Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwq-32b· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Propose a card game loosely based on magic the gathering, but simplified & with the same…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219-thinking-32k’s answer.
  1. User

    Propose a card game loosely based on magic the gathering, but simplified & with the same or more strategic depth. Instead of deckbuilding, we shoul implement an alterntive approach, such as "grab an go" approach, where players choose premade decks (20 cards?) out of a pool of "factions" and shuffle them together (2 to 3?).

    • There should be something akin to a Commander. Depending on the colors of factions they chose, they will select one commander of those color identities ( out of a pool of commanders)
    • Card placement should matter

    This is just my idea, feel free to chime in and propose your own.

  2. Qwen Assistant

    **Game Title: Faction Command
    Objective: Reduce your opponent’s Commander’s health to 0 by strategically deploying cards across zones, leveraging faction synergies, and triggering powerful commander abilities.


    Core Mechanics

    1. Factions & Decks

    • Factions: Five factions, each with a color identity, unique theme, and 20-card deck (including their commander).
      • Example Factions:
        • Ironclad Legion (Red): Frontline attackers with aggression and burst damage.
        • Arcane Syndicate (Blue): Spells and Rear support for mana and card draw.
        • Verdant Keep (Green): Growth mechanics and defensive Rear cards.
        • Shadow Covenant (Black): Sneaky creatures and life manipulation.
        • Celestial Order (White): Healer units and commander buffs.
    • Deckbuilding: Players choose 2-3 factions, combine their 20-card decks (total 40–60 cards), and select a commander from their chosen factions.
    • Color Identity: The commander must match the combined colors of your factions (e.g., picking Red and Blue lets you choose a Red, Blue, or Red-Blue commander).

    2. Commander

    • Health: 25.
    • Abilities:
      • Static Ability: A passive effect tied to the faction’s theme (e.g., "Frontline creatures you control get +1 power").
      • Ultimate Ability: A game-ending or game-changing effect (e.g., "Spend 3 mana and 5 loyalty counters to deal 10 damage to a target").
    • Loyalty Counters: Earn 1 counter each time you deal combat damage to the opponent (either to their commander or life total).

    3. Zones & Card Placement

    • Frontline: Cards here can attack and block. They gain offensive bonuses (e.g., Ironclad Legion’s +1 power).
    • Rear: Cards here provide support, generate mana, or have defensive abilities (e.g., Arcane Syndicate’s "Draw a card when a Rear creature enters").
    • Resource Zone: Optional zone for mana-generating cards (e.g., Verdant Keep’s "Tap for 1 green mana").

    4. Turn Structure

    1. Draw Phase: Draw 1 card.
    2. Action Phase:
      • Play up to 3 actions:
        • Play a card from hand into Frontline or Rear.
        • Move a card between zones.
        • Activate a card’s ability (costs may involve loyalty counters, mana, or cards).
    3. Combat Phase:
      • Attack with Frontline creatures. Choose to damage the opponent’s commander or their life total.
      • Opponent blocks with their Frontline creatures.
    4. End Phase: Discard down to hand limit (7 cards).

    5. Victory Conditions

    • Reduce your opponent’s Commander to 0 health.
    • Alternatively, achieve a faction-specific goal (e.g., "Gather 10 loyalty counters" or "Play 5 spells from the Rear").

    Example Cards

    Ironclad Legion (Red)

    • Frontline Champion (Red): 3/3. When attacking, deal 1 damage to the opponent’s commander.
    • Pyro Barrage (Red): Deal 2 damage to a Rear creature. Discard a card.

    Arcane Syndicate (Blue)

    • Mana Siphon (Blue): Rear. Tap: Draw a card.
    • Mirror Image (Blue): Create a copy of a Frontline creature. It can’t attack this turn.

    Verdant Keep (Green)

    • Growth Spire (Green): Rear. When tapped, put a +1/+1 counter on a Frontline creature.
    • Rootwalla (Green): 2/2. When this enters the Rear, draw a card.

    Strategic Depth

    • Synergy: Combine factions for combos (e.g., Green’s growth with Red’s attackers).
    • Positioning: Decide whether to prioritize Frontline offense or Rear support.
    • Commander Management: Balance earning loyalty counters for the ultimate vs. dealing direct damage.
    • Resource Control: Manage mana and loyalty counters to activate abilities at optimal times.

    Simplified Rules for Playtesting

    • Deck Size: Start with 15 cards per faction (total 30–45 cards) for simplicity.
    • Commander Health: Reduce to 20.
    • Ultimate Cost: Lower to 2 mana and 3 counters.

    This framework balances simplicity with strategic choices, encouraging players to think about faction synergies, commander abilities, and battlefield positioning. Players can experiment with different faction combinations to find unique strategies!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.