Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I'm trying to remember an mmorpg that had a crafting system that people didn't…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with MiniMaxminimax-m1’s answer.
  1. User

    I'm trying to remember an mmorpg that had a crafting system that people didn't understand for like 10 years

  2. Gemini Assistant

    You are almost certainly thinking of Final Fantasy XI (FFXI).

    Its crafting system is legendary for being one of the most complex, unforgiving, and misunderstood systems in any MMORPG. The "not understanding it for 10 years" is not an exaggeration; it was a decade of myth, superstition, and community-led science before data mining finally confirmed the truth.

    Here's a breakdown of what made FFXI's crafting system so mysterious:

    The Basics (What People Knew)

    On the surface, it was simple. You got a specific type of crystal (Fire, Ice, Wind, etc.) and combined it with ingredients. If you were successful, you got an item. If you failed, you lost your ingredients and sometimes the crystal.

    The Mystery (The Hidden Mechanics)

    The success rate was not a simple percentage. For years, the community furiously debated and tested a huge number of hidden variables that seemed to influence the outcome of a craft (or "synthesis"). These included:

    1. Direction: The single most famous myth. Players swore that facing a specific direction (North, Southeast, etc.) while crafting would improve success rates or the chance of getting a High-Quality (HQ) item. People would have maps of the best "crafting spots" in cities.

    2. Vana'diel Day of the Week: The in-game world of Vana'diel had an 8-day week, with each day corresponding to an element (Firesday, Iceday, Watersday, etc.). The common theory was that crafting with a crystal on its corresponding day (e.g., using a Fire Crystal on Firesday) was either better or worse.

    3. Moon Phase: FFXI has a visible moon cycle. Players meticulously tracked the moon phase, believing that crafting during a full moon, new moon, or waxing/waning phase had a significant impact.

    4. Guild Support: You could get "synthesis support" from your crafting guild. This was a known mechanic, but the exact statistical benefit it provided was a mystery for a long time.

    5. Player's HP/MP: Some players believed that crafting with low HP or MP could influence the outcome.

    6. Gear: Certain pieces of gear gave +1 to a craft, but the exact formula for how skill level affected success was unknown.

    The "Decade-Long" Unraveling

    For the better part of a decade (FFXI was released in 2002), all of this was based on anecdotal evidence, massive player-run data collection projects, and a lot of superstition. The community wikis were filled with theories.

    The Revelation:

    It wasn't until around 2011-2013, when dataminers were finally able to dig deep into the game's files, that the truth was revealed.

    • Direction was FALSE: The most famous theory was completely debunked. Facing a certain direction did absolutely nothing. All those years of players running to a specific corner were for naught.
    • Day of the Week was TRUE: Crafting on a day that was "strong" against your crystal's element increased your skill-up rate but decreased your success rate. Crafting on a day "weak" to your element did the opposite.
    • Moon Phase was TRUE: The moon phase had a significant impact on HQ rates and success.
    • Guild Support was TRUE: The exact (and very powerful) statistical benefits were finally quantified.

    The fact that the community was right about some things (Day, Moon) and spectacularly wrong about others (Direction) is what makes the story so compelling. Final Fantasy XI's crafting wasn't just a game mechanic; it was a decade-long scientific experiment run by its players.

    No other MMORPG has a crafting system with a history quite like it. If you remember a game where people argued about which way to face while crafting, it was definitely Final Fantasy XI.

  3. User

    I think it might be Ryzom

  4. Gemini Assistant

    Ah, you're absolutely right to bring up Ryzom (also known as The Saga of Ryzom)! It is another fantastic candidate for this title, though for very different reasons than Final Fantasy XI.

    While FFXI's crafting mystery was about hidden, external variables (like moon phase and direction), Ryzom's complexity was entirely internal to the system itself. It was less about myth and superstition and more about being a deeply complex, almost programmatic system of engineering.

    Here’s why Ryzom's crafting system is legendary for its difficulty and depth:

    The Ryzom Crafting System: A Deep Dive

    Ryzom's crafting was not about following simple recipes. It was a modular, component-based system where you essentially designed items from the ground up.

    1. Modular Plans (Stanzas): You didn't just have a "recipe" for a sword. You had a "plan" that was built from individual instruction lines called "stanzas."

      • One stanza might define the item type (e.g., "One-Handed Sword").
      • Another stanza would add a feature (e.g., "Increase Damage").
      • Another could add a different feature (e.g., "Add Acid Damage").
      • Another could modify durability (e.g., "Increase Durability"). You could mix and match these stanzas to create a custom blueprint for an item.
    2. Material Properties are Everything: This is the core of the complexity. Every single raw material in the game (a piece of wood, a creature's tooth, a plant fiber) had a range of stats. For example, a piece of wood wasn't just "wood." It had specific values for:

      • Durability
      • Flexibility
      • Weight
      • Damage types (blunt, piercing, slash)
      • Elemental affinities
      • And many more...
    3. The Combination is Key: When you crafted an item, the system would look at your "plan" (the stanzas) and the "materials" you used. The quality of the final item was a direct result of how well the properties of your chosen materials matched the requirements of your plan.

      • Want to make a high-damage sword? You needed to find materials with a high "slashing damage" property.
      • Want to make it lightweight? You needed to use materials with low weight values.
      • Often, these were trade-offs. The best material for damage might be very heavy. The master crafter's job was to find the perfect balance of materials to create the optimal item for a specific purpose.

    Why It Was "Not Understood for Years"

    The sheer combinatorial explosion of this system meant that it was nearly impossible for any one person to master.

    • Discovery: The properties of materials weren't always obvious. It took years of community effort, with harvesters and crafters working together, to create databases of what materials had what stats.
    • No "Best in Slot": Because you could design items for any purpose, there wasn't a single "best sword." There was the best sword for fighting a specific creature, or the best armor for resisting a certain type of magic.
    • Interdependence: The system created a deep and meaningful economy. A crafter couldn't just do everything. They needed a harvester to go out and find that specific quality of Gubani wood from a specific high-level area to make their masterpiece.
    • It Was Engineering, Not Cooking: It was less like following a recipe and more like being an engineer with a set of blueprints and a warehouse of components. The community spent years experimenting with stanza combinations and material sources to figure out optimal designs.

    Conclusion: FFXI vs. Ryzom

    You are likely remembering Ryzom if the complexity you recall was about:

    • Designing items from parts.
    • The specific quality and stats of raw materials being incredibly important.
    • A system that felt more like programming or engineering than following a recipe.

    If the mystery was about superstition, facing certain directions, or the time of day, that was Final Fantasy XI.

    Both games have a legitimate claim to a crafting system that took the community the better part of a decade to truly unravel. Ryzom's is a masterpiece of sandbox design, and it's a great game to remember for that reason

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.