Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

How find how many scientific papers has about microorganisms and nitrogen fixation ?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4.1-2025-04-14’s answer.
  1. User

    How find how many scientific papers has about microorganisms and nitrogen fixation ?

  2. Assistant

    Below is a practical, step-by-step “recipe” you can follow to discover (and even keep track of) how many scientific papers exist on the topic “microorganisms AND nitrogen fixation.”


    1. Decide which database(s) you’ll trust for the count

    DatabaseStrengthsTypical Result Counter?Free?
    PubMed / MEDLINEBiomedical & life-sciences journalsYes (top of results)✅
    Web of Science Core CollectionMultidisciplinary, citation toolsYes❌ (institution)
    ScopusBroad coverage, good analyticsYes❌ (institution)
    Google ScholarVery broad, grey lit includedYes (rough estimate)✅
    Dimensions, Crossref, Lens.orgAPI friendly, patentsYesMostly ✅

    The number you get will differ per database because of coverage differences, so pick the source that matters most to you (or report more than one).


    2. Build a solid search string

    Key concepts:

    1. “microorganisms” ≈ microbe*, bacteri*, archae*, cyanobacteria, diazotroph*, etc.
    2. “nitrogen fixation” ≈ “nitrogen fixation”, “nitrogen-fixing”, nitrogenase, “N₂ fixation”, diazotrophy

    Boolean template (most databases accept this syntax):

    ( microbe* OR microorganism* OR bacteri* OR archae* OR cyanobacteria
      OR diazotroph* )
    AND
    ( "nitrogen fixation" OR "nitrogen-fixing" OR nitrogenase* OR "N2 fixation"
      OR diazotroph* OR diazotrophy )
    

    Tips
    • Use the asterisk () as a wildcard (bacteri = bacteria, bacterial, bacterium).
    • Put phrases in quotes.
    • Some databases need the phrase “N2” instead of “N₂”.


    3. Run the query & read the counter

    Example: PubMed

    1. Go to https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
    2. Paste the query (or refine with [Title/Abstract])
    3. Hit Search – PubMed shows a result count at the top (e.g., “3,482 results”).
    4. Use “Publication dates” filter on the left for trend lines.

    Example: Web of Science

    1. Advanced Search → paste query.
    2. Change field to TOPIC (looks in Title, Abstract, Keywords).
    3. Click Analyze results → Publication Years for a graph.
    4. The count appears above the list.

    Example: API / scripted count (reproducible)

    Python + NCBI Entrez:

    from Bio import Entrez
    Entrez.email = "you@example.com"
    query = '(microbe*[Title/Abstract] OR bacteri*[Title/Abstract] OR ... ) AND ("nitrogen fixation"[Title/Abstract] OR nitrogenase[Title/Abstract])'
    handle = Entrez.esearch(db="pubmed", term=query, retmax=0)
    record = Entrez.read(handle)
    print("PubMed hits:", record["Count"])
    

    4. Clean up & refine (if the number looks suspicious)

    • Remove obviously irrelevant terms (e.g., “nitrogen fixation” in geology).
    • Limit to Title or Title/Abstract if you want only papers where the topic is central.
    • Use document type filters: Article, Review, Conference Paper, etc.
    • Consider time period: e.g., 2000–2023.


    5. (Optional) Track publications over time

    Most databases let you export the yearly counts to Excel/R for plotting.
    Example in R using bibliometrix:

    library(bibliometrix)
    res <- biblioSearch(
        query = 'TOPIC: (microorganism* AND "nitrogen fixation")',
        db = "scopus",
        api_key = "YOURKEY"
    )
    plot(x = res$Years, y = res$Freq, type = "l", main = "Trend")
    

    6. Report your findings transparently

    A short example statement:

    “Using Web of Science (Core Collection, search run 14 May 2024) with the query (TS=(microorganism* OR bacteri* OR archaea* OR cyanobacteria OR diazotroph*) AND TS=("nitrogen fixation" OR nitrogenase*)) returned 4,215 records (articles + reviews, 1900–2024).”

    Include:
    • Database & date searched
    • Exact query string
    • Filters (years, doc types)


    FAQ

    Q : Why does Google Scholar say 18,000 while Scopus says 3,900?
    A : Scholar indexes theses, books, preprints, web pages, and sometimes duplicates; Scopus is stricter.

    Q : Can I get a definitive global count?
    A : Not really—coverage is always partial. Give a range or quote multiple sources.

    Q : I only want reviewed journal articles from the last 5 years.
    A : Add filters Article + year range (e.g., 2019–2024) and re-check the counter.


    🚀 That’s it! With this workflow you can quickly grab a credible number, refine it, and even automate future updates. Happy literature hunting!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.