Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Is it possible to hide link file:... behide "SHOW"? notify-send "Warning: Git Changes…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-4-maverick-03-26-experimental’s answer.
  1. User

    Is it possible to hide link file:... behide "SHOW"? notify-send "Warning: Git Changes Detected" "Unstaged changes found!\nClick to view: file://RESULTSFILE)"−aRESULTS_FILE)" -a APP_NAME

  2. Qwen Assistant

    Yes, it is possible to hide the file://... link behind a word like "SHOW", but notify-send has limitations. Specifically:

    ⚠️ Limitations of notify-send:

    • notify-send only supports very basic formatting, and does not support rich text or clickable links with custom labels like HTML <a href="...">SHOW</a>.
    • It only supports plain text, and if you include a file:// or http:// URL, some notification daemons (like libnotify on GNOME) will automatically make it clickable — but always showing the full URL.

    ✅ Workaround: Use "SHOW" as the body and open the file manually

    You can't display "SHOW" as a clickable link label using notify-send, but you can do this:

    1. Show "SHOW" in the notification.
    2. When the user clicks the notification, open the file (or terminal command) using a script or desktop notification actions.

    Here's how:

    🔧 Option 1: Use dunst + custom action (advanced)

    If you're using Dunst, you can define custom notification actions and format notifications more flexibly.

    Example:

    notify-send -a "$APP_NAME" -u critical \
      "Warning: Git Changes Detected" \
      "Unstaged changes found! Click SHOW to view." \
      -h string:x-dunst-stack-tag:git-warning \
      -a "action=show_diff;SHOW"
    

    Then in your Dunst config (~/.config/dunst/dunstrc), define a rule to execute a command when "SHOW" is clicked.

    This requires configuration and is not portable across all desktop environments.


    🛠️ Option 2: Simpler approach (standard notify-send + click handler)

    Use a shell script that opens the file manually when the notification is clicked.

    #!/bin/bash
    
    APP_NAME="Git Watcher"
    RESULTS_FILE="/tmp/git_changes.log"
    
    # Write git diff output to file
    git diff > "$RESULTS_FILE"
    
    # Notify user
    notify-send \
      -u critical \
      -a "$APP_NAME" \
      "Warning: Git Changes Detected" \
      "Unstaged changes found! Click to view details." \
      "file://$RESULTS_FILE"
    

    When clicked, it will try to open the file in your default file manager or editor (depending on your desktop environment). But again, it shows the full file:///tmp/git_changes.log.


    ✅ Best Practical Solution: Use a wrapper script for click behavior

    Instead of trying to show "SHOW" in the notification, intercept the click event by wrapping the notification in a script that opens the file manually.

    #!/bin/bash
    
    APP_NAME="Git Watcher"
    RESULTS_FILE="/tmp/git_changes.log"
    
    # Write git diff output to file
    git diff > "$RESULTS_FILE"
    
    # Show notification
    NOTIFY_PID=$$
    
    notify-send \
      -u critical \
      -a "$APP_NAME" \
      "Warning: Git Changes Detected" \
      "Unstaged changes found! Click SHOW to view." \
      -A "open_file=SHOW" \
      "file://$RESULTS_FILE"
    

    Then use something like dunstify or nclick or a DBus listener to detect the click and run a command like:

    xdg-open "$RESULTS_FILE"
    

    Or better yet, open it directly in a text editor:

    xdg-open "$RESULTS_FILE" &
    

    ✅ Alternative: Use a GUI toolkit like zenity or yad

    If you want full control over the UI:

    zenity --warning \
      --text="Unstaged changes found!" \
      --extra-button=SHOW \
      && xdg-open "$RESULTS_FILE"
    

    This gives you a modal dialog with a SHOW button that opens the file.


    ✅ Summary

    ApproachCan show "SHOW" as clickable label?Notes
    notify-send❌Only shows full URL
    dunst + custom actions✅Requires setup
    xdg-open after click✅ (indirectly)Simple and works everywhere
    zenity / yad✅Full control, GUI-based

    📝 Recommendation:

    For portability and simplicity, go with:

    notify-send -u critical "Warning: Git Changes Detected" "Unstaged changes found!\nClick to view: file://$RESULTS_FILE" -a "$APP_NAME"
    

    And then just accept that the full path is shown — most users don't mind.

    If you really want to show "SHOW", consider launching a GUI dialog (zenity) or switch to a notification daemon like Dunst that allows advanced scripting.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.