Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

When a surface is too hot, say over 40C under sunlight, does it repels (even mildly)…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with DeepSeekdeepseek-v3-0324’s answer.
  1. User

    When a surface is too hot, say over 40C under sunlight, does it repels (even mildly) flying insects? (wasps, flies and what not) Or is it attractive for them?

  2. Qwen Assistant

    When considering whether surfaces exceeding 40°C under sunlight repel or attract flying insects like wasps and flies, several factors come into play, rooted in their ectothermic physiology and behavioral adaptations:

    1. Thermal Sensitivity and Avoidance:
      Insects are ectothermic, relying on external heat sources to regulate body temperature. However, extreme temperatures can be harmful. Most common insects (e.g., houseflies, wasps) thrive in moderate ranges (20–35°C). At 40°C, many species may avoid surfaces to prevent overheating, desiccation, or tissue damage. Studies suggest that some insects detect and avoid thermal extremes through sensory neurons, though sensitivity varies by species.

    2. Behavioral Thermoregulation:

      • Basking vs. Avoidance: While some insects bask on warm surfaces to raise their body temperature, this occurs within tolerable limits. Exceeding their upper thermal threshold (often near 40°C) triggers avoidance. For example, blowflies may leave surfaces above 38°C to prevent heat stress.
      • Desert Adaptations: Insects in arid regions (e.g., desert ants) tolerate higher temperatures, but common temperate species like wasps or houseflies likely avoid prolonged contact with such hot surfaces.
    3. Species-Specific Responses:

      • Wasps: Active in warm weather, they may not actively seek out 40°C surfaces but could land briefly if distracted by food or other attractants. Prolonged exposure might drive them away.
      • Flies: Houseflies and blowflies may avoid surfaces exceeding their thermal comfort zone. However, if a hot surface is associated with food or moisture, they might tolerate it temporarily.
      • Mosquitoes: Attracted to body heat (~37°C), but 40°C may deter them, as it exceeds their host-seeking cues.
    4. Color and Light Interaction:
      Surfaces heated by sunlight are often dark-colored, which can attract insects like flies (drawn to dark hues). However, if heat overrides visual preferences, they may avoid landing. For instance, dark asphalt might attract them initially, but extreme heat could deter settling.

    5. Moisture and Resources:
      Hot surfaces are typically dry, which may repel insects seeking water. Conversely, if food or moisture is present (e.g., sugary residue), attraction might outweigh heat avoidance.

    6. Thermal Radiation Detection:
      Some insects sense infrared radiation. A 40°C surface emits more infrared, potentially acting as a deterrent. Upon contact, rapid withdrawal may occur if the surface feels harmful.

    Conclusion:
    At 40°C, most common flying insects (wasps, flies) are likely mildly repelled due to the risk of overheating, especially if alternative cooler surfaces or resources exist nearby. However, responses vary by species, context (e.g., availability of food/water), and environmental factors (e.g., shade alternatives). While heat alone may deter them, other stimuli (color, scent) can override thermal avoidance. Thus, hot surfaces under sunlight may reduce insect presence but are unlikely to serve as a strong repellent in isolation.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.