances short, medium, and long-term SMAs with a fast EMA, making it robust across multiple timeframes.

    2. [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 SMA, 34 SMA]

    • Why?
      • Similar to the first, but 34 SMA is a Fibonacci-related number, often respected by traders.
      • 200 SMA and 20 SMA provide strong long and short-term S/R.
      • 9 EMA adds responsiveness.
    • This set is good for traders who like Fibonacci-based MAs combined with classic levels.

    3. [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 20 SMA, 50 SMA]

    • Why?
      • 200 EMA is often used by traders who prefer a more responsive long-term average.
      • 20 SMA and 50 SMA are stable, widely watched levels.
      • 9 EMA for short-term dynamics.
    • This combination mixes a responsive long-term EMA with stable SMAs, which can capture both trend and S/R effectively.

    Honorable Mentions:

    • [9 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 EMA, 50 SMA] — adds a bit more responsiveness on the 20 period.
    • [9 EMA, 200 EMA, 20 EMA, 50 EMA] — all EMAs, more dynamic but less "stable" S/R.

    Summary:

    RankCombinationReason
    19 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 SMA, 50 SMAClassic, stable, widely watched, good mix of short, medium, long-term SMAs + fast EMA
    29 EMA, 200 SMA, 20 SMA, 34 SMAFibonacci-based 34 SMA adds significance, strong long and short-term SMAs + fast EMA
    39 EMA, 200 EMA, 20 SMA, 50 SMAResponsive 200 EMA with stable SMAs, good balance of trend and S/R

    If you want, I can also help you analyze how these levels behave on specific instruments or timeframes!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.