Skip to content
The Chat Archive
deepseek-r1-0528· DeepSeek LMArena Human Preference 140K

I'm searching for old classic rock song. IIRC there might be repeated part going like…

  1. User

    I'm searching for old classic rock song. IIRC there might be repeated part going like "When I ... forever"

  2. Assistant

    Based on the clue "When I ... forever" as a repeated part in a classic rock song, here are the most likely candidates, considering potential mishearings:

    1. Def Leppard - "Bringin' On the Heartbreak" (1981):

      • The Lyric: The chorus repeats: "`Bringin' on the heartbreak / Takin' all the best you've got / When I'm with you, forever and ever / Bringin' on the backbeat / Bringin' on the heartbreak / Yeah!"
      • Why it fits: This is the strongest match. It features the exact phrase structure "When I'm with you, forever and ever" prominently in the chorus. It's a classic rock staple from the early 80s.
    2. Boston - "Foreplay / Long Time" (1976):

      • The Lyric: The "Long Time" section features: "When I'm tired / Thinkin' why / I'm alone... It's been such a long time... I think I should be goin', yeah." While not "forever," the "When I'm tired..." part is prominent and repeated. "Forever" appears later ("I get so lonely when I am without you"), but not directly linked.
      • Why it fits: If "tired" was misheard or remembered as part of a phrase ending with "forever," this could be it. It's a quintessential classic rock song with repeated sections.
    3. Journey - "Faithfully" (1983):

      • The Lyric: The chorus features: "Oh, girl, you stand by me / I'm forever yours... faithfully." The bridge has: "We all need the clowns to make us smile... Through space and time, always another show... And I will always be there, forever and a day... Ever after?"
      • Why it fits: While not starting with "When I," it heavily features "forever" and "always" in emotionally charged, repeated sections ("forever yours," "forever and a day"). The sentiment is similar, and it's a huge classic rock ballad.
    4. Scorpions - "Still Loving You" (1984):

      • The Lyric: The chorus repeats: "If I / Would go / Would you cry? ... Forever and a day / If I / Would go / Would you cry / If I / Would go / Would you die / Inside?" and "Still loving you... I need your love... Still loving you... Forever."
      • Why it fits: "If I" sounds very close to "When I," especially sung. "Forever" is central to the chorus and repeated intensely. It's a massive power ballad from the classic rock era.
    5. Boston - "More Than a Feeling" (1976):

      • The Lyric: Features the repeated line "I see my Marianne walkin' away." While not "When I... forever," it's a very prominent, repeated phrase in a classic rock anthem. It's included here because "Marianne walkin' away" could be misheard as something like "When I'm walkin' away" or similar, especially with the trailing sound.
      • Why it fits: If the memory involves a prominent repeated phrase in a Boston song, this is their biggest hit, though the lyric match is weaker.

    Key Considerations:

    • Mishearing: "When I" is easily confused with "If I" (Scorpions), "We will" (Queen - see below), or even parts of words like "Marianne" (Boston).
    • "Forever" Placement: The "forever" part might be separated slightly from the "When I" part in the lyric structure.
    • Era: All these songs are firmly in the "classic rock" canon (mid-70s to mid-80s).
    • Feel: Most of these are power ballads or have a soaring, anthemic quality.

    Less Likely, but Mentioned Often:

    • Queen - "Who Wants to Live Forever" (1986): Features "Forever" heavily ("Who wants to live forever? / Forever is our today"), but not "When I...". The vibe is different.
    • Meat Loaf - "I'd Do Anything For Love (But I Won't Do That)" (1993): Has "Forever" prominently ("And I would do anything for love... I'd run right into hell and back... Forever"), but not "When I" and is arguably more hard rock/metal theater than classic rock. Also later.
    • KISS - "Forever" (1990): Title track, lots of "Forever," but not "When I..." and later than the classic rock peak.

    Recommendation:

    1. Listen to the chorus of Def Leppard's "Bringin' On the Heartbreak" - This is the closest direct match.
    2. If not, try Scorpions' "Still Loving You" - The "If I..." sounds very much like "When I...".
    3. Then try Boston's "Foreplay/Long Time" - For the prominent "When I'm tired..." section.
    4. Then Journey's "Faithfully" - For the heavy use of "forever" in repeated, emotional sections.

    Do any of these sound familiar? If not, do you remember anything else? Male or female singer? Fast or slow? Any other words or the general feel? The year you heard it? Knowing more could help pinpoint it!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.