Imagine a scenario where the close friend of a person who is possibly suicidal is on the…
- User
Imagine a scenario where the close friend of a person who is possibly suicidal is on the phone with the person who is possibly suicidal, and must hang up to call and ensure that their close friend gets help tells the friend who is possibly suicidal, "If I hang up and you kill yourself before help arives I'll spend the rest of my life hating myself for hanging up". Is this an appropriate and/or effective tactic to temporarily prevent the possibly suicidal friend from committing suicide until help arrives? Why or why not? If not give a possible alternative.
Assistant
This is a complex and highly charged emotional situation. Let's break down the statement: "If I hang up and you kill yourself before help arrives, I'll spend the rest of my life hating myself for hanging up."
Is it appropriate?
- Understandable, but not ideal: From the friend's perspective, this statement comes from a place of desperation, fear, and a profound desire to keep their friend alive. It's an expression of their own anticipated pain and guilt.
- Potentially harmful: It places a heavy burden of responsibility on the suicidal person for the future emotional well-being of their friend. Someone in a suicidal crisis is already overwhelmed by their own pain and may feel like a burden; this statement can inadvertently amplify that feeling ("Now my friend's lifelong happiness depends on me not dying in the next few minutes"). It can be perceived as emotional blackmail, even if not intended that way.
Is it effective?
- Possibly, in the very short term, for some: For a person who still has strong empathetic connections and is concerned about harming their loved ones, this statement might cause them to pause. It leverages their care for the friend.
- High risk of backfiring:
- If the suicidal person is in a state of extreme hopelessness, nihilism, or feels completely disconnected, they might not care about the friend's future guilt, or might even see it as another reason why they are "bad" or "toxic."
- It could increase their sense of being a burden, potentially pushing them further towards suicide ("See, I even ruin my friend's life by existing").
- It focuses on the friend's pain, not the suicidal person's pain, which can make the suicidal person feel unheard or like their suffering is being minimized in comparison to the friend's potential future guilt.
Why it's generally not recommended:
- Adds to the Burden: Suicidal individuals often feel like a burden. This statement explicitly makes them responsible for their friend's future emotional state, which is an enormous weight.
- Manipulative Undertones: Even if well-intentioned, it can feel like a guilt trip or emotional manipulation.
- Focuses on the Wrong Person: The immediate crisis is the suicidal person's intense pain and desire to end it. The conversation should ideally focus on their pain and getting them help, rather than the helper's potential future feelings.
- Unpredictable Outcome: The reaction of a person in a deep suicidal crisis is highly unpredictable. What one person might interpret as a plea of love, another might interpret as a burden.
Possible Alternatives (while needing to hang up to get help):
The goal is to convey urgency, care, and a concrete plan of action without adding an emotional burden to the suicidal person.
-
Be Direct, Calm, and Reassuring (if possible):
- "Okay, [Friend's Name], I'm hearing how much pain you're in, and I'm really worried about you. I care about you so much. I need to get you help right now. I'm going to hang up for literally one minute to call [emergency services/crisis team] to come to you. Please, please stay on the line with me until they arrive, or if we get cut off, promise me you'll wait. I'm doing this because I want you to be safe."
- "I'm taking this very seriously. I need to make a quick call to get support to you immediately. Stay with me. I'm not leaving you, I'm getting you help. Can you promise me you'll wait for that help?"
-
If you can, don't hang up:
- "I'm going to get help for you right now. Stay on the phone with me." Then, use another phone to call emergency services, or ask someone else nearby to call. If you only have one phone, put them on speaker: "I'm putting you on speaker for a moment so I can call [emergency services] while we're still talking."
-
Focus on their survival for them:
- "I want you to live. There is help available, and I'm going to get it for you now. I need to make a call to do that. Please wait for me/them."
Key principles for the alternative:
- Validate their feelings: "I hear you're in a lot of pain."
- Express your care directly: "I care about you."
- State your intention clearly: "I am going to call for help now."
- Be specific about the action: "I'm calling [911/emergency services/crisis line]."
- Ask for their cooperation for a short, defined period: "Can you wait while I do this? Can you promise to stay safe until they arrive?"
- Reassure them you're doing it for them: "I'm doing this because I want you to be safe and get through this."
Crucial Next Step: Regardless of what is said, the friend must immediately call emergency services (e.g., 911, 999, or the local equivalent) or a crisis response team, provide the suicidal person's location, and explain the situation.
In summary, while the statement about self-hatred is an understandable human reaction in a moment of extreme stress, it's generally not the most appropriate or reliably effective tactic because it can inadvertently add to the suicidal person's burden. Clear, caring, action-oriented statements are preferred.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.