Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Now when doing identity verification for prolific, they use onfido, what does onfido…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-opus-4-20250514’s answer.
  1. User

    Now when doing identity verification for prolific, they use onfido, what does onfido check to either decline or verify

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Excellent question. Understanding the identity verification process can be confusing, so let's break down what Onfido checks for Prolific to either verify or decline a user.

    The primary goal for Prolific is to ensure that every user is a real, unique individual who is who they claim to be. This prevents fraud, duplicate accounts, and ensures the integrity of the research data collected on the platform. Onfido is the specialized third-party service they use to automate this process.

    Onfido's verification process is typically broken down into two main components: Document Verification and Biometric Verification.


    1. Document Verification

    This is the first major step. You are asked to submit a photo of a government-issued identity document (like a passport, driver's license, or national ID card).

    Here’s what Onfido's technology checks on the document:

    • Authenticity: Is this a genuine document? The AI looks for security features specific to that document type and country, such as:
      • Holograms, watermarks, and microprint.
      • Correct fonts, layout, and character spacing.
      • The Machine-Readable Zone (MRZ) at the bottom of a passport or ID card is checked to ensure its checksums are valid.
    • Tampering: Has the document been digitally or physically altered? The system looks for:
      • Signs of photo substitution (e.g., a picture placed over the original).
      • Inconsistencies in fonts or text alignment, suggesting data has been changed.
      • Pixel-level analysis to detect signs of digital manipulation in the image file.
    • Validity: Is the document still legally valid?
      • It checks the expiration date. An expired ID is one of the most common reasons for an automatic decline.
    • Data Extraction: The system reads the information from the document, such as your full name, date of birth, and document number.

    2. Biometric Verification (The Selfie/Video Check)

    This step confirms that the person submitting the document is the legitimate owner and a real, live person. You'll be asked to take a selfie or a short video of your face.

    Here's what Onfido checks:

    • Liveness Detection: This is crucial for preventing fraud. The system needs to confirm you are physically present and not just holding up a photo or a screen. It checks for:
      • Natural movement (e.g., asking you to turn your head or follow a dot on the screen).
      • Subtle cues like blinking, facial muscle movements, and skin texture that are difficult to fake.
      • Analysis of light and reflection on your face to ensure it's a 3D object, not a 2D image.
    • Facial Similarity: Onfido's AI compares the biometric data from your selfie/video to the photograph on your identity document.
      • It maps key facial features (distance between eyes, shape of the nose, jawline) on both images.
      • It then generates a "similarity score." If the score is high enough, it passes. If it's too low, it's flagged for decline or manual review.

    Common Reasons for Being Declined

    Based on the checks above, here are the most frequent reasons a verification fails:

    1. Poor Image Quality:

      • Photos of the ID or your face are blurry, out of focus, or have a glare obscuring information.
      • Part of the document is cut off in the picture.
      • The environment is too dark.
    2. Document Issues:

      • The document is expired. This is an instant failure.
      • The document is not supported (e.g., using a student ID instead of a government-issued one).
      • The system suspects the document is fake, fraudulent, or tampered with.
    3. Biometric Mismatch or Failure:

      • The face in the selfie does not match the photo on the ID. This could be due to a significant change in appearance, poor lighting, or wearing items that obscure your face (like sunglasses or a hat).
      • Failed liveness test. The system suspects you are not a live person (e.g., using a photo of a photo) or you didn't follow the on-screen instructions correctly.
    4. Data Mismatch (Crucial for Prolific):

      • The name or date of birth on your ID does not exactly match the information you entered in your Prolific "About You" section. Even a small difference (e.g., "Mike" on Prolific vs. "Michael" on your ID) can cause a failure. Prolific requires this data to be identical.

    How to Ensure You Are Verified

    • Use a valid, in-date ID. Check the expiration date before you start.
    • Ensure your Prolific account details (name, DOB) perfectly match what's on your ID.
    • Take high-quality photos. Place your ID on a flat, dark surface in a well-lit room. Make sure there is no glare and all four corners are visible.
    • Follow the selfie/video instructions carefully. Find a spot with good, even lighting on your face. Remove any hats, sunglasses, or face coverings.
    • Don't try to cheat the system. Onfido's AI is specifically designed to catch fraud attempts.

    In summary, Onfido performs a comprehensive, automated check of your document's authenticity and your biometric identity to ensure for Prolific that you are a real, unique, and legitimate participant. A failure on any of these checks will lead to a decline.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.