Evaluate this ethical model: …. LLM: The case when p = 1 looks like…
- User
User: Evaluate this ethical model: ….
LLM: The case when p = 1 looks like utilitarianism. Let me plug in p = 1 to illustrate. [some math] Plugging in p = 1 did not reduce the model to utilitarianism. This is a crucial flaw.
Why might the user be unhappy with this exchange?
- Assistant
The user might be unhappy with this exchange for several reasons:
-
The response makes a strong claim about a "crucial flaw" without properly explaining why not reducing to utilitarianism is actually a problem
-
The math work is completely omitted with just "[some math]" placeholder, making it impossible to follow the reasoning
-
The evaluation appears incomplete - it only focuses on one aspect (p=1) without a comprehensive analysis of the full ethical model
-
The response ends abruptly after identifying a supposed flaw, without offering any constructive feedback or alternative perspectives
-
Without seeing the full model that was presented, the conclusion feels unjustified and potentially dismissive of the user's work
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.