Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219· AnthropicHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

can you help me with this yaml in home assistant? alias: BLINDS Bedroom description:…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-4-scout-17b-16e-instruct’s answer.
  1. User

    can you help me with this yaml in home assistant? alias: BLINDS Bedroom description: Automation to control bedroom blinds based on time, sunlight, and DND mode. triggers:

    • trigger: sun event: sunset offset: "-0:30" id: Sunset
    • trigger: time at: "20:00:00" id: closeB4bedtime
    • trigger: state entity_id:
      • input_boolean.dnd_bedroom from: "on" to: "off" id: DND Off
    • trigger: state entity_id:
      • input_boolean.dnd_bedroom from: "off" to: "on" id: DND On
    • trigger: template value_template: >- {{ states('sensor.met_office_gogerddan_temperature_3_hourly') | float > 16 }} id: baby_its_hot_out
    • trigger: template value_template: >- {{ state_attr('weather.met_office_gogerddan', 'temperature') is not none and state_attr('weather.met_office_gogerddan', 'temperature') > 16 }} id: baby_its_hot_out
    • device_id: 2af47b9300fcf239cc70b5f2c832ca22 domain: cover entity_id: d9c57312f1a60951eaf7d55d38530662 type: closed trigger: device id: Manual closed
    • device_id: 2af47b9300fcf239cc70b5f2c832ca22 domain: cover entity_id: d9c57312f1a60951eaf7d55d38530662 type: opened trigger: device id: Manual open conditions: [] actions:
    • choose:
      • conditions:
        • condition: trigger id:
          • Sunset
          • closeB4bedtime
          • DND On
        • condition: state entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom state: open sequence:
        • action: cover.close_cover target: entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom data: {}
        • action: system_log.write data: message: Closed blinds due to sunset, bedtime, or DND on.
        • action: input_boolean.turn_on metadata: {} data: {} target: entity_id: input_boolean.automation_closing_bedroom_blinds
      • conditions:
        • condition: trigger id:
          • DND Off sequence:
        • if:
          • condition: time after: "08:29:00"
          • condition: sun before: sunset before_offset: "-0:30" then:
          • action: cover.set_cover_position data: position: 98 target: entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
          • delay: seconds: 30
          • action: cover.set_cover_position data: position: 100 target: entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
          • action: input_boolean.turn_off metadata: {} data: {} target: entity_id: input_boolean.automation_closing_bedroom_blinds
          • action: system_log.write data: message: Opened blinds due to DND off during daytime.
      • conditions:
        • condition: trigger id:
          • Manual closed sequence:
        • wait_for_trigger:
          • trigger: state entity_id:
            • cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom to: open from: closed timeout: hours: 0 minutes: 1 seconds: 0 milliseconds: 0
        • if:
          • condition: time after: "08:30:00" before: "17:59:00"
          • condition: state entity_id: input_boolean.automation_closing_bedroom_blinds state: "off" then:
          • action: input_boolean.turn_on target: entity_id: input_boolean.dnd_bedroom data: {}
          • wait_for_trigger:
            • trigger: state entity_id:
              • cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom to: open from: closed timeout: hours: 2 minutes: 0 seconds: 0
          • if:
            • condition: or conditions:
              • condition: sun before: sunset before_offset: "1:00"
              • condition: time before: "21:00:00" then:
            • action: input_boolean.turn_off target: entity_id: input_boolean.dnd_bedroom data: {}
            • action: system_log.write data: message: >- Turned off DND mode after blinds were manually closed and then opened.
      • conditions:
        • condition: trigger id:
          • Manual open sequence:
        • if:
          • condition: sun before: sunset then:
          • action: system_log.write data: message: >- Turned off DND mode after blinds were manually opened and then opened.
          • action: input_boolean.turn_off target: entity_id: input_boolean.dnd_bedroom data: {}
      • conditions:
        • condition: trigger id:
          • baby_its_hot_out
        • condition: state entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom state: open sequence:
        • if:
          • condition: time before: "13:00:00" then:
          • wait_for_trigger:
            • trigger: time at: "13:00:00" continue_on_timeout: false
          • action: cover.set_cover_position data: position: 5 target: entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
          • delay: seconds: 30
          • action: cover.set_cover_position data: position: 0 target: entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
          • action: input_boolean.turn_on metadata: {} data: {} target: entity_id: input_boolean.automation_closing_bedroom_blinds
          • action: system_log.write data: message: Adjusted blinds for sunlight before 1 PM. else:
          • action: cover.set_cover_position data: position: 5 target: entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
          • delay: seconds: 30
          • action: cover.set_cover_position data: position: 0 target: entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
          • action: system_log.write data: message: Adjusted blinds for sunlight after 1 PM.
  2. Claude Assistant

    This is a well-structured automation for controlling bedroom blinds. I notice a few potential issues and improvements:

    1. You have duplicate temperature triggers ("baby_its_hot_out" appears twice with different templates)
    2. The second temperature trigger might be more reliable as it checks for null values
    3. The "Manual closed" condition has a wait_for_trigger that might not work as expected
    4. There's no default action if none of the conditions match

    Here's a revised version:

    alias: BLINDS Bedroom
    description: Automation to control bedroom blinds based on time, sunlight, and DND mode.
    triggers:
      - trigger: sun
        event: sunset
        offset: "-0:30"
        id: Sunset
      - trigger: time
        at: "20:00:00"
        id: closeB4bedtime
      - trigger: state
        entity_id:
          - input_boolean.dnd_bedroom
        from: "on"
        to: "off"
        id: DND Off
      - trigger: state
        entity_id:
          - input_boolean.dnd_bedroom
        from: "off"
        to: "on"
        id: DND On
      - trigger: template
        value_template: >-
          {{ state_attr('weather.met_office_gogerddan', 'temperature') is not none
          and state_attr('weather.met_office_gogerddan', 'temperature') > 16 }}
        id: baby_its_hot_out
      - device_id: 2af47b9300fcf239cc70b5f2c832ca22
        domain: cover
        entity_id: d9c57312f1a60951eaf7d55d38530662
        type: closed
        trigger: device
        id: Manual closed
      - device_id: 2af47b9300fcf239cc70b5f2c832ca22
        domain: cover
        entity_id: d9c57312f1a60951eaf7d55d38530662
        type: opened
        trigger: device
        id: Manual open
    conditions: []
    actions:
      - choose:
          - conditions:
              - condition: trigger
                id:
                  - Sunset
                  - closeB4bedtime
                  - DND On
              - condition: state
                entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
                state: open
            sequence:
              - action: cover.close_cover
                target:
                  entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
                data: {}
              - action: system_log.write
                data:
                  message: Closed blinds due to sunset, bedtime, or DND on.
              - action: input_boolean.turn_on
                metadata: {}
                data: {}
                target:
                  entity_id: input_boolean.automation_closing_bedroom_blinds
          - conditions:
              - condition: trigger
                id:
                  - DND Off
              - condition: time
                after: "08:29:00"
              - condition: sun
                before: sunset
                before_offset: "-0:30"
            sequence:
              - action: cover.set_cover_position
                data:
                  position: 98
                target:
                  entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
              - delay:
                  seconds: 30
              - action: cover.set_cover_position
                data:
                  position: 100
                target:
                  entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
              - action: input_boolean.turn_off
                metadata: {}
                data: {}
                target:
                  entity_id: input_boolean.automation_closing_bedroom_blinds
              - action: system_log.write
                data:
                  message: Opened blinds due to DND off during daytime.
          - conditions:
              - condition: trigger
                id:
                  - Manual closed
              - condition: time
                after: "08:30:00"
                before: "17:59:00"
              - condition: state
                entity_id: input_boolean.automation_closing_bedroom_blinds
                state: "off"
            sequence:
              - action: input_boolean.turn_on
                target:
                  entity_id: input_boolean.dnd_bedroom
                data: {}
              - wait_for_trigger:
                  - trigger: state
                    entity_id:
                      - cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
                    to: open
                    from: closed
                timeout:
                  hours: 2
                  minutes: 0
                  seconds: 0
              - if:
                  - condition: or
                    conditions:
                      - condition: sun
                        before: sunset
                        before_offset: "1:00"
                      - condition: time
                        before: "21:00:00"
                then:
                  - action: input_boolean.turn_off
                    target:
                      entity_id: input_boolean.dnd_bedroom
                    data: {}
                  - action: system_log.write
                    data:
                      message: Turned off DND mode after blinds were manually closed and then opened.
          - conditions:
              - condition: trigger
                id:
                  - Manual open
              - condition: sun
                before: sunset
            sequence:
              - action: system_log.write
                data:
                  message: Turned off DND mode after blinds were manually opened.
              - action: input_boolean.turn_off
                target:
                  entity_id: input_boolean.dnd_bedroom
                data: {}
          - conditions:
              - condition: trigger
                id:
                  - baby_its_hot_out
              - condition: state
                entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
                state: open
            sequence:
              - if:
                  - condition: time
                    before: "13:00:00"
                then:
                  - wait_for_trigger:
                      - trigger: time
                        at: "13:00:00"
                    continue_on_timeout: false
                  - action: cover.set_cover_position
                    data:
                      position: 5
                    target:
                      entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
                  - delay:
                      seconds: 30
                  - action: cover.set_cover_position
                    data:
                      position: 0
                    target:
                      entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
                  - action: input_boolean.turn_on
                    metadata: {}
                    data: {}
                    target:
                      entity_id: input_boolean.automation_closing_bedroom_blinds
                  - action: system_log.write
                    data:
                      message: Adjusted blinds for sunlight before 1 PM.
                else:
                  - action: cover.set_cover_position
                    data:
                      position: 5
                    target:
                      entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
                  - delay:
                      seconds: 30
                  - action: cover.set_cover_position
                    data:
                      position: 0
                    target:
                      entity_id: cover.blinds_upstairs_bedroom
                  - action: system_log.write
                    data:
                      message: Adjusted blinds for sunlight after 1 PM.
        default:
          - action: system_log.write
            data:
              message: "Bedroom blinds automation triggered but no conditions matched."
    

    Would you like me to explain or break down the changes I made?

  3. User

    I have a problem, sometimes when I manually open the blinds they immediately close by automation - any idea what is causing this?

  4. Claude Assistant

    This is a common issue with blind automations. Looking at your configuration, I can see a few potential causes for your blinds immediately closing after manually opening them:

    1. Overlapping triggers: When you manually open the blinds, it might be during a time when another condition is active (like high temperature or sunset approaching).

    2. State tracking issue: The "Manual open" trigger fires, but another automation condition is immediately evaluated and takes precedence.

    3. Missing delay after manual operation: There's no buffer time between manual operation and automation response.

    Try adding this to your automation:

    # Add this at the top level of your automation
    mode: queued
    max: 10
    
    # And add this to your "Manual open" condition sequence
    sequence:
      - action: delay
        data:
          minutes: 5
      - action: system_log.write
        data:
          message: Manual override - preventing automations for 5 minutes
      # Then your existing actions...
    

    This creates a 5-minute buffer after manual operation before other automations can take effect. You could also consider adding a specific "manual override" input_boolean that gets set when you manually operate the blinds and prevents other automations from running for a set period.

    Another approach is to check what's being logged in your system_log when this happens - it might reveal which specific condition is causing the immediate close.

  5. User

    Thank you very much for your help...

  6. Claude Assistant

    You're welcome! I'm glad I could help with your blinds automation issue. The immediate closing after manual opening can be frustrating, but the delay buffer should give you more control.

    If you continue to have issues or want to refine the automation further, checking your system logs when the problem occurs will provide valuable clues. Sometimes it takes a bit of trial and error to get home automations working perfectly with your specific usage patterns.

    Feel free to reach out if you need any additional help with this or other Home Assistant automations!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.