Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash-preview-04-17· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

give me example of cremona transformation that cubic equation map to cubic euation

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.0-flash-001’s answer.
  1. User

    give me example of cremona transformation that cubic equation map to cubic euation

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, here is an example of a Cremona transformation that maps a specific cubic curve to another cubic curve.

    The most famous and simplest non-linear Cremona transformation is the standard quadratic transformation (also known as the standard Cremona transformation or the Jonquieres transformation). It is a birational map from the projective plane P2\mathbb{P}^2 to itself.

    Let (x:y:z)(x:y:z) be homogeneous coordinates in P2\mathbb{P}^2. The standard quadratic transformation TT is defined by: T(x:y:z)=(yz:xz:xy)T(x:y:z) = (yz : xz : xy)

    This map is defined everywhere except at the three base points where all components are zero: yz=0,xz=0,xy=0yz=0, xz=0, xy=0. These are the points P1=(1:0:0)P_1=(1:0:0), P2=(0:1:0)P_2=(0:1:0), and P3=(0:0:1)P_3=(0:0:1) (the vertices of the coordinate triangle).

    The inverse transformation T−1T^{-1} is given by essentially the same formula. If we denote the target coordinates by (u:v:w)(u:v:w), so (u:v:w)=(yz:xz:xy)(u:v:w) = (yz : xz : xy), we can find the inverse map (u:v:w)↦(x:y:z)(u:v:w) \mapsto (x:y:z). For non-zero x,y,zx,y,z, we have uv=(yz)(xz)=xz2uv = (yz)(xz) = xz^2, uw=(yz)(xy)=xy2zuw = (yz)(xy) = xy^2 z, vw=(xz)(xy)=x2yzvw = (xz)(xy) = x^2 yz, and uvw=x2y2z2uvw = x^2 y^2 z^2. Then x=x2yzyz=vwux = \frac{x^2 yz}{yz} = \frac{vw}{u} (if u,y,z≠0u, y, z \neq 0). Similarly, y=uwvy = \frac{uw}{v} and z=uvwz = \frac{uv}{w}. In projective coordinates, scaling does not matter, so we can take the inverse map as: T−1(u:v:w)=(vw:uw:uv)T^{-1}(u:v:w) = (vw : uw : uv)

    This inverse map is undefined at the points Q1=(1:0:0),Q2=(0:1:0),Q3=(0:0:1)Q_1=(1:0:0), Q_2=(0:1:0), Q_3=(0:0:1) in the (u:v:w)(u:v:w) plane.

    Effect of T on the Degree of a Curve:

    Let CC be an irreducible curve of degree dd defined by the equation F(x,y,z)=0F(x,y,z)=0. The image of CC under TT is the curve C′C'. If CC does not pass through any of the base points P1,P2,P3P_1, P_2, P_3, its image C′C' is given by substituting the inverse map: F(vw,uw,uv)=0F(vw, uw, uv) = 0. The degree of this new polynomial in u,v,wu,v,w would be d×2=2dd \times 2 = 2d.

    However, if the curve CC passes through the base points, the situation is more complex due to blowing up and down. The standard quadratic transformation blows up the points P1,P2,P3P_1, P_2, P_3 to lines (the exceptional curves u=0,v=0,w=0u=0, v=0, w=0). The degree of the strict transform C′C' of a curve CC of degree dd with multiplicities m1,m2,m3m_1, m_2, m_3 at P1,P2,P3P_1, P_2, P_3 respectively is given by the formula: deg⁡(C′)=2d−m1−m2−m3\deg(C') = 2d - m_1 - m_2 - m_3.

    Finding a Cubic Mapped to a Cubic:

    We want a cubic curve CC (d=3d=3) such that its strict transform C′C' is also a cubic (d′=3d'=3). Using the formula: 3=2(3)−m1−m2−m33 = 2(3) - m_1 - m_2 - m_3 3=6−(m1+m2+m3)3 = 6 - (m_1 + m_2 + m_3) m1+m2+m3=3m_1 + m_2 + m_3 = 3.

    This tells us we need a cubic curve that passes through the three base points (1:0:0),(0:1:0),(0:0:1)(1:0:0), (0:1:0), (0:0:1) with total multiplicity 3. The simplest way to achieve this is for the curve to pass through each base point with multiplicity 1 (m1=1,m2=1,m3=1m_1=1, m_2=1, m_3=1).

    Let's find such a cubic. A general cubic equation is F(x,y,z)=0F(x,y,z)=0. For the curve to pass through (1:0:0)(1:0:0), setting x=1,y=0,z=0x=1, y=0, z=0 must satisfy the equation. This implies the coefficient of x3x^3 must be zero. Similarly, the coefficients of y3y^3 and z3z^3 must be zero for it to pass through (0:1:0)(0:1:0) and (0:0:1)(0:0:1). So the cubic must be of the form: ax2y+bx2z+cy2x+dy2z+ez2x+fz2y+gxyz=0ax^2y + bx^2z + cy^2x + dy^2z + ez^2x + fz^2y + gxyz = 0.

    Now let's check the multiplicity at each point. At P1(1:0:0)P_1(1:0:0): Set x=1x=1. The equation becomes ay+bz+cy2+dy2z+ez2+fz2y+gyz=0ay + bz + cy^2 + dy^2z + ez^2 + fz^2y + gyz = 0. The lowest degree terms in y,zy,z are ay+bzay+bz. For the multiplicity to be 1, (a,b)(a,b) cannot be (0,0)(0,0). At P2(0:1:0)P_2(0:1:0): Set y=1y=1. The equation becomes ax2+bx2z+cx+dz+ez2x+fz2+gxz=0ax^2 + bx^2z + cx + dz + ez^2x + fz^2 + gxz = 0. The lowest degree terms in x,zx,z are cx+dzcx+dz. For the multiplicity to be 1, (c,d)(c,d) cannot be (0,0)(0,0). At P3(0:0:1)P_3(0:0:1): Set z=1z=1. The equation becomes ax2y+bx2+cy2x+dy2+ex+fy+gxy=0ax^2y + bx^2 + cy^2x + dy^2 + ex + fy + gxy = 0. The lowest degree terms in x,yx,y are ex+fyex+fy. For the multiplicity to be 1, (e,f)(e,f) cannot be (0,0)(0,0).

    A simple example of such a cubic, where m1=m2=m3=1m_1=m_2=m_3=1, is the cubic: C:x2y+y2z+z2x=0C: x^2y + y^2z + z^2x = 0. Let's check the multiplicities: P1(1:0:0)P_1(1:0:0): Set x=1x=1. y+y2z+z2=0y + y^2z + z^2 = 0. Lowest degree term is yy. Multiplicity m1=1m_1=1. P2(0:1:0)P_2(0:1:0): Set y=1y=1. x2+z+z2x=0x^2 + z + z^2x = 0. Lowest degree term is zz. Multiplicity m2=1m_2=1. P3(0:0:1)P_3(0:0:1): Set z=1z=1. x2y+y2+x=0x^2y + y^2 + x = 0. Lowest degree term is xx. Multiplicity m3=1m_3=1. So m1+m2+m3=1+1+1=3m_1+m_2+m_3 = 1+1+1=3.

    Computing the Image Curve:

    Now we compute the equation of the strict transform C′C' under T(x:y:z)=(u:v:w)=(yz:xz:xy)T(x:y:z)=(u:v:w) = (yz:xz:xy). We substitute the inverse map x=vw,y=uw,z=uvx=vw, y=uw, z=uv into the equation of CC: x2y+y2z+z2x=0x^2y + y^2z + z^2x = 0 (vw)2(uw)+(uw)2(uv)+(uv)2(vw)=0(vw)^2(uw) + (uw)^2(uv) + (uv)^2(vw) = 0 v2w2(uw)+u2w2(uv)+u2v2(vw)=0v^2w^2(uw) + u^2w^2(uv) + u^2v^2(vw) = 0 uv2w3+u3vw2+u2v3w=0uv^2w^3 + u^3vw^2 + u^2v^3w = 0

    This is a homogeneous equation of degree 6 in u,v,wu,v,w. Since we are in projective space, we can divide by any common factors. The common factor is uvwuvw: uvw(vw2+u2w+uv2)=0uvw (vw^2 + u^2w + uv^2) = 0

    This equation represents the total transform of CC. It consists of two parts:

    1. uvw=0uvw = 0: This corresponds to the three lines u=0,v=0,w=0u=0, v=0, w=0. These are precisely the images of the base points P1,P2,P3P_1, P_2, P_3 under the transformation TT. These are the exceptional curves.
    2. vw2+u2w+uv2=0vw^2 + u^2w + uv^2 = 0: This is the equation of the strict transform C′C' of the curve CC.

    The equation for C′C' is uv2+uw2+vw2=0uv^2 + uw^2 + vw^2 = 0 (rearranging terms). Let's check the degree of this equation in u,v,wu,v,w: uv2uv^2: degree 1+2=31+2=3 uw2uw^2: degree 1+2=31+2=3 vw2vw^2: degree 1+2=31+2=3 All terms have degree 3. So C′C' is a cubic curve.

    Conclusion:

    The standard quadratic transformation T(x:y:z)=(yz:xz:xy)T(x:y:z) = (yz:xz:xy) maps the cubic curve CC defined by x2y+y2z+z2x=0x^2y + y^2z + z^2x = 0 to the cubic curve C′C' defined by uv2+uw2+vw2=0uv^2 + uw^2 + vw^2 = 0.

    This provides a concrete example of a Cremona transformation mapping a cubic equation to a cubic equation.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.