Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

What is the position of IFRS regarding sale and leaseback transactions with a repurchase…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Googlegemma-3-27b-it’s answer.
  1. User

    What is the position of IFRS regarding sale and leaseback transactions with a repurchase option present

  2. Assistant

    IFRS view on sale-and-leaseback arrangements that include a repurchase option

    The relevant guidance is in
    • IFRS 16 “Leases” – paras 99-103 and B45-B53
    • IFRS 15 “Revenue from Contracts with Customers” – paras B64-B76 (control and repurchase features)

    Below is a concise road map of how those standards interact when a repurchase option (or obligation) exists.


    1. First question: Does the transfer qualify as a “sale” under IFRS 15?

    IFRS 16 tells you to start with IFRS 15.
    Under IFRS 15, if the seller-lessee keeps a forward or call option to get the asset back, the customer (now the buyer-lessor) never obtains control. Therefore:

    🔑 Control does not pass → the transfer is not a sale.
    (The only exceptions are put options, which are treated differently; forwards and calls fail the sale test.)

    Reference: IFRS 15 B66-B69, IFRS 16 B45.


    2. Consequence for a sale-and-leaseback

    Because the “sale” failed, the whole transaction is accounted for as a pure financing transaction.

    Seller-lessee

    • Keep the underlying asset on balance sheet (continue depreciation).
    • Recognise a financial liability equal to the proceeds received.
    • Subsequent lease payments are split into interest expense and principal reduction of that liability (IFRS 9 effective-interest method).

    Buyer-lessor

    • Do not recognise the underlying asset.
    • Recognise a corresponding financial asset (loan-type receivable).

    No gain or loss is recognised on “sale,” because no sale has occurred.


    3. Journal-entry illustration (simplified)

    Assume carrying amount (CA) of asset = 1,000; proceeds = 1,200.

    At inception (seller-lessee):

    Dr Cash                               1,200
         Cr Financial liability                      1,200
    (No derecognition of PPE; continue depreciating)
    

    Each leaseback payment, say 100:

    Dr Interest expense (IFRS 9 EIR)         X
    Dr Financial liability                   Y
         Cr Cash                                           100
    

    4. Disclosure

    Both parties must disclose:

    • The nature of the transaction and key terms, including the repurchase option.
    • For the seller-lessee: carrying amount of the asset that continues to be recognised and the carrying amount of the financial liability.
    • For the buyer-lessor: carrying amount of the financial asset and associated credit-risk information per IFRS 7.


    5. Quick comparison: what would happen without the repurchase option?

    Had there been no repurchase option (and other IFRS 15 criteria met), the transfer qualifies as a sale. Then:

    • Seller-lessee recognises a right-of-use asset (= proportion of previous CA retained) and a lease liability.
    • Any gain on sale is recognised only for the portion of rights transferred.
    • Buyer-lessor recognises the purchased asset under IAS 16 or IFRS 16 (depending on lease classification).


    6. Key take-aways

    1. A substantive forward or call option held by the seller-lessee blocks sale accounting.
    2. The arrangement is therefore a failed sale → accounted for as a financing for both parties.
    3. All mechanics (measurement, subsequent accounting, disclosure) follow IFRS 9, not IFRS 16’s usual sale-and-leaseback provisions.
    4. Always document the analysis (control, option terms, pricing) for audit trail purposes.

    📝 Cheat-sheet

    Repurchase right/obligation?  → Yes
                ↓
    IFRS 15 control passes?       → No
                ↓
    Sale?                         → No (failed sale)
                ↓
    Accounting                    → Financing
    

    That is the IFRS position in a nutshell.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.