Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen-max-2025-01-25· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I am writing prompt for LLM. This prompt extracts structured info from a job post. Kind…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4.1-2025-04-14’s answer.
  1. User

    I am writing prompt for LLM. This prompt extracts structured info from a job post.

    Kind of classification.

    Prompt output is XML. I want to force model to spend more time on thinking about specific classification cases. How to do this?

    My LLM is Llama 4 Scout

  2. Qwen Assistant

    To encourage Llama 4 Scout (or any LLM) to spend more time thinking about specific classification cases when generating structured XML output, you can use a few strategic techniques in your prompt design. These techniques aim to guide the model to engage in deeper reasoning and reflection before producing its final output. Below are some approaches you can incorporate into your prompt:


    1. Explicitly Request Step-by-Step Reasoning

    Ask the model to break down its thought process into intermediate steps before generating the final XML. This forces the model to consider each classification case more carefully.

    Example Prompt:

    You are tasked with extracting structured information from a job post and classifying it into predefined categories. Before generating the final XML output, carefully analyze the job post and explain your reasoning for each classification step. Consider edge cases and ambiguities in the text.
    
    Job Post: [Insert job post here]
    
    Steps:
    1. Identify the key components of the job post (e.g., title, responsibilities, qualifications).
    2. For each component, determine the most appropriate category based on the provided schema.
    3. If there are ambiguities or edge cases, explain your reasoning and how you resolved them.
    4. Finally, generate the XML output based on your analysis.
    
    Output Format:
    <analysis>
      <step1>Explanation of key components</step1>
      <step2>Reasoning for each classification</step2>
      <step3>Ambiguity resolution</step3>
    </analysis>
    <output>
      <!-- Final XML output -->
    </output>
    

    By explicitly asking for an intermediate reasoning step, you ensure that the model spends more time thinking through the classification logic.


    2. Use a "Chain-of-Thought" Approach

    The chain-of-thought prompting technique encourages the model to articulate its reasoning process step by step. This can help it handle complex or ambiguous cases more effectively.

    Example Prompt:

    You are tasked with extracting structured information from a job post and classifying it into predefined categories. Use a chain-of-thought approach to reason through each classification decision. Explain your thought process as you go, especially for ambiguous or edge cases.
    
    Job Post: [Insert job post here]
    
    Chain of Thought:
    1. Start by identifying the main sections of the job post.
    2. For each section, think about which category it belongs to. If unsure, consider multiple possibilities and explain why one is chosen over others.
    3. Address any ambiguities or edge cases in the text and justify your decisions.
    4. Once all classifications are determined, generate the XML output.
    
    Final Output:
    <output>
      <!-- Final XML output -->
    </output>
    

    This approach ensures that the model doesn't jump directly to the answer but instead works through the problem systematically.


    3. Provide Examples with Ambiguities

    Include examples in your prompt that demonstrate how to handle ambiguous or edge cases. This trains the model to recognize similar situations in the input and apply careful reasoning.

    Example Prompt:

    You are tasked with extracting structured information from a job post and classifying it into predefined categories. Below are examples of how to handle ambiguous cases:
    
    Example 1:
    Job Post: "Seeking a candidate with strong communication skills and experience in project management."
    Ambiguity: The phrase "strong communication skills" could belong to either "Skills" or "Qualifications."
    Resolution: Classify under "Qualifications" because it describes a general requirement rather than a specific skill.
    
    Example 2:
    Job Post: "Must have 5+ years of experience in software development or equivalent education."
    Ambiguity: The phrase "or equivalent education" could belong to "Experience" or "Education."
    Resolution: Classify under "Education" because it refers to an alternative qualification.
    
    Now, analyze the following job post and classify it accordingly. If there are ambiguities, explain your reasoning.
    
    Job Post: [Insert job post here]
    
    Final Output:
    <output>
      <!-- Final XML output -->
    </output>
    

    Providing examples helps the model learn how to handle similar cases in the input.


    4. Encourage Reflection with a "Double-Check" Step

    Ask the model to review its own work after generating the initial classification. This "double-check" step encourages it to reconsider its decisions and refine its output.

    Example Prompt:

    You are tasked with extracting structured information from a job post and classifying it into predefined categories. After generating the initial XML output, review your classifications and double-check for accuracy. If you find any errors or areas for improvement, revise your output.
    
    Job Post: [Insert job post here]
    
    Steps:
    1. Analyze the job post and classify it into categories.
    2. Generate the initial XML output.
    3. Review your classifications and explain any changes made during the double-check step.
    
    Final Output:
    <initial_output>
      <!-- Initial XML output -->
    </initial_output>
    <double_check>
      <!-- Explanation of revisions -->
    </double_check>
    <final_output>
      <!-- Final XML output -->
    </final_output>
    

    This approach ensures that the model reflects on its decisions and corrects any mistakes.


    5. Introduce a Scoring System for Confidence

    Ask the model to assign a confidence score to each classification decision. Low-confidence classifications should include additional reasoning or justification.

    Example Prompt:

    You are tasked with extracting structured information from a job post and classifying it into predefined categories. For each classification, assign a confidence score between 0 and 1, where 1 indicates high confidence and 0 indicates low confidence. For low-confidence classifications, provide detailed reasoning to justify your decision.
    
    Job Post: [Insert job post here]
    
    Output Format:
    <classification>
      <category>Category Name</category>
      <value>Classified Value</value>
      <confidence>Confidence Score</confidence>
      <reasoning>Explanation for low-confidence cases</reasoning>
    </classification>
    <output>
      <!-- Final XML output -->
    </output>
    

    This technique forces the model to evaluate the strength of its decisions and provide additional reasoning for uncertain cases.


    Final Recommendation

    Combine these techniques to create a robust prompt that encourages deep reasoning and careful classification. For example, you could use a combination of step-by-step reasoning, chain-of-thought, and a double-check step to maximize the model's engagement with the task.

    Final Answer: To force Llama 4 Scout to spend more time thinking about specific classification cases, use techniques like step-by-step reasoning, chain-of-thought prompting, examples with ambiguities, double-checking, and confidence scoring. These methods guide the model to engage in deeper analysis and produce more accurate and well-reasoned outputs.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.