Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
DeepSeekdeepseek-r1-0528· DeepSeekHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Why does an M1 Macbook laptop screen flicker at a relatively low and seemingly variable…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-5-haiku-20241022’s answer.
  1. User

    Why does an M1 Macbook laptop screen flicker at a relatively low and seemingly variable refresh rate while externally attached monitors do not exhibit the same behavior?

  2. DeepSeek Assistant

    The flickering you're observing on your M1 MacBook's built-in display (but not on external monitors) is very likely caused by Apple's ProMotion technology combined with individual visual sensitivity and environmental factors. Here's why:

    1. ProMotion & Variable Refresh Rate (VRR):

      • M1 MacBook Pro (and later) internal displays feature ProMotion, which dynamically adjusts the screen's refresh rate between 24Hz and 120Hz based on content and activity.
      • Goal: Save power (lower Hz when static) and provide smoothness (higher Hz when scrolling/gaming).
      • How it causes perceived flicker:
        • Low Refresh Rate Perception: When the display drops to very low rates (e.g., 24Hz, 30Hz, 40Hz) during inactivity or slow movement, some individuals are highly sensitive to the inherent flicker of low refresh rates. This is physiological.
        • Rate Switching: The transition between refresh rates can sometimes be momentarily perceptible as a subtle flicker or stutter.
        • Inconsistent Frame Pacing: Imperfect implementation or specific content might cause slight inconsistencies in how frames are delivered at lower variable rates, making flicker more noticeable.
    2. External Monitors Don't Have ProMotion (Usually):

      • Most external monitors operate at a fixed refresh rate (e.g., 60Hz, 75Hz, 120Hz, 144Hz).
      • Stable Flicker Perception: A fixed 60Hz refresh rate, while still technically flickering, is generally high enough and consistent enough that the vast majority of people perceive it as perfectly stable. Higher fixed rates (120Hz+) are even smoother.
      • No Variable Switching: Since the rate doesn't change dynamically, there's no transition flicker/stutter.
    3. Individual Sensitivity & Environmental Factors:

      • Visual Sensitivity: People vary greatly in their sensitivity to flicker. Some perceive low VRR flicker acutely, while others don't notice it at all. Peripheral vision is often more sensitive.
      • Ambient Lighting: Fluorescent lights (especially older magnetic ballasts) and some dimmed LEDs flicker themselves. This ambient flicker can interact with the screen's refresh rate, causing a more pronounced "beat frequency" flicker effect that's unique to the internal display's variable rate. External monitors with a fixed rate might not interact as noticeably with the same lights.
      • Brightness Level: Perceived flicker can sometimes be more noticeable at lower screen brightness levels.

    Why it's "Seemingly Variable":

    • The refresh rate is constantly varying based on what you're doing (moving the mouse, scrolling, watching video, idle).
    • The perception of flicker depends on the current refresh rate and the factors above (sensitivity, lighting). When the rate is higher (e.g., 90Hz+), flicker is usually imperceptible. When it drops low, it becomes noticeable.

    Addressing the Issue (Mitigations, Not Always Fixes):

    1. Check for macOS Updates: Apple continuously refines ProMotion behavior.
    2. Adjust Brightness: Try increasing the screen brightness.
    3. Change Ambient Lighting:
      • Use natural light if possible.
      • Avoid fluorescent lights. Switch to high-quality LED bulbs (look for "flicker-free" specs).
      • If using dimmable LEDs, ensure they are dimmed using PWM-free methods or set them to full brightness.
    4. Accessibility Settings (Workaround):
      • Go to System Settings > Accessibility > Display.
      • Enable "Limit frame rate". This caps the internal display at 60Hz. While you lose ProMotion's benefits (smoothness and some power savings), the consistent 60Hz often eliminates the perceived flicker for sensitive users. This is the most effective software solution.
    5. Temporarily Disconnect External Monitors: Rarely, specific external monitor configurations/software might subtly interfere with the internal display's power management or timing. Test with the external display unplugged.
    6. Reset SMC/PRAM (Less likely on Apple Silicon, but a standard step): On Apple Silicon Macs, this involves shutting down, waiting 30 seconds, then restarting. It clears low-level settings.

    In summary: The flicker is primarily an interaction between the inherent nature of low/variable refresh rates (ProMotion) and human visual perception, exacerbated by certain lighting. External monitors, using fixed (and often higher) refresh rates, lack this specific variable behavior, making them appear stable in comparison. Using the "Limit frame rate" accessibility setting is often the most practical solution if the flicker is bothersome.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.