Principles - Client diversity is a key design principle. - Official client list, with…
- User
Principles
- Client diversity is a key design principle.
- Official client list, with good UX and explanation.
- TODO: create a feature baseline
- Official UX guidelines for consistency.
- Difference between protocol and clients is emphasized.
- Official client list, with good UX and explanation.
- All clients should be full-featured.
- This also encourages client diversity.
- Users can expect consistent experience.
- Encourages them to try other clients, maybe use multiple at the same time on different devices.
- Ensure that the recipient sees the messages in the same way as the sender.
- Features should be easy to implement.
- Lift as much work as possible to the server, clients should need the least amount of logic.
- State management is done on the server.
- Not wasting development resources on interoperability between a client that supports the feature and one that does not.
- SDKs should provide very good info, so LLM helpers can be used with best efficiency.
- No flagship instance.
- Truly decentralized.
- Avoids wasting resources of the core developers on server maintenance.
- True decentralization.
- Official server list, with good UX and explanation.
- Paid hosting providers too.
- Richer branding for servers.
- Official server list, with good UX and explanation.
- From a UX perspective, a messaging server is not just a parameter, it's a place to belong.
- Richer branding options.
- Mandatory web-based presence.
- TODO: is it mandatory or should be recommended instead?
- If someone wants to have an entirely different web page, create a subdomain.
- In Matrix, the only way the user interacts with their server is that they have to specify the server domain name at login. No branding, no other forms that help the user remember it.
- Designed explicitly for friends & family, and small communities.
- Maybe small companies can use it if they like the features.
- Not designed for large-scale deployment.
- Easy server hosting.
- TODO: investigate ways to run a server without a domain name
- Provide a complete OS, not just Docker.
- Zero maintenance required:
- space is managed correctly, never run out of space
- TODO: collect other possible problems
- Easy migration between servers (both accounts and rooms).
- No backwards compatibility.
- Both server admins and client users are expected to update in a timely manner.
- Most features present from day one.
- Less-featureful clients have to be correctly indicated to chat partners.
- e.g. “Your partner has no devices that could display this message type.”
- No interoperability or (hidden) graceful degradation hacks. No need to guess how the recipient sees your message. It either fully works, or the sender can see that it won't work at all.
- Canonical DMs.
- Easy key sharing in-app.
- Nobody cares about key verification, not even power users.
- Implement mechanisms to avoid MITM without key verification.
- Encryption is mandatory in non-public rooms.
Some ideas to develop later:
- import conversations from other platforms and continue the chat here
- users could import their own messages, similar to double puppeting
- maybe not import but authorize (sign) if correct, and their account becomes associated with it
- how do we know who
- difference from bridging
- the import is a one-time action, it does not remain connected
- control is wholly in the room, no remote
- maybe reuse some of the bridge metadata format
- users could import their own messages, similar to double puppeting
- no-motion mode
- servers can downsample animated images
- per-room data residency tag
- rooms refuse to accept servers with different settings
- clients must clearly show this
- can not reimport to servers when account migrated
- e.g. ["EU", "DE", "FR"]
- maybe only compliance (["GDPR"]), or both region and GDPR?
- does compliance imply every server that is compliant or only servers that reside in the given regions where the legislation is in effect?
- rooms refuse to accept servers with different settings
- search keywords for rooms/spaces
- unlinkable invites to avoid exposing social graph, but still allow only trusted users
- maybe anti-spam only, not the examct invite
- verification system could be used somehow?
- translation
- should document the translated version(s) at the time of the chat, so if a weaker LLM introduced translation errors that caused confusion in the conversation, it's apparent
- clients SHOULD feed the last
nmessages from the conversation to provide context for more accuracy - before sending, clients SHOULD ask the sender for ambigously translatable phrases, explaining the differences
- some rooms may provide their own translation services
- able to restrict to only allow those (e.g. privacy management)
- maybe use other too if allowed (e.g. when someone has expensive DeepL subscription and provides it in the given community only, but someone might have a better local model)
- location-based discovery
- enable other users discovering you by location
- enumeration-based attack vectors?
- should be restricted to room/space members, e.g. you must share at least one room in common? maybe client should enable only for certain rooms?
- must not reveal the actual location (however, it's difficult since servers know it, and anyone can run their server)
- this was discontinued by Telegram due to abuse, so no exact copy
- maybe provide a geofence for rooms, and the client automatically leaves it when leaving the area? or just sets the presence data for the room as "offline"?
- “opening hours” for rooms
- useful for stuff like live chat rooms for conferences, cafés
- can not send messages outside of the time window
- limited-time passes for rooms
- expiring room membership
- can be used for physical presence-based chatting, e.g. client periodically refetching a token from WiFi LAN server or BLE
- can be abused by leaving a small device there
- fast indexing
- allow downloading in bigger batches than in Matrix
- events are grouped, so do not use pagination windows, but the hierarchy size
- no fallback for message content
- non-techie users are extremely confused
- they may not indicate that it's not working
- it's better to deny and indicate to use other client
- clients can easily implement their own fallbacks
- authors may notice that after a fallback, a proper implementation wouldn't be too hard
- standardise how fallback must be presented (e.g. “multiparty voice calls are not supported”)
- SDKs can provide a fallback mechanism for features that they support but the client doesn't
- outdated clients must not be used
- protocol version is increased for every content change
- most features will be present from v1.0
- non-techie users are extremely confused
- paid plan on homeserver
- larger retention period
- larger media storage
- better call resolution
- must be able to migrate if the pricing changes
- may be paid by someone else (e.g. organization or family)
- appropriately show the subscription info in the client
- maybe allow more control of HS to UI?
- matrix.to style links: homeserver.domain/user
- difficulty to use when HS has web too
- maybe only a subdomain for this but not for the username, if there is a username too?
- difficulty to use when HS has web too
- matrix.to style links: homeserver.domain/user
- email compatibility
- threads
- email address shows up in conversation list
- if they register, their profile is replaced, and conversations imported
- server instance chooser
- high quality, officially maintained
- no flagship server instance in order to be truly decentralized
- support opening it from client registration flow
- client chooser
- high quality, officially maintained
- good UX research necessary
- not only present a list, but add a “choose wizard” that asks simple questions
- flagship client should not be distinguished
- if a client not recommended, still include it but indicate the reason
- high quality, officially maintained
- estimated response time
- auto-reply to DMs (even if no clients are online) is useful?
- can be replaced with rich status?
- community management tools
- “knock” forms: questionnaire for users who want to join a room
- maybe a link, similar to the anti-spam token
- external link can help concentrate the data on only one server
- irrelevant if it can be solved in an encrypted way?
- however, messaging server hides ip addr in a reliable, standardized way
- room management bot for communities
- easily associate authorized bots, to avoid scammers sending fake authorization requests for newcomers
- use cases
- allow message sending only after authentication
- can be solved with restricted threads grouped under a “new user authentication” parent thread
- it may need to be encrypted, but currently it seems that encrypted threads are unlikely to be supported in public rooms
- can be solved with restricted threads grouped under a “new user authentication” parent thread
- allow message sending only after authentication
- live streamed video
- few seconds delay can be expected
- „stage” streams where the clients MAY overlay the chat to the video feed
- may require dedicated thread?
- Q&A: moderators may select messages to show
- maybe tagging and filtering is sufficient?
- “privacy” mode
- limit metadata exposure when possible with technical settings
- prominent UI warnings and education
- “noob” mode
- similar to stranger mode, but it limits features mostly related to technical scamming
- 3rd party webhook API authentication requests
- key export
- more prominent warnings when leaving to an external app/site
- warn about possible IP address exposure
- TODO: more
- bot-provided buttons
- similar to stranger mode, but it limits features mostly related to technical scamming
- “vulnerable personality” mode
- should be client side entirely, too sensitive
- check messages for deception or abuse patterns or harmful conversations
- content filters all default to the strictest UI hiding, some can not be unhidden
- webhooks
- easy authentication, don't copy API keys around
- activity analytics
- available to space admins
- users can view their own
- can be scraped with advanced tools, so there is no point in disabling it
- only derived from the stored data, not the deleted history
- stories
- TODO: see https://telegram.org/tour/stories
- take ideas from Circles (a specialized Matrix client)
- clear info about limits
- max group size
- attachment quotas, max file sizes
- query server info for easily viewing in the client
- website
- server admin(s) alternative contacts
- hosting provider name, website
- firewall info (e.g. Cloudflare)
- whether it's 3rd party or in-house
- description
- summary
- longer
- registration openness
- server creation date maybe
- community guidelines (maybe also accessible from web? could provide a rendered HTML version)
- last seen (for federated)
- logo, cover images
- color scheme? (or at least a primary color)
- uptime
- ping
- location
- country of physical location
- jurisdiction(s)
- maximum retention time
- compliance info (GDPR, etc)
- power source (solar, hydro)
- donation URLs
- documents
- privacy policy
- terms of service
- community guidelines
- attachment size and storage limits
- federation enabled?
- list of banned/allowed federation servers
- list of banned/allowed communities
- list of server focus
- e.g. mainly for local people in Berlin
- since communities can be connected anywhere, topics should not be specified, only demographics
- external abuse report url (if someone do not have an account here)
- social media profiles of the server
- any external link (each with a label)
- maybe separate info meant for user/admin
- notes (an array of random text prominently displayed)
- maybe even at badge level? (collect use cases!)
- specify language for communities (e.g. en, fr, pt)
- user directories
- similar to spaces, but for accounts, not chats
- could be used to select “story” audiences
- user discovery
- each space could have its own
- one user can be in multiple places in the same directory
- explore extended use cases
- customer support
- in-game chat
- task management
- rich rate limiting response
- “wait 5 minutes and try again. verify your phone number for higher rate limits”
- malware scanning
- both at upload time on the server and download time via the client
- return rich error message if room can not be joined
- community banned on server
- maybe use same spamlist method -> admin creates a spam list for their server
- it's on a spamlist that the server has enforced
- maybe it could be solved by lazy membership, which converts room complexity to
O 1instead ofO n
- community banned on server
- maybe unify the bridge, content filter, malware scanner, translator into the bot API somehow?
- auto-joined rooms must be indicated (e.g. some server autojoins users to certain rooms on registration)
Some unstructured rambling:
Client implementation simplicity is the key. One of the main principles of this protocol is not limiting the client implementation languages. Devs should be able to write the clients in any library they want, even if there are no libraries. For example, we can't use libp2p from IPFS because there are libraries for JavaScript, Rust, and Go, and that's all. Sure, these are not so bad languages, but why not allow somebody to write some simple client for themselves in their favorite languages? Also, there are many tinkerers who like integrating technology into their lives in unconventional and personalized ways because they can tinker with it and implement their ideas in tech. For example, creating a simple e-ink display with an old Raspberry Pi, very low resources, and writing a lightweight, very lightweight client in Zig, and they don't want to consume much memory or CPU or anything. The protocol is based on HTTP, which can be very resource-hungry from the point of view of an embedded system, but if you have more than 200 megabytes of memory, then it's good. Sure, it could require kilobytes instead of megabytes, but we are good with megabytes. Even the slowest Linux phones have some megabytes available, but it should not require hundreds of megabytes for a DHT and complex routing and things like that. If an external proxy can provide it, okay, then it can be based on a DHT. Servers could use advanced technology between themselves, but clients must be very, very simple. No specific libraries. If the programming language has a JSON library and an HTTP library, it should work. It might need some bindings for cryptography, like libsodium or some other cryptographic library, but the cryptography implementation must be the only thing required for writing a basic client. Sure, if you look at the protocol, you notice that open location code is a requirement, so probably it will pull in a few hundred lines of open location code and some other nuances, but basically, in order to communicate, facilitate communication between the client and the server, an HTTP3 library and JSON decoding is what is required. Nothing else. It must be simple. HTTP3 is great. It is quick, it has non-blocking, multi-stream communication, WebTransport, many, many other great things, compression built in, quantum secure, or quantum resistant cryptography built in. It has many things, and a client can be written by standard browser APIs. It should not require state resolution and things like that, or distributed hash table or something more advanced should not be in the client. The client simplicity, implementation simplicity is key. One of the goals of the protocol is client diversity. This means that many of the clients must be fully featured. Features must not lock users to a few main clients, like in Matrix, where everyone uses Element and maybe FluffyChat, but nothing else. Even basic clients should provide enough features for chat. A developer could set up an authentication and basic message sending in an afternoon if they start reading the docs in that afternoon. So they are finding this protocol first, they start learning it, and at the start of the afternoon and in the evening, they have a working client that can send at least text messages. It must be that simple. So, client implementation must be simple. Put as much state on the server as possible.
Technical principles
- Modern instant messaging is not sequential — it's not IRC.
- As little connection between separate parts of the conversation as possible.
- “event” relations must not be placed far away in a DAG with different encryption sessions.
- Encryption should be based on the data structure, not on complex cryptographic schemes.
- Encryption sessions and conversation parts must not be intertwined.
- An user should be able to share a single part of a conversation with someone, without exposing other conversation parts inside the same session.
- Share only a single thread, poll or location share.
- An user should be able to share a single part of a conversation with someone, without exposing other conversation parts inside the same session.
- Some parts of the conversation shouldn't be slowed down by another feature that generates many “events”.
- e.g. a poll should not need to decrypt thousands of live location sharing positions in between the votes
- Parts must be able to conveniently deleted.
- Disappearing messages must be easy to implement.
- Delete an entire thread, poll, or even an edited message and it should remove all related events, but nothing more.
- Deletion must not break the room state.
- Deletion must not break encryption.
- Data structure must make it possible to download only the necessary parts of a certain conversation.
- download only one thread, and only the latest messages in that thread
- lessons from Matrix
- Trying to force everything into a DAG wastes lot of resources.
- Backwards compatibility wastes even more resources.
- Do not care about scalability and large deployments. If a solution is better for smaller deployments, but doesn't scale, use it. This protocol is meant for small rooms and communities.
- Protocol must prioritize simplifying the client implementations, even if it results in additional complexity on the server.
- SDKs should provide enough higher-level components to be able to implement a new client easily and avoid having soft forks (like SchildiChat and Element).
- Design must emphasize reducing server strain.
- Lazy loading where possible both client-server and server-server interactions.
Client implementation guidelines
When a client mutates something, do not rely on update propagation, proactively fetch the new data. TODO: clarify
Some ideas for later:
- put legal hold on
- official client UX guidelines
- unified client terminology
- clients must send feature flags
- e.g. when user wants to send animated sticker, it would say “your chat partner has no devices that could display this properly”
- no devices at all, or no online devices?
- read markers should indicate whether the message type is supported or not
- e.g. when user wants to send animated sticker, it would say “your chat partner has no devices that could display this properly”
- multi-account support in every client
- Cloudflare-like “global-kill” for every feature
- redact faces in photos
- federation sending errors must be clearly visible in the client (can't send because other server is unresponsive)
Server implementation guidelines
Server implementations MUST be designed for no-maintenance.
- No "getting stuck" due to too weak CPU/RAM/etc.
- Return errors instead of getting stuck and slowed down.
- No running out of storage.
- Cleverly delete redundant data and later non-redundant too.
- TODO: Avoid attacks that overload the storage to delete important data.
- Cleverly delete redundant data and later non-redundant too.
- maybe allow hosting for multiple virtualhosts?
- can spare costs
- storage
- CPU/RAM
- not running multiple processes
- no federation sending overhead between
- maybe allow batching between virtualhosts to servers hosted elsewhere?
- reduce latency between virtualhosts hosted on the same machine
- needs to solve the problem of sharding out when one server gets too big
- or simply constrain the server and notify the owner before they register it at the hosting provider
- API to easily query info about virtualhots, for privacy management info?
- could be used with DNS queries too? maybe not, if behind reverse proxy
- can spare costs
Error resilience
client crashes, so one interaction (e.g. result of a request) is lost
Challenges
How do users remember which servers did they choose?
Some ideas:
- registration confirmation email
- should not be cringe
- must not send it immediately as this complicates onboarding
- allow incoming invitations, but require confirmation for outgoing
- communicate this to the client
- simple error message?
- maybe an account status
- a requestable capability maybe? (it's meant for other use cases)
- communicate this to the client
- allow incoming invitations, but require confirmation for outgoing
figure out some more info to include in the server info endpoint
- Client diversity is a key design principle.
Assistant
This is a fantastic and comprehensive brain dump of principles and ideas for a new messaging protocol/platform! It covers a lot of ground, from high-level philosophy to minute technical details and UX considerations.
To make it more structured and impactful, I'll organize, refine, and elaborate on your points, adding context and rationale where appropriate.
Principles for a New Decentralized Messaging Protocol
I. Core Philosophy & Vision
These principles define the fundamental identity and purpose of the protocol.
-
True Decentralization & No Flagship Instance:
- The protocol must be inherently decentralized, designed to function robustly without reliance on any single entity, server, or client.
- There will be no "flagship" server instance maintained by core developers, preventing resource drain and fostering genuine distributed ownership.
- Rationale: Ensures resilience, censorship resistance, and prevents a single point of failure or control, empowering users and server administrators.
-
Client Diversity as a Key Design Principle:
- Actively encourage and enable a wide array of clients, both official and community-contributed.
- An "Official Client List" will be provided with good UX and clear explanations, potentially including a "Client Chooser Wizard" to guide users based on their needs.
- Rationale: Promotes innovation, caters to diverse user needs (e.g., accessibility, specific features, resource constraints), prevents vendor lock-in, and strengthens the ecosystem's resilience.
-
Target Audience: Friends & Family and Small Communities:
- The protocol is explicitly designed and optimized for personal use, close-knit groups, and small, private communities.
- While small companies might find it useful, it is not optimized or intended for large-scale enterprise deployments.
- Rationale: Allows for focused development on features that matter most to this demographic, avoids the complexities and compromises inherent in trying to serve all use cases (e.g., extreme scalability requirements).
II. Client Design Principles
These principles guide the development and user experience of clients built on the protocol.
-
Full-Featured & Consistent User Experience (UX):
- All clients (especially official/recommended ones) should strive to be full-featured, offering a complete set of capabilities for typical messaging needs.
- This encourages client diversity by ensuring users don't feel locked into a specific client for features.
- Users should expect a consistent experience, encouraging them to try multiple clients or use different clients on different devices.
- Sender-Recipient Parity: Crucially, the sender must have confidence that the recipient sees messages in the same way they were sent.
- Rationale: Enhances user trust, simplifies onboarding to new clients, and prevents feature fragmentation that plagues other decentralized systems.
-
Extreme Simplicity of Client Implementation:
- Clients should require the least amount of logic and complexity possible.
- The protocol should primarily rely on ubiquitous web standards (e.g., HTTP/3, JSON), minimizing the need for specialized libraries beyond core cryptography.
- A developer should be able to implement basic authentication and message sending in a single afternoon.
- Rationale: Lowers the barrier to entry for new client developers, fostering greater client diversity and innovation, including lightweight clients for embedded systems or niche use cases.
-
Server-Centric State Management & Logic:
- As much work as possible, especially state management, should be lifted from the client and handled by the server.
- Clients should proactively fetch updated data after making mutations rather than relying solely on server pushes for consistency.
- Rationale: Directly supports client implementation simplicity, reduces client resource consumption, and streamlines development by centralizing complex logic.
-
Forward-Only Protocol Evolution (No Backwards Compatibility):
- The protocol will not actively maintain backwards compatibility across major versions for content types or core features.
- Both server administrators and client users are expected to update their software in a timely manner.
- Most core features will be present from day one (v1.0).
- Rationale: Enables rapid iteration, avoids the accumulation of technical debt, and prevents complex "interoperability hacks" or hidden graceful degradation. It allows the protocol to evolve efficiently.
-
Transparent Feature Support Indication:
- If a message type or feature is not supported by a recipient's client/device, it must be clearly indicated to the sender (e.g., "Your partner has no devices that could display this message type.").
- There will be no hidden interoperability or graceful degradation hacks. A feature either fully works and is displayed as intended, or the sender is explicitly informed that it will not.
- Clients should send feature flags to partners. Read markers should also indicate support status.
- Rationale: Prevents user confusion, avoids unintended communication breakdowns, and builds trust by setting clear expectations.
-
Practical Security & Usable Key Management:
- Encryption is mandatory for all non-public rooms.
- The protocol will implement mechanisms to avoid Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) attacks without requiring users to manually verify cryptographic keys.
- Key sharing should be easy and integrated directly within the client UX.
- Rationale: Acknowledges that most users do not care for or understand manual key verification, prioritizing practical, transparent security that "just works" while providing robust protection against common threats.
-
Multi-Account Support:
- Clients should inherently support and provide good UX for managing multiple accounts across different servers.
- Rationale: Common user need, enhances privacy (segmenting identities), and supports exploring the decentralized ecosystem.
III. Server Design Principles
These principles govern the implementation and operation of servers within the network.
-
Zero-Maintenance Server Hosting:
- Server implementations MUST be designed for minimal administrator intervention after initial setup.
- This includes automated resource management (e.g., smart space management to prevent running out of disk, graceful error handling instead of getting "stuck").
- Provision of complete, ready-to-run OS images (not just Docker containers) is encouraged.
- Rationale: Lowers the barrier for individuals and small communities to host their own servers, directly supporting true decentralization.
-
Server as a "Place to Belong":
- A messaging server is more than just a domain name; it's a community and identity.
- Servers should offer rich branding options (logos, cover images, color schemes, custom descriptions, community guidelines).
- Mandatory (or strongly recommended) web-based presence for each server instance, potentially at a subdomain.
- Rationale: Fosters a stronger sense of identity and community for users, making server choice more meaningful than just a technical parameter.
-
Easy Migration & Portability:
- The protocol must support seamless migration of both user accounts and rooms between different servers.
- Rationale: Prevents server lock-in, increases user freedom, and contributes to the overall health and flexibility of the decentralized network.
-
Comprehensive Server Information Endpoint:
- Each server must expose a public, standardized endpoint providing detailed information about itself for display in clients.
- This includes (but is not limited to): website, admin contacts, hosting provider, firewall info, description (summary/long), registration openness, creation date, community guidelines, uptime, ping, physical location/jurisdiction, data retention policy, compliance info (GDPR), power source, donation URLs, attached documents (privacy policy, ToS), attachment limits, federation status, banned/allowed servers/communities, server focus/demographics, external abuse report URL, social media profiles, and notes.
- Rationale: Empowers users to make informed choices about which server to join or interact with, fostering trust and transparency.
-
Support for Virtual Hosting:
- Allow a single server instance to host multiple distinct virtual domains (virtualhosts).
- Rationale: Can reduce infrastructure costs, optimize resource usage, and potentially lower latency for users on different virtual hosts on the same physical machine. This needs careful consideration for sharding if a virtualhost grows too large.
IV. Protocol & Technical Principles
These principles define the underlying architecture and technical decisions of the protocol.
-
Modern, Loosely Coupled Data Model:
- Instant messaging is not sequential like IRC. The protocol's data structure must reflect this.
- Emphasize minimal connections between separate parts of a conversation. "Events" (messages, polls, reactions) should be as independent as possible.
- Encryption should be applied to self-contained data units, not complex, intertwined cryptographic sessions that span entire conversation histories.
- Rationale: Facilitates independent deletion of specific messages/threads/polls without breaking room state or encryption; allows for downloading only necessary parts of a conversation (e.g., one thread, latest messages); and avoids the resource-intensive complexity of DAG-based models (lessons learned from Matrix).
-
Simplified Client-Server Interaction:
- The protocol must explicitly prioritize simplifying client implementations, even if it results in additional complexity on the server side.
- Rationale: Reinforces the "Client Implementation Simplicity" principle, leading to more diverse and innovative clients.
-
High-Quality SDKs & Documentation:
- Software Development Kits (SDKs) should be comprehensive, well-documented, and provide high-level components to prevent soft forks (like
SchildiChatvs.Element). - SDKs should provide excellent meta-information, making them highly usable with AI/LLM-based developer helpers.
- Rationale: Accelerates client development, ensures consistency, and reduces fragmentation within the client ecosystem.
- Software Development Kits (SDKs) should be comprehensive, well-documented, and provide high-level components to prevent soft forks (like
-
Focus on Small Deployments, Not Hyperscale:
- If a solution is demonstrably better for small deployments but does not inherently scale to millions of users or complex enterprise setups, it should be chosen.
- Rationale: Aligns with the "Target Audience" principle, preventing over-engineering and allowing for more elegant solutions tailored to the intended use case.
V. User Experience (UX) Principles
Beyond client features, these principles ensure a positive overall user journey.
-
Guided Client & Server Onboarding:
- Provide high-quality, officially maintained "Chooser Wizards" for both clients and server instances, asking simple questions to guide user selection rather than just presenting a list.
- Clearly indicate reasons if a client or server is not recommended.
- Rationale: Addresses choice paralysis for new users entering a decentralized ecosystem, improving initial onboarding and long-term user satisfaction.
-
Canonical Direct Messages (DMs):
- DMs should be a clear, fundamental concept, easy to initiate and manage.
- Rationale: DMs are a core primitive of instant messaging; making them straightforward is crucial for basic usability.
-
Contextual User Modes:
- "Noob" Mode: A client-side feature that limits exposure to technical scamming vectors (e.g., third-party webhook API authentication requests, key export), provides more prominent warnings for external links, and simplifies UI.
- "Vulnerable Personality" Mode: A strictly client-side feature that employs content filters to detect and warn about deception, abuse patterns, or harmful conversations. Some content filters may be unmodifiable by the user.
- Rationale: Provides user-friendly safety nets, empowering users with varying levels of technical literacy or personal vulnerability to use the platform securely.
-
Rich & Actionable Error Messages:
- All errors (e.g., server issues, room joining failures, rate limits) should return clear, human-readable messages with actionable advice (e.g., "Wait 5 minutes and try again. Verify your phone number for higher rate limits," or "This community is banned on your server.").
- Rationale: Reduces user frustration, helps users self-diagnose and resolve issues, and improves overall usability.
VI. Future / Advanced Features & Considerations (Ideas to Develop Later)
These are specific features or considerations that align with the above principles and can be explored post-launch.
A. Interoperability & Migration
- Conversation Import: Allow users to import their own message history from other platforms (e.g., WhatsApp, Telegram, Signal), possibly by signing/authorizing. This is a one-time import, not a persistent bridge.
- Email Compatibility: Allow conversations to include email addresses, where a registered user's profile replaces their email, and conversations can be imported.
B. Content & Media Enhancements
- "No-Motion" Mode: Servers can downsample or convert animated images to static to save bandwidth or accommodate user preferences.
- Built-in Translation:
- Clients should feed recent conversation context to LLMs for more accurate translations.
- Before sending, clients should flag ambiguously translatable phrases for sender clarification.
- Rooms may offer their own preferred translation services (e.g., privacy-focused), allowing or restricting other options.
- Translated versions should be documented with the original message for context/audit.
- Live Streamed Video: Support for "stage" streams with a few seconds delay, where clients can overlay chat to the video feed. Moderators can select Q&A messages.
- Malware Scanning: Both server-side during upload and client-side during download.
- Stories: A popular ephemeral content format.
C. Community & Moderation Tools
- "Opening Hours" for Rooms: Restrict message sending outside of defined time windows (e.g., for conference support, cafes).
- Limited-Time Passes for Rooms: Expiring memberships, useful for physical presence (e.g., WiFi/BLE token-based entry for events).
- Search Keywords for Rooms/Spaces: Aid discovery and organization.
- "Knock" Forms: Questionnaires for users wanting to join a room, possibly via unlinkable invite links or integrated within the chat.
- Room Management Bots: Easily associate authorized bots for tasks like authentication or content filtering, avoiding scammer impersonation.
- Community Guidelines: Easily accessible and integrated into server/room info.
D. Privacy & Control
- Per-Room Data Residency Tags: Rooms can refuse servers with conflicting data residency settings (e.g.,
["EU", "GDPR"]). Clients must clearly show this. - Unlinkable Invites: Allow trusted users to invite without exposing the full social graph, potentially via anti-spam tokens.
- "Privacy" Mode: Technical settings to limit metadata exposure with prominent UI warnings and education.
- Activity Analytics: Available to space/room admins and users for their own activity, derived from stored (not deleted) data.
- User Directories: Similar to spaces but for accounts, enabling user discovery and selecting audiences (e.g., for stories).
E. Monetization & Hosting
- Paid Plans on Homeservers: For features like larger retention, media storage, better call resolution. Must support migration if pricing changes and show subscription info clearly.
F. Discovery & Presence
- Location-Based Discovery (Carefully Implemented): Enable discovery by location (e.g., in shared rooms) without revealing exact coordinates. Must address Telegram's past abuse issues (e.g., restricting to shared room members, client-side geofencing with auto-leave/presence change).
- Estimated Response Time: In DMs.
- Auto-Reply to DMs: Even if no clients are online (could be replaced by rich status).
G. Technical Enhancements
- Fast Indexing: Grouped events, allowing larger batch downloads for quick initial sync, moving beyond pagination windows.
- Webhooks: Easy authentication without copying API keys.
- Rich Rate Limiting Responses: Detailed messages for users.
- Unified Bot API: Potentially unify bridges, content filters, malware scanners, and translators through a robust bot API.
VII. Challenges
- User Memory of Server Choice: How do users easily remember and identify their chosen server(s) beyond a domain name? (Server branding and web presence help, but consider client-side "favorites" or clear display).
- Spam & Abuse in Decentralized Systems: How to effectively combat spam, misinformation, and abuse in a truly decentralized environment without central authority? (Community guidelines, server-side blocklists, reporting tools, trusted bots, unlinkable invites, "knock" forms).
- Registration Confirmation: How to implement non-cringe registration confirmation (e.g., email) that doesn't hinder onboarding but allows for necessary security (e.g., allowing incoming invites but requiring confirmation for outgoing actions)?
This organized structure provides a clear vision for the protocol, distinguishing between fundamental principles and future features, while acknowledging the inherent challenges of a decentralized system.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.