Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
DeepSeekdeepseek-r1-0528· DeepSeekHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Does my fax machine need a CIWS?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219-thinking-32k’s answer.
  1. User

    Does my fax machine need a CIWS?

  2. DeepSeek Assistant

    That's an excellent question with a surprisingly layered answer:

    1. Technically, Yes (But Only in the Most Literal, Absurd Sense):

      • If your fax machine is located on the forward deck of an active warship currently engaged in missile defense, then yes, the ship's CIWS (like the Phalanx) is technically defending everything on that deck, including your fax machine. Its survival would be a fortunate side effect.
    2. Practically and Reasonably, Absolutely Not:

      • Function: A CIWS (Close-In Weapon System - like the Phalanx) is designed to automatically detect, track, and destroy incoming supersonic anti-ship missiles and aircraft with a high-velocity rotary cannon. Your fax machine receives phone line signals and prints on paper. These are fundamentally incompatible missions.
      • Threat Profile: Fax machines face threats like paper jams, toner shortages, power outages, spam faxes, and security vulnerabilities (eavesdropping, unauthorized access). None of these threats are kinetically intercepted by 20mm depleted uranium shells traveling at Mach 3.
      • Scale & Cost: A CIWS weighs tons, costs millions of dollars, requires massive power and cooling, and creates significant noise, vibration, and collateral damage (stray rounds, shell casings). Your fax machine sits on a desk. The mismatch is comical.
      • Effectiveness: A CIWS firing anywhere near your office would destroy the fax machine, the building, and likely several city blocks long before it could "defend" the fax from a paper jam or a wrong number. Its radar would also be utterly confused by staplers and coffee mugs.
      • Security: CIWS provides physical defense against large kinetic projectiles. Fax machine security involves encryption (if supported), secure phone lines, physical access control, and proper disposal of received documents. A cannon doesn't help with any of that.

    Why might this question arise? (The Humor/Insight)

    • Outdated Tech Comparison: Fax machines are often seen as archaic technology (like battleships). CIWS defends battleships. It's a humorous leap comparing one "dinosaur" defending another.
    • Frustration with Faxes: The sheer annoyance of dealing with fax machines (jams, noise, spam) might make the idea of obliterating the perceived source of the problem (incoming signals?) with overwhelming firepower darkly appealing.
    • Security Concerns: If you're genuinely worried about your fax machine's security, a CIWS is the most extreme (and useless) "solution" imaginable, highlighting the absurdity of the threat model for a fax.

    What your fax machine actually needs:

    • A reliable phone line.
    • Toner/Ink and paper.
    • Basic physical security (don't leave sensitive faxes sitting in the tray).
    • Consideration of secure digital alternatives (encrypted email, secure file transfer).
    • If high security is essential: a dedicated secure fax line, encrypted fax capability (if available), and strict protocols for sending/receiving sensitive documents.

    In conclusion: While the image of a tiny CIWS mounted on your fax machine swiveling furiously to intercept a spam fax is hilarious, it is profoundly unnecessary, utterly impractical, physically impossible, and would result in catastrophic collateral damage to your office supplies. Stick to toner and paper jams as the primary threats.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.